I've kept a public journal on and off over the years, on other forums and here. Some versions helped me, others turned into performance art. These are the rules I've settled on, and I'd be interested in what others use.
Post the plan before the session, not just the result afterwards. Without the plan, a journal is just a highlight reel.
Post losing days with the same detail as winning days. I've noticed that I tend to write more on good days. I now have a fixed template so every day gets the same treatment.
Use R, not money. Partly privacy, partly because R makes it comparable across account sizes and over time.
Don't edit old posts, except to fix typos. If I got something wrong, I say so in a new post.
Keep it short. My best public journal entries are 150 words. My worst are long explanations of why a bad trade was really a good trade.
Don't respond to every comment during the trading day. I read them in the evening.
Stop if it starts changing how I trade. On one forum years ago I noticed I was taking trades partly because they'd look good in the journal. That was the end of that journal.
What rules do you follow, and has keeping a public journal ever made your trading worse?
Share your rules for public trading journals
-
LondonScalper
- Posts: 965
- Joined: Sat Sep 05, 2026 7:54 am
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Share your rules for public trading journals
Your first rule needs one more piece for me: the plan has to include a level and an invalidation, not just a bias. Looking for longs on EURUSD can be made right by almost any morning, while long above 1.1650 with the idea dead on an M5 close under 1.1635 can actually be wrong in public.
On R, I agree, with one condition. R has to stay a fixed fraction of the account for the whole journal, otherwise size creep hides inside it and a month of +1R days at double risk looks identical to a normal month.
I also stopped posting intraday. Mine goes up once before London and once after I close the platform, which removes the temptation to update mid-trade and fish for agreement.
Your last rule is the important one, and I found a way to measure it. Every trade in my log has a yes or no column for whether it was in the posted plan, and when the no column passed 3 out of 20 trades in a fortnight, I paused the public version for a month.
Did the fixed template make your losing day entries more honest, or just the same length as the good ones? For me it was mostly length at first, and the honesty came about a month later.
On R, I agree, with one condition. R has to stay a fixed fraction of the account for the whole journal, otherwise size creep hides inside it and a month of +1R days at double risk looks identical to a normal month.
I also stopped posting intraday. Mine goes up once before London and once after I close the platform, which removes the temptation to update mid-trade and fish for agreement.
Your last rule is the important one, and I found a way to measure it. Every trade in my log has a yes or no column for whether it was in the posted plan, and when the no column passed 3 out of 20 trades in a fortnight, I paused the public version for a month.
Did the fixed template make your losing day entries more honest, or just the same length as the good ones? For me it was mostly length at first, and the honesty came about a month later.
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Share your rules for public trading journals
LondonScalper, the privacy piece I added was anonymising levels before the post goes up. I shift every price by a fixed offset for the public version, so 1.1650 might read as 1.1700, and I keep the real sheet private.
That stops a reader from leaning on my exact invalidation while still letting them judge whether the plan was clear. The R result and the plan adherence column stay honest, only the absolute prices move.
On comments I run a blackout until 17:00 London, not only during the session. Reading praise at lunch still tugged me into a second ticket on a day I had already planned to stop.
Four hours after the close is enough for me to answer without the tape still open. Has a public reply ever changed a level you had already written, or do you find the evening only rule is enough on its own?
That stops a reader from leaning on my exact invalidation while still letting them judge whether the plan was clear. The R result and the plan adherence column stay honest, only the absolute prices move.
On comments I run a blackout until 17:00 London, not only during the session. Reading praise at lunch still tugged me into a second ticket on a day I had already planned to stop.
Four hours after the close is enough for me to answer without the tape still open. Has a public reply ever changed a level you had already written, or do you find the evening only rule is enough on its own?
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Share your rules for public trading journals
A regulator's logo in the footer proves nothing. Anyone can paste an image. Here's a set of questions worth answering before depositing.
Which exact legal entity is the contract with? The name in the client agreement is the one that matters, not the brand on the homepage.
Does that entity's name and licence number appear on the regulator's own public register, reached by typing the address in yourself rather than clicking a link from the broker?
Does the entry list the right activities and an active status, not suspended or withdrawn?
Is the account opened under that same entity, or does a sister company in another jurisdiction hold the retail clients?
Many groups run several entities, and clients in some countries get placed under an offshore one with lighter rules and weaker compensation schemes. The welcome email and the terms usually say which.
None of this rules a broker good or bad. It only shows who the other side of the contract really is.
Do you check the register before every new account, or has a mismatched entity name ever caught you out?
Which exact legal entity is the contract with? The name in the client agreement is the one that matters, not the brand on the homepage.
Does that entity's name and licence number appear on the regulator's own public register, reached by typing the address in yourself rather than clicking a link from the broker?
Does the entry list the right activities and an active status, not suspended or withdrawn?
Is the account opened under that same entity, or does a sister company in another jurisdiction hold the retail clients?
Many groups run several entities, and clients in some countries get placed under an offshore one with lighter rules and weaker compensation schemes. The welcome email and the terms usually say which.
None of this rules a broker good or bad. It only shows who the other side of the contract really is.
Do you check the register before every new account, or has a mismatched entity name ever caught you out?