Advertisement IC Markets

Account Types: Choosing Between Standard, Raw, and Others

Compare ECN/Raw spread brokers, analyze execution speeds, report slippage, and evaluate commission structures for high-frequency traders.
Post Reply
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Account Types: Choosing Between Standard, Raw, and Others

Post by Fairman »

Account Types: Choosing Between Standard, Raw, and Others

Brokers often offer several account types. The names differ, but the choices usually reduce to a few trade-offs.

A standard account typically charges no commission and builds costs into wider spreads. Pricing is simple, and it suits traders who place few trades, hold positions longer, or want predictable costs. Spreads might start around one pip for major pairs.

A raw or ECN account offers tight spreads, sometimes near zero, with a fixed commission per lot. It tends to be cheaper for active traders, particularly scalpers and day traders, since the sum of spread and commission is often lower than the standard spread.

Premium or VIP accounts offer reduced costs for larger balances or higher volume, along with extras such as dedicated support.

Cent and micro accounts, discussed earlier, serve beginners.

Swap-free and professional accounts add other differences. Professional classification can increase leverage but remove protections, so understand the trade-offs before applying.

To choose, calculate your total cost per round trip, including commission, for your usual pair and trading hours. Compare account types with your own numbers, using your average lot size and trade frequency.

Also check whether execution differs by account type. Some brokers route raw accounts differently from standard ones.

Review the choice periodically as your style and volume change.

Practical step: compute the total cost per lot of a round trip for each account type of your broker, at the spread you typically see.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: Account Types: Choosing Between Standard, Raw, and Others

Post by Fairman »

Professional classification is the one to be careful with. More leverage sounds nice, but losing negative balance protection and other retail rules is a big trade. Negative balance protection means that in a sudden gap, like the franc event in 2015, you can't lose more than your deposit. Without it, a gap through your stop can leave you owing the broker money. For most retail traders that tail risk isn't worth the extra leverage, especially since good risk management rarely needs more than the leverage retail accounts already allow. If a broker pushes the upgrade hard, ask yourself why they want you to give up those protections.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: Account Types: Choosing Between Standard, Raw, and Others

Post by Fairman »

Run the numbers with your own average lot and trade count. For someone trading a few times a week, the difference between standard and raw can be small, for a scalper it can be most of the edge. Example: a standard account at 1.2 pips on EURUSD versus a raw account at 0.2 pips plus 7 dollars commission per lot round trip. On one lot, the standard costs 12 dollars and the raw costs 2 plus 7, so 9 dollars. On thirty lots a month that's about 90 dollars saved. On 300 lots it's around 900. Check the commission per side versus round trip carefully, since brokers quote it differently.
It’s Fairman :geek:
FXS Prop Desk
Posts: 1689
Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am

Re: Account Types: Choosing Between Standard, Raw, and Others

Post by FXS Prop Desk »

Calculate the break-even trade frequency between account types. For example, if the raw account works out three tenths of a pip cheaper per trade than the standard one, a trader making only a few trades a month may not notice the difference, while one making several trades a day saves a lot.

Some brokers also offer different leverage or margin conditions by account type, which is worth checking.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Account Types: Choosing Between Standard, Raw, and Others

Post by Shadow Trader »

The comparison is easiest to feel when it is measured against the target rather than per lot. On a 5 pip target, a 1.2 pip standard spread uses 24 percent of the move before anything else happens.

The raw example above works out to 0.9 pips once the 7 dollar commission is turned into pips on a standard lot, so the same target loses 18 percent. Six points of the target on every trade is a large share of a thin edge.

Two details can shrink that gap. Raw spreads widen off peak like any other, so at a quiet hour the 0.2 can become 0.8, and some brokers set a minimum commission per ticket that hits very small lot sizes harder than the headline rate suggests.

Commission on other pairs is worth checking too. If it is charged on the notional value converted to dollars, a lot of GBPJPY or GBPUSD costs more than a lot of EURUSD, because 100,000 pounds is worth more than 100,000 euros.

Has anyone compared the overnight swap on the two account types at the same broker? It usually comes out identical, but where it differs, anyone holding past rollover may find it outweighs the spread saving.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Account Types: Choosing Between Standard, Raw, and Others

Post by Shadow Trader »

Advertised figures are averages over the whole day, and a scalper's trades are not spread evenly across the day. The cost that matters is the one paid at the hours the trades actually happen.

One way to get it is to export a month of trades and compare each fill with the mid price at that second. Say 60 trades on the standard account come out at 1.5 pips on average rather than the 1.2 quoted since most sit near the London open.

Raw spreads move at those same moments, so the 0.2 might average 0.4 there, which with the 7 dollar commission makes 1.1 pips. The gap between the two accounts is then 0.4 pips, or 4 dollars a lot, rather than the 3 dollars from the headline numbers.

On 30 lots a month that is 120 rather than 90, and on 300 lots it is 1,200. The ranking rarely flips, but the size of the saving can shift by a third once real fills are used.

Many brokers allow a second account type under the same profile at no cost. Running both at minimum size for two weeks at the usual hours settles the question better than any comparison table.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Account Types: Choosing Between Standard, Raw, and Others

Post by Shadow Trader »

Trust in a trading forum depends on the honesty of shared results. Posts that show only winners, omit costs, or conceal drawdowns mislead readers and damage the community's value.

Good standards include sharing both wins and losses, stating the sample size and period, disclosing the broker and account type, and including spread and commission in results. Where possible, linking to verified statements or exports from the platform adds credibility.

Clear labeling distinguishes live from demo results and backtests from forward tests. Explaining the strategy's logic, rather than only the outcome, allows others to evaluate it. Admitting uncertainty and acknowledging limits of the data signals integrity. Communities that reward detailed, honest posts, and treat unverifiable claims with polite skepticism, tend to attract serious traders. Over time, a culture of transparency filters out promoters and builds a knowledge base that members can rely on when making their own decisions.

Forum moderators and members who gently ask for sample size, costs, and drawdown on every performance claim help set standards that benefit everyone reading.
Post Reply