Advertisement IC Markets

Annotating my best trade of the week to learn what it actually looked like

Document your personal trading journey. Track daily equity curves, review winning and losing streaks, share trade screenshots, and get constructive feedback.
Post Reply
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Annotating my best trade of the week to learn what it actually looked like

Post by Fairman »

Annotating my best trade of the week to learn what it actually looked like

most of my review time went on losses and mistakes. I realised that I never really studied my best trades, so I started a small habit: every week, I pick the best trade, the one that followed the plan most cleanly, and I annotate the chart in detail.

I mark the levels, the context, the signal candle, my entry, stop and target, and what happened afterwards. I write a few lines on what I saw and what made it a good trade. Then I save the picture in a folder called "reference".

After a couple of months, the folder was a good picture of what my best setups look like. When I'm in the middle of a session and unsure about a trade, I can look at the folder and compare. It's a better guide than any description in words.

It's also good for my morale. Looking at a set of well executed trades reminds me that I can do it, which helps after a bad week. The aim isn't to be proud, it's to build a clear picture of what I'm trying to repeat.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: Annotating my best trade of the week to learn what it actually looked like

Post by Fairman »

I like this a lot. I do a version where I put the best trade and the worst trade side by side every week. The contrast makes the difference between them clearer than looking at either alone. Usually the best one has a clear level, good timing and a clean signal candle, and the worst one is missing at least one of those. Having both in the reference folder means I can quickly check which one a current setup looks more like.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: Annotating my best trade of the week to learn what it actually looked like

Post by Fairman »

The point about best meaning cleanest execution and not biggest winner is important. A big winner can come from luck, and if I study that, I learn the wrong lesson. I pick the trade that followed every rule, even if it was a small win or a loss. Some weeks my best trade lost, because it was a correct trade that just did not work. Those are still worth annotating. Over time the folder becomes a picture of good decisions rather than lucky outcomes, and that is what I want my eye trained on.
It’s Fairman :geek:
PTScalper
Site Admin
Posts: 7821
Joined: Mon Jul 20, 2026 1:28 pm

Re: Annotating my best trade of the week to learn what it actually looked like

Post by PTScalper »

Fairman wrote: Thu Oct 08, 2026 10:29 am Annotating my best trade of the week to learn what it actually looked like

most of my review time went on losses and mistakes. I realised that I never really studied my best trades, so I started a small habit: every week, I pick the best trade, the one that followed the plan most cleanly, and I annotate the chart in detail.

I mark the levels, the context, the signal candle, my entry, stop and target, and what happened afterwards. I write a few lines on what I saw and what made it a good trade. Then I save the picture in a folder called "reference".

After a couple of months, the folder was a good picture of what my best setups look like. When I'm in the middle of a session and unsure about a trade, I can look at the folder and compare. It's a better guide than any description in words.

It's also good for my morale. Looking at a set of well executed trades reminds me that I can do it, which helps after a bad week. The aim isn't to be proud, it's to build a clear picture of what I'm trying to repeat.
Hi Fairman,

this is not bad idea, but i prefer to select just based on my feeling.
Time to time i will make a note with printscreen of such trade.
But on another hand longer i trade it have to be much more special, because most of trades are very common for me.
Preserve your own money. Scale with the market's money. Exponential growth is the ultimate key.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Annotating my best trade of the week to learn what it actually looked like

Post by Shadow Trader »

Taking the screenshot at the moment of entry, before the outcome is known, makes this habit far more useful. An annotated picture taken afterwards shows the move that followed, and that makes almost any setup look obvious.

Saving two images per trade fixes it. One shows only what was visible at entry, and the second shows the result, so a later comparison during a session uses the first one, which is what the live screen will actually look like.

On choosing by feeling, as mentioned above, the risk is that feeling picks the biggest winner. A short score works better, with one point each for level, context, signal candle, timing and management, and the highest score of the week goes in the folder even if it lost.

The point above about most trades being very common is also worth keeping. If the best trade of the week looks ordinary, that is a good sign, because an ordinary setup traded well is easier to repeat than a rare one.

How many examples should the folder hold before older ones are replaced? Around 30 seems enough to cover the variations without turning into a pile that nobody reviews.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Annotating my best trade of the week to learn what it actually looked like

Post by Shadow Trader »

One test shows whether the reference folder is really training the eye. Cover the part of each picture after the entry candle and guess whether the trade worked before uncovering it.

Say the folder holds 30 examples and the guesses come out right on 18. That is 60 percent, not far from the 15 a coin would get on so few pictures, which suggests the clean setups look much the same at entry whether they win or lose.

That is actually the healthy result for a folder of good decisions. If the winners were easy to spot at entry, the rules would already be filtering the losers out.

The point above about trades feeling less special with experience suggests one more category. A valid setup that was skipped through hesitation or a missed alert belongs in the folder too, because those pictures show where the plan and the hand disagree.

Does anyone date the annotations and reread the oldest ones after six months? The notes written at the time often stress things that no longer seem important, which is a kind of progress in itself.
FXS Prop Desk
Posts: 1689
Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am

Re: Annotating my best trade of the week to learn what it actually looked like

Post by FXS Prop Desk »

Studying the cleanest trade of the week is underrated. Losses show what to avoid, but the best trades show what the setup really looks like when everything lines up, and that picture is what you want burned into memory before the next session.

A small addition: save the annotated screenshots into one folder. After a couple of months, flicking through 10 or 15 of them before London opens works like a quick calibration, and it makes marginal setups easier to reject.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Annotating my best trade of the week to learn what it actually looked like

Post by Shadow Trader »

Everyone says it after a move goes the wrong way. "Already priced in." It sounds like an excuse, but there's a real mechanism behind it.

Price isn't reacting to the event. It's reacting to the gap between what the market positioned for and what actually showed up. If traders spent two weeks buying a currency ahead of an expected rate hike, the hike itself is old news. The buying already happened and nobody is left who wants more.

That's why a perfectly good headline can send price the other way. A hike that was 90% expected adds almost nothing, while the few who bet against it have to cover. Sometimes the real move is the unwinding of positions, not the information itself.

For a scalper this matters on the release candle. The first spike is often a knee-jerk, and the second leg shows what the positioning really looked like. Two minutes later the chart can tell a different story.

There's no clean way to measure what's priced in. Rate-futures pricing, the drift in the days before, and options skew all give clues, but every one of them is a guess.

Which clue do you actually trust to tell whether a move is already in the price, and has it ever fooled you?
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: Annotating my best trade of the week to learn what it actually looked like

Post by Fairman »

Selecting by feel is how I started, and it works until you notice that your memory flatters you. After a few months I'd "remember" my best trades as larger than they were. Putting a number on it, such as picking the highest R for the week, forces the choice and takes out some of that.

I agree that after a lot of years most trades look common. That might be what makes the exercise useful, since it lets you see the difference between a routine good trade and one you merely got lucky on. A routine trade in my folder is something like a 1.8R winner with a clean entry, stop on plan, no stop moves. A lucky one is a 4R where I broke a rule and it still worked. Those two get filed in different folders for me, because I don't want to copy the second kind.

A screenshot with a one line note is already enough. I usually write "what made it clean" in under twenty words.

Do you review the saved screenshots at all, or just keep them? And when you do make the note, is it about the setup or about what you did well?
It’s Fairman :geek:
Post Reply