MT4 accounts use one of two execution modes, and they handle fast markets in opposite ways.
Instant execution: the order is filled at the requested price or not at all. If the price moved, you get a requote — a new price to accept or reject. Common in fast markets and on news.
Market execution: the order is filled at the best available price when it reaches the server. No requotes, but the fill can differ from the price shown (slippage).
Practical differences:
Instant execution can cause missed trades during the moves scalpers want most.
Market execution guarantees a fill but not a price.
Some instant-execution accounts allow a "maximum deviation" setting, which accepts small price changes automatically.
For scalping, most traders prefer market execution and measure slippage, rather than dealing with requotes.
Which execution mode does your account use, and how often do you see requotes?
FXS Prop Desk, I moved to market execution for scalping after a month of missed fills on instant during London opens. The requotes arrived exactly on the moves I wanted, and by the time I accepted the new price the setup was gone.
Slippage on market fills is real, though. On my EURUSD book the average negative slip sits near 0.2 pips in quiet hours and closer to 0.6 around Tier 1 releases, which I fold into the stop distance before entry.
The maximum deviation setting on some instant accounts is a halfway house. I tried 1 pip for a week and still lost fills when the book jumped further, so I stopped fighting it.
For prop accounts the choice is often made by the firm, not by the trader. If the platform forces instant, I simply skip the first 30 seconds after any major print rather than arguing with requotes.
I am on market execution now and log slip on stops separately from entries. Which mode are you on, and have you split those two measurements yet?
Market execution gets far more informative once you split slippage into negative and positive fills. On a fair execution model price can move for you as well as against you, so over a few hundred fills the two should at least be in the same range.
On one account I logged 300 market orders and found 41 percent filled worse than requested, 9 percent better and the rest exact. That imbalance told me more about the dealing setup than anything in the account terms.
Pending orders need their own line in that log too. A buy stop on a market execution account becomes a market order when triggered, so it can slip, while a limit order should fill at its price or better, never worse.
If limit orders on your account are filling worse than their price, that is worth a support ticket with the ticket numbers attached. I have had two adjusted that way.
Anything under one positive slip for every three negatives makes me look harder at the provider. What ratio do you see on your own fills?
Everyone has a story. The trade that was perfect, the click that was instant, and then the platform came back with a new price, 1.5 pips worse, and the move was already gone.
One requote is noise. Ten requotes, all on winning setups, is a pattern worth documenting. Some execution models do show a tendency to reject or reprice orders when price moves in the client's favor during the processing delay, and to fill cleanly when it moves against.
Evidence beats suspicion here. A simple sheet with columns for time, direction, requested price, filled price, order result and eventual trade outcome gives a clear picture after a month or two. If rejections cluster on winners, the data will say so. If they're evenly spread, the feeling was probably confirmation bias.
Either answer is useful. One protects against a bad venue, the other protects against paranoia.
Fifty rows like that say far more than a feeling does. If most of the requotes sit in rows where price later moved in the trader's favor, the pattern is hard to argue with. And if the log shows nothing unusual, that's good news and worth knowing too.
What does the record look like for rejected or requoted orders: random, or tilted toward winners?