Monthly check: planned trades vs taken trades
Every month I compare two numbers: how many valid setups appeared according to my rules, and how many I actually traded. It sounds basic, but it shows a lot.
To do this you need to log setups whether or not you take them, ideally with a screenshot. At the end of the month, you have a list of everything that met your criteria and can compare it with your trade log.
If you took far fewer trades than the setups that appeared, you may be hesitating, missing them because you weren't watching, or filtering more than your rules say. If you took more trades than valid setups, some of your trades didn't meet your rules.
The next step is to compare results. What would the missed setups have done if you'd taken them? If they would have been profitable on balance, your hesitation is costing you. If they would have lost, maybe your instinct to skip them is picking up on something your rules don't capture, which is worth investigating.
It's also a good reality check on the strategy. If you take all valid setups and the results over time look different from your backtest, that's information too.
It takes discipline to log the skipped setups, but it's one of the most useful things I've added to my review.
Does anyone else track this?
Monthly check: planned trades vs taken trades
Monthly check: planned trades vs taken trades
It’s Fairman 
Re: Monthly check: planned trades vs taken trades
A practical challenge is that you can't watch every setup during a session, especially if you trade several pairs. One way to handle that is to do a quick end-of-session scan of the charts for setups you might have missed, using the same rules. It's not perfect, since hindsight can creep in, but taking a screenshot at the setup's trigger point and judging it only on what was visible then helps. Marking which ones you saw live and which you found later is useful too. Be strict that the found later ones don't get counted as setups you'd have taken live, since hindsight makes everything look clearer.
It’s Fairman 
Re: Monthly check: planned trades vs taken trades
I'd also keep in mind that some setups get skipped for valid reasons not written in the rules, like an upcoming news release or a spread that's wider than usual. If those reasons come up repeatedly, add them to the rules so the comparison is fair. Otherwise the gap between planned and taken trades looks like hesitation when it's actually good judgement that just hasn't been written down yet. Writing it down also makes it easier to test whether those reasons actually help. Over time those notes often turn into the most useful rules in the whole plan.
It’s Fairman 
Re: Monthly check: planned trades vs taken trades
One thing that makes this check easier is a short list of what counts as a planned setup, written so specifically that you can scan a chart at the end of the day and tick them off. If the definition is vague, you'll find yourself arguing about whether a pattern counted, and the comparison stops being objective. Screenshots of a few textbook examples next to the definitions help a lot. The tighter the definition, the more honest the monthly numbers become, and the easier it is to see whether you skip trades out of fear or because they genuinely didn't fit.
It’s Fairman 
-
FXS Prop Desk
- Posts: 1689
- Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am
Re: Monthly check: planned trades vs taken trades
Comparing planned and taken trades shows a lot about discipline. A big gap means many valid setups are being skipped, often because of hesitation after losses.
The result of the skipped setups is also useful. If they would have been profitable, it shows that the rules work and that the problem is execution. If they would have lost, it may mean the trader has good instincts, and the rules need to be updated.
The result of the skipped setups is also useful. If they would have been profitable, it shows that the rules work and that the problem is execution. If they would have lost, it may mean the trader has good instincts, and the rules need to be updated.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
Re: Monthly check: planned trades vs taken trades
I'd also compare the skipped trades with the taken ones. If the setups you skipped would have done better than the ones you took, your filtering in the moment is making things worse. If they'd have done worse, your instincts might be catching something the rules don't describe, and that's a hint to write it into the rules. Either way, the comparison turns a vague feeling about missed trades into something concrete. It only needs a column in the journal marking each setup as taken or skipped, and a few minutes at the end of the month to add them up.
It’s Fairman 