Advertisement IC Markets

Partial fills of the fair value gap on EURUSD M5, where I take profit and where I'm wrong

Discuss 1-minute to 15-minute price action setups, fading intraday momentum, key support/resistance zones, and proven short-term trading methodologies.
Post Reply
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Partial fills of the fair value gap on EURUSD M5, where I take profit and where I'm wrong

Post by Fairman »

Partial fills of the fair value gap on EURUSD M5, where I take profit and where I'm wrong

fair value gaps get overcomplicated. On M5 I look for a strong displacement candle that leaves a gap between the first candle's high and the third candle's low, in the direction of the higher timeframe bias. Then I wait for price to pull back into it.
diagram.png
diagram.png (37.44 KiB) Viewed 223 times
I don't need a full fill. For me the midpoint of the gap is the key spot. If price comes back to about halfway into the gap and a candle closes back in the direction of the move, that's my entry. Stop goes below the whole gap, so if price closes fully through it the idea is wrong and I'm out. Target is the swing high that preceded the pullback.

What I skip: gaps that formed in a quiet period with no real momentum behind them. If the displacement was just a couple of pips, it isn't a gap that anyone cares about. I only want gaps created by a strong move, usually around the London open or a data release. Also anything formed against the M15 trend gets ignored, those fill and keep going.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: Partial fills of the fair value gap on EURUSD M5, where I take profit and where I'm wrong

Post by Fairman »

Someone asked how I measure the midpoint without guessing. I literally draw a box from the high of the first candle to the low of the third candle, then put a horizontal line at fifty percent. TradingView has a midline option on the rectangle tool which saves doing the maths. I am not precious about price touching it exactly. If a candle wicks within a pip or so of the line and then closes back up, I treat that as the reaction I wanted. Waiting for a perfect tag usually means missing the move completely.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: Partial fills of the fair value gap on EURUSD M5, where I take profit and where I'm wrong

Post by Fairman »

On the stop, a lot of people put it right under the gap and get taken out by one wick. What I do is look at where the displacement candle started and keep the stop just under the bottom of the gap with a little extra for spread. If the M5 candle closes below the whole gap, I am out even if the stop has not been hit yet. A close through means the move that created the gap has been fully given back, and I do not want to sit there hoping.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: Partial fills of the fair value gap on EURUSD M5, where I take profit and where I'm wrong

Post by Fairman »

When the gap gets filled completely and price keeps going, I do not look at it again for a long time. It has done its job and the idea is finished. Sometimes it flips and acts as resistance on the way back up, which is the inverse gap idea, but that is a separate trade with its own rules and I do not want to mix the two. Keeping it to one clear plan per gap stops me from inventing new reasons to stay in something that has already failed.
It’s Fairman :geek:
FXS Prop Desk
Posts: 1693
Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am

Re: Partial fills of the fair value gap on EURUSD M5, where I take profit and where I'm wrong

Post by FXS Prop Desk »

Partial fills of the gap are common, and deciding in advance where to take profit helps. The far side of the gap is a natural target, while a close beyond the gap's origin invalidates the idea.

It might help to track how often price fills the gap fully versus partially. If most fills are partial, taking profit at the midpoint may improve results.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Partial fills of the fair value gap on EURUSD M5, where I take profit and where I'm wrong

Post by Shadow Trader »

Tracking full against partial fills, as suggested above, is worth putting numbers on. Say a displacement on EURUSD M5 leaves a gap from 1.0842 to 1.0856, 14 pips wide, with the swing high at 1.0880.

A limit at the midpoint, 1.0849, with the stop at 1.0840 just under the gap, risks 9 pips to make 31. That is about 3.4R, and it breaks even at a win rate of 9 divided by 40, or 22.5 percent.

Entering at the top edge, 1.0856, with the same stop risks 16 pips to make 24, so 1.5R with break even at 40 percent. The chart shows both entries on the made up move.
img_13513_r1.png
img_13513_r1.png (50.9 KiB) Viewed 165 times
The top edge always fills when the pullback comes, and the midpoint does not. So the useful count is how many winners from the top edge the midpoint misses.

Say 20 pullbacks touch the top edge and 12 reach the midpoint. If most of the 8 misses would have gone on to the swing high, the deeper entry is paying for its better ratio with exactly the winners it needs.

Does anyone keep that missed trade column? Without it the midpoint entry will always look better than it really is.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Partial fills of the fair value gap on EURUSD M5, where I take profit and where I'm wrong

Post by Shadow Trader »

A strong displacement often leaves two gaps rather than one, when four or five large candles print in a row. Picking which one to trade matters more than it looks.

Say a move on EURUSD M5 leaves a lower gap from 1.0905 to 1.0913 and an upper one from 1.0918 to 1.0926, with the swing high at 1.0945. The upper midpoint, 1.0922, fills more often because it is closer, while the lower midpoint at 1.0909 gives the better price.

Treating the upper gap on its own, a stop at 1.0915 risks 7 pips for 23, about 3.3R. The catch is that a pullback through the upper gap often keeps going into the lower one before turning, so that trade gets stopped just before the move works.

Waiting for the lower midpoint with the stop at 1.0902 risks 7 for 36, about 5.1R, but it only fills on the deeper pullbacks. When two gaps are stacked, the rule about a close through the whole gap really applies to the lower one.

A middle path is to take half at each midpoint, with one stop under the lower gap. Has anyone tested whether the upper gap on its own holds often enough to justify the tight stop?
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Partial fills of the fair value gap on EURUSD M5, where I take profit and where I'm wrong

Post by Shadow Trader »

A fair value gap, in the vocabulary popular among some online educators, is a three-candle formation where the first candle's high and the third candle's low don't overlap, leaving a gap in the middle candle's range. The claim is that price tends to return to fill that gap.

Sometimes it does. Price revisits recent levels constantly, and gaps in thin trading are naturally revisited. The open question is whether the return happens more often than it would for any random level, and whether it happens in a way that can be traded profitably after costs.

A fair test marks every such three-candle formation on a chosen timeframe, records whether price returns to the gap within, say, 20 candles, and compares the rate with that of randomly chosen price levels of the same distance. If the gap fills 80% of the time but so do random levels, the pattern adds nothing.

Even then, filling is not the same as a profitable trade. Entry, stop and target all need rules.

One more wrinkle: gaps in a continuous market aren't the same as gaps in a candle pattern. On a one-minute chart, the "gap" between candle one's high and candle three's low is a zone of rapid movement, not an absence of trading. Price travelled through it, so every level inside it had at least some trades.

Has the fill rate of these gaps been measured against a random baseline, and what did it show?
Post Reply