Advertisement IC Markets

Instant execution versus market execution, side by side

Compare ECN/Raw spread brokers, analyze execution speeds, report slippage, and evaluate commission structures for high-frequency traders.
Post Reply
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Instant execution versus market execution, side by side

Post by Fairman »

Instant execution versus market execution, side by side

These two modes get explained badly, so here is a plain comparison.

Instant execution: the platform sends the price on the screen. The broker either accepts it, rejects it, or offers a new price within a deviation setting. Fills tend to land at the clicked price when quiet, and requotes show up when fast.

Market execution: the platform sends the order with no price attached. The broker fills at whatever the best available price is at that moment. No requotes, but slippage can go any direction and there is no protection built in.

For a scalper the trade-off looks like this:

- Instant gives control over entry price, at the cost of missed trades when the market runs
- Market gives certainty of getting in, at the cost of paying whatever the book charges
- Instant with a tight deviation setting behaves almost like a limit order and can reject a great deal of fast entries
- Market with a loose setting never rejects anything, which sounds nice until a news candle

Neither is better in general. The one that matches the way entries are taken is better. Breakout entries usually want market. Mean reversion entries into a pullback often do fine with instant and a modest deviation.

There is a hybrid in some platforms, request execution or exchange execution, where the trader sees a price and the broker confirms it with a short delay. It behaves like instant execution for the user and like market execution for the broker. Knowing which mode applies to which symbol is worth checking, because brokers sometimes set different modes for different instruments on the same account, and a strategy trading several pairs can be running under three sets of rules without anyone noticing.

Which mode did the strategy actually get backtested under, and does the live account use the same one?
It’s Fairman :geek:
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Instant execution versus market execution, side by side

Post by Shadow Trader »

The platform shows a message and the instinct is to lump it all together as "bad execution." They aren't the same thing, and they point to different problems.

A requote means the price moved between click and arrival, and the server offers a new price for the trader to accept or decline. It's the dealing-desk style of handling and tends to show up on instant-execution accounts.

A rejection means the order never filled at all. Reasons range from "off quotes" to "invalid price" to "market closed," and the platform's wording is often vague about the actual cause.

Slippage is the quiet one. The order fills, but at a price different from the one on screen. No message appears. The only evidence is the gap between the click price and the execution price in the trade history.

Each one costs something different. Requotes cost time. Rejections cost the trade entirely. Slippage costs money without announcing itself, which makes it the easiest to ignore and the most dangerous over a few thousand trades.

Pulling the history and comparing requested price to filled price for a month shows which one is actually hurting.

Instant execution and market execution account types handle these differently. Instant execution sends the requested price along with the order and allows the broker to requote if the market moved. Market execution fills at whatever price is available, with no requote, which moves the risk from "no trade" to "different price." Neither is better in general, but a scalper with tight targets usually prefers knowing the trade will happen and measuring the slippage afterward.

Deviation settings sit between the two. A deviation of three points tells the server to accept a fill within three points of the requested price. Too tight and orders bounce. Too loose and slippage hides inside the allowance.

A table with three columns, requotes, rejections, and slippage in pips, filled in weekly, shows where to adjust.

Which of the three shows up most often on your account, and does it cluster around certain times?
Post Reply