Where my exits slip, market vs limit for taking profit
I wanted to know whether my exits were costing me, so I looked at how I took profit over a few months. I split them into limit orders sitting at my target and market orders where I closed by hand.
The limit orders were filled at the target price almost every time, or sometimes slightly better. There wasn't much to say about them. The manual market closes were different. When I closed by hand during fast moves, I often got a worse price than the one I clicked on, especially around session opens. The difference was small each time, but across many trades it was real.
That told me two things. First, using a limit order at the target is better when I'm sure about the level. Second, manual closes should be reserved for situations where I really need to get out, and I should do them when the market is calm if I can.
For stops, I can't use limits, so the only way to improve is to avoid the times when slippage is worse and to give the stop room.
Where my exits slip, market vs limit for taking profit
Re: Where my exits slip, market vs limit for taking profit
Something I noticed after doing a similar review is that the manual closes were not just worse on price, they were also often earlier than the plan. I would see a candle against me and bail, then price would go to the target anyway. So the cost was not only slippage, it was also giving up part of the move. Splitting exits into planned limit fills and discretionary closes, and then checking how each group did against the original target, showed me how much of my result came from nerves rather than the market.
It’s Fairman 
Re: Where my exits slip, market vs limit for taking profit
For stops, the only thing I found that actually helps is avoiding the moments where slippage is worst. I do not hold through high impact releases, I close before rollover when the spread blows out, and I am careful around the first minutes of a session open. That does not remove slippage, but it reduces the worst cases. I also check the stop fills on the statement every month so I know what normal looks like. If the slippage suddenly gets worse, that is something I would raise with the broker.
It’s Fairman 
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Where my exits slip, market vs limit for taking profit
The split into limit targets and manual market closes is the right frame. The early bail point is usually the cost that hurts more than the slip itself.
Say you track 80 gold or EURUSD exits over six weeks and tag each one as planned limit or discretionary market. The chart (illustration) uses a made up split of 50 limits and 30 market closes: the limits average about 0.05 pips better than the target, while the market closes average 0.7 pips worse and leave about 1.2R of unfinished move on the table when price later tags the original target.
That unfinished move is not slippage. It is a decision cost, and it only shows up if you compare the exit to the plan rather than to the fill alone.
For the times a market close is still required, I wait for a quieter second rather than clicking into a spike candle. The same exit order at a calm print costs less than the same order on the wick.
Do you log discretionary exits as their own bucket in the journal? Or do you only look at fill quality after the fact?
Say you track 80 gold or EURUSD exits over six weeks and tag each one as planned limit or discretionary market. The chart (illustration) uses a made up split of 50 limits and 30 market closes: the limits average about 0.05 pips better than the target, while the market closes average 0.7 pips worse and leave about 1.2R of unfinished move on the table when price later tags the original target.
That unfinished move is not slippage. It is a decision cost, and it only shows up if you compare the exit to the plan rather than to the fill alone.
For the times a market close is still required, I wait for a quieter second rather than clicking into a spike candle. The same exit order at a calm print costs less than the same order on the wick.
Do you log discretionary exits as their own bucket in the journal? Or do you only look at fill quality after the fact?
-
FXS Prop Desk
- Posts: 1689
- Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am
Re: Where my exits slip, market vs limit for taking profit
The result matches what most traders find: limit orders at the target fill at the price or better, while manual closes slip. How big was the difference per trade on average?
For scalpers, even half a pip per trade on manual exits makes a real difference over a month. One option is to always have a limit at the target and only close manually when you have a specific reason, like an approaching news release, rather than as the normal way to exit.
For scalpers, even half a pip per trade on manual exits makes a real difference over a month. One option is to always have a limit at the target and only close manually when you have a specific reason, like an approaching news release, rather than as the normal way to exit.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Where my exits slip, market vs limit for taking profit
One quirk of limit targets catches people on shorts. Most platforms draw candles from the bid, and the buy limit that closes a short fills on the ask, so the target only fills once the bid trades down to the target minus the spread.
If the spread is 0.8 pip, a short target at 1.09000 needs the bid at 1.08992. Price can print a low of 1.08995, look as if it tagged the level, and leave the order sitting there.
That near miss is where a lot of manual closes start, because the trader sees the touch and clicks out at market. Setting short targets a spread inside the level, or switching on the ask line, removes most of them.
On the size of the difference asked about above, small numbers add up quickly. Say half a pip is lost on 120 manual exits a month at 1 lot, which is 5 dollars each and 600 dollars in total, before counting any move given up early.
Stops have the mirror case. A long's stop fills on the bid, so the candles show it honestly, while a short's stop fills on the ask and can be hit with no visible touch on bid candles.
If the spread is 0.8 pip, a short target at 1.09000 needs the bid at 1.08992. Price can print a low of 1.08995, look as if it tagged the level, and leave the order sitting there.
That near miss is where a lot of manual closes start, because the trader sees the touch and clicks out at market. Setting short targets a spread inside the level, or switching on the ask line, removes most of them.
On the size of the difference asked about above, small numbers add up quickly. Say half a pip is lost on 120 manual exits a month at 1 lot, which is 5 dollars each and 600 dollars in total, before counting any move given up early.
Stops have the mirror case. A long's stop fills on the bid, so the candles show it honestly, while a short's stop fills on the ask and can be hit with no visible touch on bid candles.
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Where my exits slip, market vs limit for taking profit
Closing half a position at a first target and letting the remainder run is usually described as a way to feel better about trades. Mathematically it does something more specific: it reshapes the distribution of outcomes. Fewer trades end as full losses after being in profit, and fewer large winners are captured at full size.
Whether expectancy improves depends on how price behaves after the first target. If moves tend to extend, the partial exit gives up some profit on the closed half. If moves tend to stall and reverse, the partial exit rescues gains that would otherwise vanish. The method itself does not decide which situation applies; the market's behaviour does.
Costs also matter. Two exits mean two commissions or two crossings of the spread on the closed portions, and small lot sizes may not divide cleanly on every account type. On a tight scalping target, the extra friction can consume much of the benefit.
The practical test is to log the same entries under both rules: full exit at one target, and split exit. Comparing average result per trade, not win rate, shows whether the split genuinely adds expectancy or merely smooths the equity curve.
Whether expectancy improves depends on how price behaves after the first target. If moves tend to extend, the partial exit gives up some profit on the closed half. If moves tend to stall and reverse, the partial exit rescues gains that would otherwise vanish. The method itself does not decide which situation applies; the market's behaviour does.
Costs also matter. Two exits mean two commissions or two crossings of the spread on the closed portions, and small lot sizes may not divide cleanly on every account type. On a tight scalping target, the extra friction can consume much of the benefit.
The practical test is to log the same entries under both rules: full exit at one target, and split exit. Comparing average result per trade, not win rate, shows whether the split genuinely adds expectancy or merely smooths the equity curve.