Second test of the London high: why I'd rather trade the retest than the first touch
When price runs into a level for the first time, everyone is watching it. Breakout traders are waiting to buy above, faders are waiting to sell into it, and stops are sitting just beyond. The first touch is noisy because all of that gets triggered at once, and the candle that results often tells you very little.
The second test is different. By then you've seen how price behaved on the first touch. Did it reject cleanly and fall a fair distance, or did it hover just under and grind? Did the pullback between touches hold a higher low, or did it lose ground? That information is the whole reason I wait.
If the first test produced a strong rejection and the second test arrives on weaker momentum, smaller candles and less range, that leans toward the level holding again. If the pullback was shallow and price comes back fast with bigger candles, that leans toward a break.
The cost of waiting is real. Some levels never get a second test and you just miss the move. I'm fine with that. A missed trade costs nothing, and the second test gives me a stop location that actually means something, beyond the high of the first reaction rather than a guess.
How many of you treat the first touch as information only?
Second test of the London high: why I'd rather trade the retest than the first touch
Re: Second test of the London high: why I'd rather trade the retest than the first touch
One thing that changes the read is time between the two tests. If the second test comes within a few candles, it's often the same order flow still working and the level is likely to give way. If it comes an hour or more later, the participants are different and the earlier rejection is a more relevant guide. I'd also note whether a news release sits between the two touches. A level that held before a data print can behave completely differently after it, so I treat that as a fresh first test rather than a second one.
It’s Fairman 
Re: Second test of the London high: why I'd rather trade the retest than the first touch
A question on stops: if the second test pokes slightly above the first high before turning, does that invalidate the setup for you, or is it the setup? Some people would say a small overshoot of the first high is exactly the sweep they want before selling. Others would call it a sign the level is weakening. I'd lean toward needing a close back below the first high on the entry timeframe before taking it, which handles both cases, but I know some traders here prefer entering on the overshoot itself with a tighter structure.
It’s Fairman 
Re: Second test of the London high: why I'd rather trade the retest than the first touch
The size of the move away from the first test changes things for me. If price pulls back only ten pips from the London high and comes straight back, the second test often breaks it, because the sellers at the first touch didn't push price very far. If the pullback was thirty or forty pips, the second test has more meaning, since sellers clearly had some strength at that level. I'd measure the pullback in terms of the morning's range rather than fixed pips, so the rule adjusts to quieter and busier days.
It’s Fairman 
-
FXS Prop Desk
- Posts: 1692
- Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am
Re: Second test of the London high: why I'd rather trade the retest than the first touch
The depth of the pullback between the two touches might be worth putting a number on. You contrast a clean rejection that falls a fair distance with price hovering just under the level; logging that drop in pips, or as a share of the Asian range, would show where the dividing line actually sits for each pair. I'd expect the cutoff on EURUSD and GBPJPY to be quite different.
The other question is what happens when the second test does go through. If the retest came in on the smaller candles you'd normally read as the level holding, and it still closes above, that's fairly strong information as well. Do you ever take the break side in that case, or is this purely a fade setup for you?
The other question is what happens when the second test does go through. If the retest came in on the smaller candles you'd normally read as the level holding, and it still closes above, that's fairly strong information as well. Do you ever take the break side in that case, or is this purely a fade setup for you?
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
Re: Second test of the London high: why I'd rather trade the retest than the first touch
Do others treat the London high differently once New York opens? A retest in the London morning and a retest at 14:30 feel like different trades to me. In the morning the same people who made the high are still around. After New York arrives, there's fresh flow and data releases, and the old high is just one level among several. I've started only trading the retest before the New York open and treating later tests more like a generic level. My sample is small though, so I'd like to hear what others see.
It’s Fairman 