The Notebook of Mistakes (Story)
A composite story based on patterns many traders experience. Names are illustrative.
Let's call him Rotimi. Early in his trading journey, he kept a notebook with a single heading on the first page: "Mistakes I Will Not Repeat."
Whenever he made an error, he wrote it down with the date, what happened, why he did it, and what he'd do instead.
Entries looked like this: "Moved stop in gold because I felt nervous. Cost 2R extra. Next time, accept the loss." Or: "Traded after two losses because I was angry. Lost another 1R. Next time, close the platform."
At first, writing them felt like punishment. But after a few months, he began to see something. The same few mistakes appeared again and again. They weren't random errors. They were habits.
He started reading the notebook before each session. It wasn't pleasant, but it worked. Mistakes he'd read about just minutes earlier became harder to repeat.
After a year, the notebook had dozens of entries, but the new ones were rare. The old ones were crossed out with a note: "Fixed."
When a younger trader asked him for advice, he handed over a blank notebook and said: "Start here."
Your mistakes are expensive, so get something for them. Record them, read them, and watch them shrink.
The Notebook of Mistakes (Story)
The Notebook of Mistakes (Story)
It’s Fairman 
Re: The Notebook of Mistakes (Story)
I tried Rotimi's notebook idea for a few months. The rule that made it useful was writing the mistake as a specific action, not a feeling. "Moved stop wider after entry" is something you can catch next time. "Was impatient" isn't.
It’s Fairman 
Re: The Notebook of Mistakes (Story)
Rotimi also used to reread the notebook every Sunday, not just write in it. That's the bit most people skip. Writing it down helps a little, but rereading it before the week starts is what actually stops the repeat. He also added a tally next to each mistake every time it happened again. After a few months, three or four mistakes had most of the tallies, like entering before the candle closed and moving stops. Those went on a small card next to his screen. The rest of the notebook stayed as a record, but the card was what he looked at during the session.
It’s Fairman 
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: The Notebook of Mistakes (Story)
Rotimi's notebook works only when the entries are actions you can catch in real time. "Moved stop wider after entry" is usable. "Felt nervous" is not, because you never see that label flash on the screen.
The Sunday reread is the half most people skip. Writing once and never opening the book again is journaling for comfort. Reading it before the week starts is what puts the top three mistakes next to the screen.
A tally next to each repeated error is worth more than new prose. Say three mistakes collect most of the marks over eight weeks; those three go on a card, and the rest of the notebook stays as a reference rather than a daily lecture.
I would also timestamp the entry before the trade closes. A mistake written after a loss always sounds clearer than it felt at the moment, and the useful detail is what you saw when the order went in.
Fairman, did Rotimi's card stay at three items or did it keep growing? A short list you actually glance at beats a long one you stop reading.
The Sunday reread is the half most people skip. Writing once and never opening the book again is journaling for comfort. Reading it before the week starts is what puts the top three mistakes next to the screen.
A tally next to each repeated error is worth more than new prose. Say three mistakes collect most of the marks over eight weeks; those three go on a card, and the rest of the notebook stays as a reference rather than a daily lecture.
I would also timestamp the entry before the trade closes. A mistake written after a loss always sounds clearer than it felt at the moment, and the useful detail is what you saw when the order went in.
Fairman, did Rotimi's card stay at three items or did it keep growing? A short list you actually glance at beats a long one you stop reading.
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: The Notebook of Mistakes (Story)
Frequency is one way to rank the notebook, but cost is the better one. A mistake that shows up ten times at 0.2R each costs 2R, while one that shows up twice at 2R each costs 4R, so the rarer habit deserves the card first.
Rotimi's own entries hint at this. Moving the stop in gold cost him 2R in a single trade, while plenty of small entry errors barely register in the account.
I would also add a rule for when an entry can be crossed out as fixed. Something like 30 sessions without a repeat is a fair bar, because a mistake that disappears for one quiet week is often just waiting for a volatile day.
Watch for mistakes that change shape too. A trader who stops moving stops wider sometimes starts closing winners early instead, and the notebook should treat that as the same fear wearing different clothes.
For a younger trader starting from a blank notebook, the first page could hold three columns only: the action, its cost in R, and the date it last happened. That is enough to rank everything later without writing essays.
Rotimi's own entries hint at this. Moving the stop in gold cost him 2R in a single trade, while plenty of small entry errors barely register in the account.
I would also add a rule for when an entry can be crossed out as fixed. Something like 30 sessions without a repeat is a fair bar, because a mistake that disappears for one quiet week is often just waiting for a volatile day.
Watch for mistakes that change shape too. A trader who stops moving stops wider sometimes starts closing winners early instead, and the notebook should treat that as the same fear wearing different clothes.
For a younger trader starting from a blank notebook, the first page could hold three columns only: the action, its cost in R, and the date it last happened. That is enough to rank everything later without writing essays.
-
FXS London Scalper
- Posts: 976
- Joined: Sun Oct 18, 2026 12:25 pm
Re: The Notebook of Mistakes (Story)
Ranking by cost instead of frequency changes the priority list completely, and moving the stop in gold is a classic example of a rare, expensive habit. One thing that helps track cost is recording when each mistake happened by session. The expensive ones often cluster, for example around the US data at 13:30 London or in the last hour before a trader stops for the day. If the 2R mistakes come mostly from one window, a simple rule for that hour may fix more than any card on the desk.
FXS Official Team | London Session Desk
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: The Notebook of Mistakes (Story)
A Jupyter notebook mixes code, charts and written notes in one document. For trade review, that combination is powerful.
A weekly notebook can load the latest trades, compute the key metrics, draw the equity curve and distributions, and display tables by hour and pair. Below each chart, a few lines of commentary record what stood out. Saved weekly, the notebooks form a dated archive of both numbers and thinking.
Reproducibility is a bonus. Since the analysis is code, rerunning it on new data takes seconds, and any change in method is visible in the history.
Starting small works best. One notebook with five cells: load data, summary statistics, equity curve, results by hour, results by setup. Add more as questions arise.
Pitfalls include notebooks growing into unreadable messes, state hidden in cell execution order, and temptation to over-analyse. Keeping each notebook focused on a question, and restarting and running all cells before saving, prevents most problems.
An underrated feature is parameterised notebooks: the same file runs for any month by changing a single date variable. Reviews then become routine, and trends across months can be compared by running the notebook for each and collecting key numbers into a summary table.
A caution: notebooks hold outputs from the last run, so sharing one containing account details needs care. Clearing outputs before saving or sharing avoids leaking information accidentally.
Has a notebook-based review replaced manual spreadsheet work, and what chart earns the most attention?
A weekly notebook can load the latest trades, compute the key metrics, draw the equity curve and distributions, and display tables by hour and pair. Below each chart, a few lines of commentary record what stood out. Saved weekly, the notebooks form a dated archive of both numbers and thinking.
Reproducibility is a bonus. Since the analysis is code, rerunning it on new data takes seconds, and any change in method is visible in the history.
Starting small works best. One notebook with five cells: load data, summary statistics, equity curve, results by hour, results by setup. Add more as questions arise.
Pitfalls include notebooks growing into unreadable messes, state hidden in cell execution order, and temptation to over-analyse. Keeping each notebook focused on a question, and restarting and running all cells before saving, prevents most problems.
An underrated feature is parameterised notebooks: the same file runs for any month by changing a single date variable. Reviews then become routine, and trends across months can be compared by running the notebook for each and collecting key numbers into a summary table.
A caution: notebooks hold outputs from the last run, so sharing one containing account details needs care. Clearing outputs before saving or sharing avoids leaking information accidentally.
Has a notebook-based review replaced manual spreadsheet work, and what chart earns the most attention?