I ended up weighting fill quality over the advertised raw spread. On one trial account the spread looked half a pip tighter, but rejections on EURUSD market orders at London open made the effective cost worse than the slightly wider book I use now.
Moving the VPS into the same city as the broker cut round trip enough that my usual limit entries started filling on the first touch instead of chasing. That gain showed up in the fill log within a week.
The scalping clause in the terms is the one I actually read line by line. A broker that reserved the right to cancel sub-minute trades was an immediate no, regardless of the platform.
Withdrawals were the last filter. Two small live tests and a same-week payout request beat any demo comparison I had run.
Which of those filters would you drop first if you could only keep three? For me the terms and fill logs stay, and the marketing page never enters the shortlist.
One criterion missing from the list is the minimum stop distance, which some platforms call the stops level. On one account it was set at 20 points on EURUSD, so a limit entry or stop closer than 2 pips to the current price was simply rejected.
For a scalper who trails a stop or places entries near the touch, that rule matters more than a tenth of a pip of spread. I check it in the symbol specification on a live account during London, because on that account it widened to 50 points around data.
The freeze level is its cousin. Inside it you cannot modify or cancel an order close to market, which once left me unable to pull a limit as price ran into it before a release.
I would also put margin treatment on the list. Two accounts with the same leverage set different margin on crosses and metals, and that changed how many positions I could hold during an overlap.
Does anyone check stops level and freeze level before opening a trial account, or only after the first rejection? I only learned to look after a rejected order.
Marketing pages look similar. The details tell the real story.
Regulation comes first. Which authority licenses the entity serving the account? Many brokers have multiple entities, and clients outside certain regions get placed under the weakest one.
Segregation of client funds, negative balance protection and compensation schemes vary by jurisdiction.
Execution policy matters for scalpers. Does the broker allow scalping and hedging without restrictions? What is the average execution speed and rejection rate? Is there a minimum hold time?
Costs deserve scrutiny. Typical spreads at active hours, commission, swap rates and fees for deposits, withdrawals and inactivity.
Withdrawals are the real test. Reviews that describe delays or refusals carry more weight than any promotion.
A small deposit, a few trades and a test withdrawal before committing serious capital reveals a lot, and takes only a few days.
What was the deciding factor in choosing the current broker, and has it held up?