Advertisement IC Markets

Case Study, Diego: Four Quiet Months and One Loud One

Document your personal trading journey. Track daily equity curves, review winning and losing streaks, share trade screenshots, and get constructive feedback.
Post Reply
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Case Study, Diego: Four Quiet Months and One Loud One

Post by Fairman »

Case Study, Diego: Four Quiet Months and One Loud One

Diego is a composite character. He runs a carry trade, long a high-yielding currency against a low-yielding one, with a 10,000-dollar position size relative to a 20,000-dollar account. The pair paid positive swap, and his account grew 0.6 percent a month for four months. In the fifth month, a risk-off shock cut the pair by 9 percent in a week.

Compute the effect. Four months at plus 0.6 percent: 1.006 to the 4th power is 1.0242, so the account reached about 20,484 dollars. A 9 percent fall on a 10,000-dollar position is 900 dollars, a 4.4 percent loss on the account at that point. The account fell to about 19,584.

Net after five months: 19,584 against 20,000, minus 2.1 percent. Four months of carry were erased by one week.

How should he have thought about it? The carry earned 120 dollars a month on 20,000, while the position's monthly volatility was perhaps 3 percent of 10,000, which is 300 dollars. He was collecting a small, steady premium for bearing a risk several times larger.

What if the position had been 20,000 dollars, matching the account, with the same percentage drop? The loss would be 1,800 dollars, 9 percent. Carry would be 240 a month.

What protects you? Smaller size, a stop loss, a volatility filter that exits when risk-off signals appear, and diversification across pairs. The first of these matters most.

Lesson: the smoother the income, the more carefully you should study the tail.

Exercise: compute the ratio of monthly carry to a one-standard-deviation monthly move for any carry position you consider.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Case Study, Diego: Four Quiet Months and One Loud One

Post by Shadow Trader »

A requote and slippage get lumped together as bad fills, but they hand the decision to different people. With a requote the broker comes back and says the price asked for is gone, here is a new one, take it or leave it. The choice stays with the trader, so the cost is time and sometimes the trade itself. With slippage the order was already committed, and the market decides the price on arrival.

For a scalper that difference matters more than the labels suggest. A declined requote costs nothing except the entry, which makes it a missed trade, not a lost one. Slippage on a ten pip target is paid in full whether anyone wanted it or not, and on a tight scalp it can erase a meaningful chunk of the expected edge in a single fill.

The funny part is that accounts which remove requotes usually do it by switching to market execution, which is exactly where slippage lives. The cost did not disappear. It moved from a visible prompt to a quiet number in the fill price.

Calling one of them better misses the point. What matters is which one a strategy can tolerate, since a trade that depends on a precise entry fares differently from one that rides a wider move.

Do you prefer a setup that can requote, or one that always fills and lets the price land where it lands?
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: Case Study, Diego: Four Quiet Months and One Loud One

Post by Fairman »

The calculation shows the classic carry trade profile clearly. A steady 120 dollars a month over four months adds about 484 dollars, and one bad week takes away 900. The monthly volatility estimate of around 300 dollars on the position means a 900 dollar move is about three times a typical month's swing, which is unusual but not rare for carry currencies during risk off periods. Historically, high yielding currencies have often fallen sharply when investors cut risk, sometimes erasing months or years of interest income in days. Diego's experience is a small version of a pattern that has played out many times in the market.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Amanhasnoname
Posts: 2060
Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 9:45 am

Re: Case Study, Diego: Four Quiet Months and One Loud One

Post by Amanhasnoname »

Diego's story reminds me of a stretch I had trading a high-yield pair purely for the swap. For about five months I collected a few dollars a day on a position that I'd sized to a quarter of my account, and I started to think of it as a salary. Then one risk-off Thursday the pair dropped around 250 pips, and I gave back nearly all of it in a few hours.

The ratio you suggest is what I now calculate before any carry position. I take the monthly carry and divide it by one standard deviation of the monthly move, and if the answer is below about 0.5 I treat the position as a speculative bet with a bonus, not as income. Mine at the time was closer to 0.3, which I only saw after the fact.

What helped most was a hard stop placed where I'd already decided the risk-off scenario had begun, and a size that let me survive the stop being hit twice in a row.
Post Reply