Tick volume spikes: confirmation or just noise?
A short test most traders never run: take a month of breakout trades, split them into those where tick volume spiked at the break and those where it did not, and compare the results.
Plenty of people expect the spike group to do much better. Often it does, but not by as much as the folklore says. The reason is that a spike in ticks happens for lots of reasons, including a spread widening, a platform lag, or a series of tiny orders that move nothing.
Where tick volume tends to help is in ruling out. A breakout with no visible increase in activity at all is usually a bad bet, because there is little participation behind it. A breakout with a surge is at least a candidate.
So the signal is more of a filter than a trigger. It removes the worst setups and leaves a pool that still needs other criteria.
The honest answer comes from the numbers, not the reputation. A simple spreadsheet will show whether tick volume adds anything to the system in use.
A quick method for the test: tag each breakout with the ratio of the tick count in the break bar to the average of the previous twenty bars. Then group by ratio buckets, such as under 1, 1 to 2, and over 2. If the results are flat across buckets, volume adds nothing. If they climb with the ratio, there is a useful filter hiding in the data.
There is one more caveat. Tick volume is sensitive to the broker's feed settings, so a threshold found on one broker may not transfer to another. Re-testing after any change of broker is the safe policy.
Does filtering by tick volume actually improve the stats?
Tick volume spikes: confirmation or just noise?
Tick volume spikes: confirmation or just noise?
It’s Fairman 
-
FXS London Scalper
- Posts: 979
- Joined: Sun Oct 18, 2026 12:25 pm
Re: Tick volume spikes: confirmation or just noise?
Splitting a month of breakout trades by whether tick volume spiked at the break is a simple, telling test. Many find little difference, which suggests the filter adds complexity without edge.
FXS Official Team | London Session Desk
Re: Tick volume spikes: confirmation or just noise?
One important caveat is that spot-FX “tick volume” is usually a count of quote updates in a particular feed, not a consolidated count of all market transactions. A spike can therefore reflect busier quoting, volatility, or a feed-specific change; it is not automatically evidence that broad participation confirmed the breakout. That makes the thread’s warning about spread widening and platform lag especially relevant.
For the spreadsheet test, I would define the spike ratio and buckets before looking at outcomes, and make sure the comparison is within the same pair, session, and breakout definition. Record spread, slippage, scheduled-news proximity, and whether the entry was actually executable, then compare net expectancy and drawdown—not just win rate. The denominator matters too: a month may contain very few breakouts in the highest bucket, so a dramatic average can be driven by a handful of trades. If tick activity appears useful, it would be worth checking whether it adds information beyond range expansion and spread, and then testing the fixed rule on later data. A filter that works only on one broker feed may be a local execution feature rather than a transferable market signal.
For the spreadsheet test, I would define the spike ratio and buckets before looking at outcomes, and make sure the comparison is within the same pair, session, and breakout definition. Record spread, slippage, scheduled-news proximity, and whether the entry was actually executable, then compare net expectancy and drawdown—not just win rate. The denominator matters too: a month may contain very few breakouts in the highest bucket, so a dramatic average can be driven by a handful of trades. If tick activity appears useful, it would be worth checking whether it adds information beyond range expansion and spread, and then testing the fixed rule on later data. A filter that works only on one broker feed may be a local execution feature rather than a transferable market signal.
It’s Fairman 
-
Amanhasnoname
- Posts: 2060
- Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 9:45 am
Re: Tick volume spikes: confirmation or just noise?
I ran almost exactly this test on about four months of EURUSD and GBPUSD range breakouts in the London session. I took the tick count of the breakout bar divided by the average of the previous twenty, and grouped the trades into three buckets. The low-ratio breakouts were clearly worse, with a negative expectancy after costs, but the difference between the medium and high buckets was small and inconsistent from month to month.
So for me it ended up as a filter to throw out the dead breakouts, not a trigger. I skip a break when the ratio is under one, and otherwise ignore it. That alone removed a fair number of losers without hurting the winners much.
The broker point matters too. When I moved accounts, the tick counts on the new feed ran noticeably higher in general, and my old threshold was letting almost everything through. I had to redo the buckets from scratch on the new data before the filter meant anything again.
So for me it ended up as a filter to throw out the dead breakouts, not a trigger. I skip a break when the ratio is under one, and otherwise ignore it. That alone removed a fair number of losers without hurting the winners much.
The broker point matters too. When I moved accounts, the tick counts on the new feed ran noticeably higher in general, and my old threshold was letting almost everything through. I had to redo the buckets from scratch on the new data before the filter meant anything again.