Trading plans change over time, but the reasons for changes are usually forgotten. A simple change log keeps that history and makes future decisions better.
What to record for each change:
Date.
The rule before and after.
Why it changed: a specific losing pattern, new statistics, a new account type.
The evidence: number of trades, period, journal references.
When the change will be reviewed.
Benefits:
Prevents the same rule being added and removed repeatedly.
Shows whether changes were driven by data or by a single painful trade.
Makes reviews faster: you can see which changes improved results.
A good rule of thumb is to allow changes only at weekly or monthly reviews, never during a session. The log makes it easy to see if that discipline holds.
Do you keep a record of rule changes, or does your plan simply get edited over time?
FXS Prop Desk, I have kept a change log for about two years and the most useful column turned out to be the trigger. Mine records whether a change came from a review of at least 50 trades or from a single session, and the second kind has been reversed far more often.
When I counted last spring, 9 of my 14 single session changes had been undone within two months. Only 2 of 11 review based changes went the same way, which settled the question of when I allow edits.
I also write the expected effect next to each change. Something like fewer Asia trades and average R up by 0.05 gives the review date something to check, instead of a vague sense of whether things feel better.
One edge case is a firm rule change on a prop account. Those go in the log too, but marked as forced, so I do not later mistake a firm imposed limit for a lesson I learned.
The log lives as a tab in the same spreadsheet as the journal. Do you keep yours with the trading plan, or separate so the plan stays clean?
Since my last reply in here I went back through the log to count something different, which was how often each rule actually fired. Over the last quarter, 6 of my 23 written rules never triggered once, and two of them referred to a session I no longer trade.
That is the failure on the other side of the one you describe. Rules get added after a painful trade, nobody removes them, and the plan slowly turns into a list I skim rather than read.
So the log now has a retirement entry as well as a change entry. A rule that has not fired in 90 days gets reviewed, and if it no longer matches how I trade, it is struck through with the date and reason rather than deleted.
Each rule also carries a version number that goes into the journal tag. When I filter trades by v3 against v4 of my entry rule, I can see the before and after on real tickets instead of from memory.
My cap is 20 active rules, and adding one past that means retiring another. Do you ever take rules out, or does your list only grow?
Some traders notice a sudden change in fill quality that cannot be explained by market conditions. Spreads look normal, but slippage rises and rejections increase for a week or two.
One possible cause is a change in the broker's liquidity setup. Brokers add, remove, or reweight liquidity providers, sometimes because of cost, sometimes because of risk management, and rarely announce it.
Another is a change in how the broker classifies the account. Some brokers route flow differently depending on trading style, profitability, or volume, and a strategy that once looked like retail noise can start to look like something else in the data.
Detecting this requires a baseline. Keep a rolling log of average slippage and rejection rate, and a sudden shift stands out against the history. Without it, everything gets blamed on volatility.
Another possible clue is a change in the spread profile at specific times of day, since a new provider mix can alter the quote behaviour in thin hours first. Keeping an hourly average of the spread alongside the slippage log catches this earlier than watching profit and loss alone.
Curious whether you have ever seen a clear step change in execution quality on one account, and did anything explain it afterwards?