Copy trading adds a delay that scalping cannot afford
A signal provider opens a trade. Subscribers are meant to get the same trade moments later. For a swing trade, a second or two does not matter. For a scalper targeting one or two pips, it can be the whole profit.
The delay comes from several places: the provider's order reaching the platform, the copying service detecting it, the order being sent to each follower's broker, and each broker filling it. Followers on slower or different brokers receive worse prices than the provider.
Spreads add another layer. The provider may have a raw spread account while followers pay a wider one, so the same trade costs more for them.
Results shown on the provider's page therefore overstate what followers receive. The gap grows with the number of followers, since a large batch of copied orders can itself move the price.
Anyone considering following a scalper should look for a history that includes followers' actual results, not just the provider's, and should start with small size to measure the difference.
A simple test is running a small live account in parallel with the signal and comparing the fills trade by trade. The gap shows exactly how much the copy process costs.
Has the follower's result ever differed sharply from the signal provider's?
Copy trading adds a delay that scalping cannot afford
-
FXS HongKong Scalper
- Posts: 543
- Joined: Sat Oct 24, 2026 10:15 pm
Re: Copy trading adds a delay that scalping cannot afford
This is why copy trading and scalping mostly don't mix. For anyone looking at a signal service, comparing the provider's trade results with the subscriber's actual fills over a month shows the real cost. If targets are one or two pips, the difference tends to eat most of the edge.
FXS Official Team | Hong Kong Session Desk
Re: Copy trading adds a delay that scalping cannot afford
The follower-versus-provider comparison is the right level of analysis, but I would look beyond a single monthly average. For each copied signal, record the provider’s timestamp and quoted entry, the follower’s signal-received and fill times, executable bid/ask, fill price, size, and exit. Then summarize the distribution of delay and implementation shortfall, including rejected or missed orders, not only successful fills. A few outliers can matter a lot when the planned target is small.
It is also important to compare like with like: account type, instrument, sizing method, commissions, and exit handling can all differ from the provider’s published track record. A follower’s outcome may diverge for reasons other than latency, so separate spread and fee costs from price movement during the delay. A small live test, if someone chooses to run one, should use a pre-set risk cap and enough observations to understand variability; it should not be treated as proof that future execution will match. If results are reported, a range and sample size alongside net returns would make the comparison more informative than a headline provider-versus-subscriber figure.
It is also important to compare like with like: account type, instrument, sizing method, commissions, and exit handling can all differ from the provider’s published track record. A follower’s outcome may diverge for reasons other than latency, so separate spread and fee costs from price movement during the delay. A small live test, if someone chooses to run one, should use a pre-set risk cap and enough observations to understand variability; it should not be treated as proof that future execution will match. If results are reported, a range and sample size alongside net returns would make the comparison more informative than a headline provider-versus-subscriber figure.
It’s Fairman 
-
Amanhasnoname
- Posts: 2060
- Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 9:45 am
Re: Copy trading adds a delay that scalping cannot afford
I followed a scalping signal for about two months a few years ago, and the difference between his page and my account was striking. His published stats showed roughly two hundred pips a month on targets of three to four pips. Over the same period my copied trades made a little over sixty, and I was trading the same instruments with the same broker type.
When I compared the trades one by one, the gap came almost entirely from entries. My fills were typically half a pip to a pip worse than his, and on the fast trades where he got out quickly with a small win, I sometimes got out at break-even or a small loss. A few signals never filled at all because the price had moved.
The provider wasn't dishonest, the copying process simply took the edge away. If I ever follow anyone again, it would only be someone holding trades for twenty pips or more, where a second of delay doesn't decide the outcome.
When I compared the trades one by one, the gap came almost entirely from entries. My fills were typically half a pip to a pip worse than his, and on the fast trades where he got out quickly with a small win, I sometimes got out at break-even or a small loss. A few signals never filled at all because the price had moved.
The provider wasn't dishonest, the copying process simply took the edge away. If I ever follow anyone again, it would only be someone holding trades for twenty pips or more, where a second of delay doesn't decide the outcome.