Advertisement IC Markets

Scenario Planning: Writing If-Then Rules Before the Market Moves

Discuss 1-minute to 15-minute price action setups, fading intraday momentum, key support/resistance zones, and proven short-term trading methodologies.
Post Reply
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Scenario Planning: Writing If-Then Rules Before the Market Moves

Post by Fairman »

Scenario Planning: Writing If-Then Rules Before the Market Moves

Prices do not follow your forecast. Scenario planning replaces prediction with preparation, by defining your response to several possible paths.

For a given setup, write three scenarios. In the base case, price moves as expected: describe the entry, management, and exit. In the adverse case, price moves against you: define the stop and what you will do after being stopped, such as waiting for a new setup. In the surprise case, an unexpected event occurs, such as a news release or a large spike: define what you will do, such as closing the trade or leaving the stop in place.

Add if-then rules for common branches. If price breaks above resistance and closes above, then I add a half position on a retest. If price rejects the level twice, then I exit at breakeven. If the spread widens beyond a set value, then I do not enter.

Writing these rules before the trade removes real-time decisions, which are most vulnerable to emotion.

The process also exposes weaknesses in the idea. If you cannot describe what happens in the adverse case, you have not defined your risk.

Keep scenarios short, a few lines for each. Use a template, and store it with the trade record.

Review after the trade: which scenario occurred, and did you follow the plan?

Over time, you will anticipate more branches and be surprised less.

Practical step: write three scenarios for your next trade idea before entering.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: Scenario Planning: Writing If-Then Rules Before the Market Moves

Post by Fairman »

The surprise scenario is the one people skip. Having a line that says if a big spike hits, I leave the stop where it is stops a lot of panic decisions. Worth settling beforehand whether you'd take profit into a spike in your favour. For example, if price jumps more than one full ATR in my direction within a few minutes, I close half and move the stop to breakeven. Without a rule, people either grab the money too early or freeze and watch it retrace. The surprise doesn't need to be predicted, only the response. A one line rule for both directions covers most of it.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: Scenario Planning: Writing If-Then Rules Before the Market Moves

Post by Fairman »

If you can't write the adverse case in one line, that's a strong sign you haven't really decided where you're wrong. A good adverse line looks like this: if the 4 hour candle closes back below 1.0820, the breakout has failed, I exit and wait for a new setup, no re-entry today. It has a price, a timeframe, an action and what happens next. Vague versions like if it goes against me I'll see usually turn into moving the stop or adding to a loser. Writing the last part, no re-entry today, matters as much as the exit itself, because the revenge trade straight after a stop is where a lot of damage comes from.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Scenario Planning: Writing If-Then Rules Before the Market Moves

Post by Shadow Trader »

Three scenarios plus a few if then branches beat a single forecast. The adverse line is the honesty check: if you cannot name the price and the timeframe that kills the idea, you do not have a trade yet.

I like the no re entry today clause after a stop. Revenge fills right after an adverse exit are often the second loss that turns a normal day into a bad one.

The surprise rule should cover both directions. A spike through the target needs a planned partial or a hold decision, just as a spike through the stop needs a leave it alone decision.

Keep the whole card short enough to read in under thirty seconds at the open. A page of branches will not get used when the tape is fast.

How many branches do you actually keep live during a session? At what count does the card become noise for you?
FXS Prop Desk
Posts: 1693
Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am

Re: Scenario Planning: Writing If-Then Rules Before the Market Moves

Post by FXS Prop Desk »

Writing three scenarios is a practical tool. One addition: include the "nothing happens" scenario, where price stays around entry for a long time. A time-based rule (for example, close the trade if it hasn't moved toward target within a set number of candles) prevents trades from drifting without a plan.

Reviewing the scenarios after the trade also helps improve the planning process over time.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Scenario Planning: Writing If-Then Rules Before the Market Moves

Post by Shadow Trader »

The nothing happens case suggested above needs a number to work. On an M5 scalp aiming for 10 pips, one version is to exit if the trade has not reached plus 4 within 6 bars, which is 30 minutes.

That rule is easy to test from history. Say 60 trades are checked, 18 were still near entry after 6 bars, and only 5 of those 18 went on to hit target, so the time exit is cutting trades that win less than a third of the time.

With a 10 pip stop as well, holding those is a losing bet. Five winners and 13 losers at 10 pips each is minus 80 pips across the group, before spread.

There is one more branch worth writing, the trade that never triggers. If price runs to target without filling the entry, the card should say whether a late entry is allowed, and the default answer is usually no.

Writing the branches in the same order every time helps under pressure. Base, adverse, surprise, flat and missed make five lines that can be read before the open and once more after the exit.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Scenario Planning: Writing If-Then Rules Before the Market Moves

Post by Shadow Trader »

Psychologists have found that a vague goal, like "be more disciplined", rarely changes behaviour. A specific if-then plan, called an implementation intention, works much better. "If situation X occurs, then do Y."

In trading, the technique applies directly. "If two consecutive losses occur, then stop trading for 30 minutes." "If the spread exceeds 1.5 pips, then no entries." "If price approaches the stop and the urge to move it appears, then close the trade instead." Each plan links a trigger to a pre-decided action, removing the need for willpower in the moment.

The more specific the trigger and the action, the better the effect. "If emotional" is too vague. "If a trade loses more than 1R" is crisp.

Writing the plans down, reading them before each session, and rehearsing them mentally increases the chance of following through. Some traders turn them into a checklist stuck on the monitor.

Reviewing which plans were triggered and followed each week shows which ones work and which need rewording.

A starter list of if-then lines to adapt:

If the daily loss limit is hit, then the platform closes for the day.
If a trade is open and a news event is under ten minutes away, then close it.
If the spread is above the threshold, then no entry.
If the urge to add to a loser appears, then walk away from the desk for five minutes.
If three trades in a row break a rule, then the session ends.

Short, binary, and tied to something observable. The best ones are boring.

Which if-then rules are in place, and which one has been triggered most often?
Post Reply