The almost fill
Price touches the limit order's level, retreats a tenth of a pip short, and runs away without filling the order. The trade would have been a winner. Instead there is nothing.
This near miss is a source of outsized frustration. The next time, the trader moves the limit closer to the market to make sure it fills. Then it fills too easily, in poor conditions, and loses.
Chasing the fill is a pattern. Each almost-fill pushes the entry rule slightly toward the market until the original edge is gone.
The way out is statistical. Track the fill rate of limit orders at a given distance from the market and the outcome of those that fill. If the strategy's edge relies on the entry level, moving it is a change in strategy, not a tweak.
A modest improvement is to decide the entry offset in advance, test it across many trades, and leave it alone.
How many times in the last month was an entry level adjusted after a near miss, and did the adjustments help?
The almost fill
The almost fill
It’s Fairman 
Re: The almost fill
An almost fill happens when price comes within a fraction of a pip of a limit order or take profit and then reverses without triggering it. It is one of the more frustrating experiences in trading, since the trade would have been successful if the level had been set slightly differently. It also reflects how orders work: a buy limit fills only when the ask reaches the level, and a sell limit only when the bid reaches it. If the chart shows bid prices and the order is a buy limit, the bid touching the level does not mean the ask did. Turning on the ask line in the chart settings often explains why an order did not fill despite the candle seeming to touch it.
It’s Fairman 
-
Amanhasnoname
- Posts: 2060
- Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 9:45 am
Re: The almost fill
I used to do exactly this, and my own numbers embarrassed me. For one month I logged every limit order that missed by under half a pip, and it was about one in seven. I had been nudging my entries closer after each miss, and by the end my average entry was nearly a pip worse than the original plan.
What fixed it was settling the offset once, then leaving it alone for fifty trades. I also turned on the ask line on my chart, because a few of my so-called near misses were simply the bid touching a buy limit, which never fills on the ask. That explained about a third of them.
When I compared the filled trades with the missed ones, the ones that filled at the original level had a better win rate than the chased fills. The missed winners hurt in the moment, but the tracking showed they were not costing me the edge I thought they were.
What fixed it was settling the offset once, then leaving it alone for fifty trades. I also turned on the ask line on my chart, because a few of my so-called near misses were simply the bid touching a buy limit, which never fills on the ask. That explained about a third of them.
When I compared the filled trades with the missed ones, the ones that filled at the original level had a better win rate than the chased fills. The missed winners hurt in the moment, but the tracking showed they were not costing me the edge I thought they were.