Should the first spike be faded?
A common claim says that the initial news spike overshoots and reverses, so fading it is the high probability play. A simple scenario shows why it is not that tidy.
A trader fades a sharp upward spike in EURUSD after a weak US report, shorting at the top. The move reverses for twenty pips, and the trade works. The next month, the same setup sees the spike continue for eighty pips and the stop fills badly.
The difference is whether the news changed the underlying story or just caused a reflex. A small surprise with mixed details often produces a spike and a fade. A large surprise that moves rate expectations produces a repricing, and the market keeps going.
Tools that help are the size of the surprise relative to the forecast, the reaction in bond yields, and whether other pairs agree. If everything points the same way, fading is dangerous.
Fading works best in a market that has been range-bound with a minor surprise. It works worst in a market already trending, or on top-tier data with a big miss.
A rule that appeals to some: only fade a spike if the surprise was small, the yields did not move much, and the spike overshoots the previous range by a modest amount. Everything else is a repricing, and fighting a repricing is a good way to learn humility.
Another useful filter is the time of the first retracement. If price pulls back at least a third of the move within thirty seconds, the spike was probably a reflex. If it keeps going without a meaningful pullback for a minute, the move has legs.
Position size matters more than the fade-or-follow question. A small trade can afford to be wrong about the direction. A large one cannot, because the same slippage that makes the spike look tempting can also make the stop expensive.
What conditions make a news spike more likely to reverse in your experience?
Should the first spike be faded?
Should the first spike be faded?
It’s Fairman 
-
FXS London Scalper
- Posts: 976
- Joined: Sun Oct 18, 2026 12:25 pm
Re: Should the first spike be faded?
Fading the first spike works until the spike is the start of a trend. A strict stop beyond the spike high, sized for the widened spread, is essential for this approach.
FXS Official Team | London Session Desk
Re: Should the first spike be faded?
The useful distinction here is between a transient overshoot and a genuine repricing, but labels such as “small surprise” or “yields did not move much” need definitions before testing. Otherwise it is easy to call a spike a reflex after it reverses and a repricing after it continues. A retracement of one third within thirty seconds is also a testable rule, not evidence by itself that the move was only a reflex; the result can depend on the pair, spread, event type, and exact quote feed.
I would predefine the surprise measure, spike size relative to a fixed pre-event range or volatility measure, retracement window, and entry/exit rules. Then compare fade, continuation, and no-trade cases on the same events, including spread, slippage, missed fills, and the possibility that a stop beyond the spike executes worse than its trigger price. Related pairs or yields may add context, but they are not independent confirmation and can move on different timing. Keep position size fixed by the risk plan, and evaluate net results on a later sample rather than choosing the filter that best explains past reversals. If execution costs consume most of the plausible target, passing is a valid outcome too.
I would predefine the surprise measure, spike size relative to a fixed pre-event range or volatility measure, retracement window, and entry/exit rules. Then compare fade, continuation, and no-trade cases on the same events, including spread, slippage, missed fills, and the possibility that a stop beyond the spike executes worse than its trigger price. Related pairs or yields may add context, but they are not independent confirmation and can move on different timing. Keep position size fixed by the risk plan, and evaluate net results on a later sample rather than choosing the filter that best explains past reversals. If execution costs consume most of the plausible target, passing is a valid outcome too.
It’s Fairman 
-
Amanhasnoname
- Posts: 2060
- Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 9:45 am
Re: Should the first spike be faded?
I faded the first spike on a weak US print once and banked about eighteen pips when price snapped back. The next similar release the spike kept going, my stop sat beyond the high with a widened spread, and one ugly fill wiped the previous three fades. Same visual, different story.
What I watch now is whether yields and the other dollar pairs agree. If bonds barely move and the surprise is small, I may take a small fade with a hard stop past the spike extreme. If the miss is large and yields jump, I treat it as a repricing and stay flat or look for continuation after a pause.
Size matters more than the fade-or-follow debate. I keep those trades at half normal risk because stop slippage can be several pips in the first half minute. If price has not pulled back at least a third of the spike within roughly thirty seconds, I usually leave it alone.
What I watch now is whether yields and the other dollar pairs agree. If bonds barely move and the surprise is small, I may take a small fade with a hard stop past the spike extreme. If the miss is large and yields jump, I treat it as a repricing and stay flat or look for continuation after a pause.
Size matters more than the fade-or-follow debate. I keep those trades at half normal risk because stop slippage can be several pips in the first half minute. If price has not pulled back at least a third of the spike within roughly thirty seconds, I usually leave it alone.