The small revenge trade
A big revenge trade is easy to spot and easy to condemn. The smaller version is sneakier. A two pip loss stings, and the next trade is taken a little quicker, a little looser, with a touch more size, to get back to even.
On a long timeframe, one revenge trade is a rare event. In scalping it can happen twenty times in a session, in forms so mild that none looks like a mistake.
The tell is timing. A trade taken within seconds of a loss, without waiting for a proper setup, is likely emotional. A trade whose entry condition would have been met anyway is fine, but one that was only half-satisfied is not.
Measuring the gap between the close of a loser and the next entry shows a lot. Plotting the results of trades by that gap often reveals that quick re-entries perform worse than the rest.
A simple rule such as a thirty second pause after any loss gives the mind time to reset. It does not need to be long. It only needs to exist.
A related pattern is the size creep after a loss, where the next trade is a little larger to recover faster. Plotting size against the result of the previous trade shows whether it is happening.
One effective fix is a hard cap on size per trade and a minimum wait after a loss. Both are simple, both are boring, and both outperform willpower at the moment of the sting.
Some traders go one step further and write the cooling-off rule on a card taped to the monitor. The card does the arguing when the mood is not up to it.
What do the results look like for trades taken immediately after a loss versus after a pause?
The small revenge trade
The small revenge trade
It’s Fairman 
-
FXS Prop Desk
- Posts: 1689
- Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am
Re: The small revenge trade
The small version is harder to catch because each instance looks defensible. One practical check is time between trades: if the gap after a loss is consistently shorter than the gap after a win, revenge is happening even when it does not feel like it. A forced two-minute pause after any losing trade costs nothing and breaks the pattern.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
Re: The small revenge trade
The time-gap comparison is a useful warning signal, but I would avoid treating every quick re-entry as revenge or assuming a fixed two-minute pause fits every setup. A scheduled scalp can legitimately qualify soon after a loss; the better test is whether the same entry conditions were present before the previous result was known. Recording the setup checklist as well as the gap helps distinguish that from loosening criteria to get back to even.
A practical guardrail could be: after a loss, keep size unchanged or smaller, and do not enter until the normal checklist is complete. If a cooling-off timer is used, make it a minimum reset rather than permission to trade as soon as it expires. In review, compare trades after losses with comparable trades after wins by pair, session, and setup type, and include costs and missed valid setups. That makes it possible to test whether the pause improves discipline without overfitting to one memorable session. The aim is not to eliminate all immediate trades, but to remove the ones that would not have passed the rules beforehand.
A practical guardrail could be: after a loss, keep size unchanged or smaller, and do not enter until the normal checklist is complete. If a cooling-off timer is used, make it a minimum reset rather than permission to trade as soon as it expires. In review, compare trades after losses with comparable trades after wins by pair, session, and setup type, and include costs and missed valid setups. That makes it possible to test whether the pause improves discipline without overfitting to one memorable session. The aim is not to eliminate all immediate trades, but to remove the ones that would not have passed the rules beforehand.
It’s Fairman 
-
Amanhasnoname
- Posts: 2060
- Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 9:45 am
Re: The small revenge trade
I measured the gap after every loser for six weeks and the chart was blunt. Trades entered within twenty seconds of a loss had an expectancy about three tenths of a pip worse than the rest of the book, and the average size on those was roughly fifteen percent larger. None of them felt like revenge at the time; each looked like "the level is still valid."
After that I hard-coded a ninety-second pause and froze size at the pre-loss amount. The next month the post-loss bucket lined up with the post-win bucket on both expectancy and size. I still get the urge, especially after a stupid scratch, but the timer does the arguing.
The useful distinction for me was checklist versus clock. If the setup was fully valid before the prior trade closed, waiting out the pause and taking it is fine. If I am only taking it because the last one hurt, the pause usually kills the impulse before the order ticket opens.
After that I hard-coded a ninety-second pause and froze size at the pre-loss amount. The next month the post-loss bucket lined up with the post-win bucket on both expectancy and size. I still get the urge, especially after a stupid scratch, but the timer does the arguing.
The useful distinction for me was checklist versus clock. If the setup was fully valid before the prior trade closed, waiting out the pause and taking it is fine. If I am only taking it because the last one hurt, the pause usually kills the impulse before the order ticket opens.