Trendline break and retest on M1 at the NY open on USDCAD
I trade this a lot in the first hour of NY because USDCAD tends to trend cleanly for a bit then reverse. On M1 I draw a trendline across at least three touches, the more obvious the better. When price breaks it with a real candle, I wait for the retest.
The entry is the pullback to the line from the other side. If it's a downtrend line that got broken to the upside, I want price to come back down to the line, hold it, and bounce. Stop goes under the pullback low. Target is the high before the trendline started to matter, or the next M5 level.
The line must be drawn honestly. I only use lines with at least three clear touches, and I don't redraw it after the break to make it fit. And I ignore breaks that happen in the first minute after a data release, since they're often just noise.
Trendline breaks are notoriously unreliable on their own, so I only take them in the direction of the M15 structure. If M15 is making lower highs, I won't buy a trendline break against it.
Trendline break and retest on M1 at the NY open on USDCAD
Re: Trendline break and retest on M1 at the NY open on USDCAD
How I check the M15 structure quickly before the NY open. I look at the last two swing highs and swing lows on M15. If both are rising, I only take breaks of falling M1 lines to the upside, since those are pullbacks ending inside a bigger up move. If both are falling, I only take breaks of rising M1 lines to the downside. When the M15 swings are mixed, I sit out, because that is usually when trendline breaks on M1 go nowhere and reverse straight back.
It’s Fairman 
Re: Trendline break and retest on M1 at the NY open on USDCAD
On USDCAD specifically, I keep an eye on oil around the NY open. If crude is moving hard in one direction, the loonie often follows, and a trendline break against that flow is much less likely to work. I am not trading oil, just using it as a quick sanity check. When oil is flat and quiet, the pair tends to respect the technical levels better and these breaks have been a lot cleaner for me. I just glance at a crude chart for a few seconds before the session starts.
It’s Fairman 
Re: Trendline break and retest on M1 at the NY open on USDCAD
If price breaks the line but never comes back to retest it, I let it go. I used to chase those with a market order and the stop ended up far too wide, under some random candle. Skipping them means missing a few good moves, but the retest is what gives me a sensible stop. Most of the time, if the break is real and the retest never comes, there will be another setup later in the session anyway. Patience on the retest is most of the edge here.
It’s Fairman 
-
FXS Prop Desk
- Posts: 1693
- Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am
Re: Trendline break and retest on M1 at the NY open on USDCAD
USDCAD often trends cleanly at the New York open because of the oil and data flows. Using at least three touches makes the trendline more reliable.
Oil prices can affect USDCAD strongly. Checking crude during the trade can help explain sudden reversals that do not match the chart.
Oil prices can affect USDCAD strongly. Checking crude during the trade can help explain sudden reversals that do not match the chart.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Trendline break and retest on M1 at the NY open on USDCAD
The rule about honest lines could use a matching rule about honest retests, since price rarely touches the line exactly. Say the broken line sits at 1.3808 when price comes back, and the pullback wicks to 1.3806 before closing at 1.3810.
Two pips through and a close back above probably counts as a hold on USDCAD M1 at that hour. With the entry at 1.3810 and the stop at 1.3803 under the wick, the risk is 7 pips, and a prior high at 1.3831 is 21 pips away, so 3R.
The harder case is a close below the line followed by a close back above. Deciding in advance how far through is allowed, maybe a fixed two or three pips, stops the line being reinterpreted after the fact.
On the oil check, Wednesdays deserve their own treatment. The weekly US crude inventory figure comes out mid morning New York time, and a break in the minutes after it is mostly oil flow rather than structure.
It may be worth tagging Wednesday breaks separately for a few weeks. If they behave differently, the fix could be as simple as no new entries in the half hour after that release.
Two pips through and a close back above probably counts as a hold on USDCAD M1 at that hour. With the entry at 1.3810 and the stop at 1.3803 under the wick, the risk is 7 pips, and a prior high at 1.3831 is 21 pips away, so 3R.
The harder case is a close below the line followed by a close back above. Deciding in advance how far through is allowed, maybe a fixed two or three pips, stops the line being reinterpreted after the fact.
On the oil check, Wednesdays deserve their own treatment. The weekly US crude inventory figure comes out mid morning New York time, and a break in the minutes after it is mostly oil flow rather than structure.
It may be worth tagging Wednesday breaks separately for a few weeks. If they behave differently, the fix could be as simple as no new entries in the half hour after that release.
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Trendline break and retest on M1 at the NY open on USDCAD
USDCAD tends to move with less drama than GBP or JPY pairs, which can lull scalpers into a false sense of calm. Its personality is steadier but not simple.
Crude oil is the obvious driver, though the link comes and goes. In some periods the pair follows oil minute by minute. In others, interest rate expectations and US data dominate. Bank of Canada decisions and Canadian employment figures add spikes, and the Wednesday oil inventory report can nudge the pair.
For scalpers, the pair often offers cleaner trends during the New York session, when oil trading is active and both countries' data lands. It can feel sluggish in Asia and early London.
An advantage: spreads are usually decent and the pair tends not to produce the frantic whipsaws of GBP crosses. A drawback: smaller ranges mean targets must be modest, and costs matter.
Tracking crude beside the pair for a few weeks shows whether oil is currently the main driver.
Spread the trades across the day and look at where USDCAD actually pays. For many, the profitable window is a short stretch from the New York open until early afternoon, with the rest of the day contributing little beyond costs. A pair with a narrow productive window rewards focus and punishes all-day watching.
Is USDCAD followed closely with oil, and when has the relationship broken down?
Crude oil is the obvious driver, though the link comes and goes. In some periods the pair follows oil minute by minute. In others, interest rate expectations and US data dominate. Bank of Canada decisions and Canadian employment figures add spikes, and the Wednesday oil inventory report can nudge the pair.
For scalpers, the pair often offers cleaner trends during the New York session, when oil trading is active and both countries' data lands. It can feel sluggish in Asia and early London.
An advantage: spreads are usually decent and the pair tends not to produce the frantic whipsaws of GBP crosses. A drawback: smaller ranges mean targets must be modest, and costs matter.
Tracking crude beside the pair for a few weeks shows whether oil is currently the main driver.
Spread the trades across the day and look at where USDCAD actually pays. For many, the profitable window is a short stretch from the New York open until early afternoon, with the rest of the day contributing little beyond costs. A pair with a narrow productive window rewards focus and punishes all-day watching.
Is USDCAD followed closely with oil, and when has the relationship broken down?