Pips flatter. R tells the truth once size varies.
All-in cost in R means: (spread paid + commission + estimated slip) divided by the stop I planned, in pips. A 0.8 pip cost on a 2-pip stop is 0.4R dead before the idea works. That number decides whether a setup is tradable at 08:05 or only in a quieter pocket. I log it for EURUSD and gold separately because the ratio changes.
Worked example. EURUSD raw account: 0.1 spread, commission equal to about 0.7 pips round trip, average slip 0.1. Total 0.9 pips. On a 3-pip stop that is 0.3R per trade. With a 1.5R target, the trade has to be right a lot more often than the chart suggests to break even. Move the stop to 6 pips and cost drops to 0.15R. Same broker, same pair, very different maths.
When mentees show me pip journals with no R cost, I send them back to rebuild a week. Without that, they are ranking strategies by vanity units.
Add one column to your journal: cost in R. It takes ten seconds per trade.
How to calculate all-in cost in R-multiples not just pips
-
LondonScalper
- Posts: 965
- Joined: Sat Sep 05, 2026 7:54 am
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: How to calculate all-in cost in R-multiples not just pips
I started logging cost in R after a week where my pip journal looked fine and the account did not. Same 0.9 to 1.1 pip all-in on EURUSD, but half the trades used a 2 to 3 pip stop, so each one paid 0.3R to 0.5R before the idea had a chance.
The attached illustration fixes the cost at 1.1 pips and varies the stop. At 2 pips you are already at 0.55R dead, and at 4 pips it is still 0.28R, above the 0.25R line I skip at the London open.
Only once the stop gets to 6 or 8 pips does cost fall into a quieter pocket. That changes which setups I allow before 08:15.
A tight Asian range break that needs a 3 pip stop is fine on paper and expensive in R, so I wait for a quieter spread or I pass. Gold is worse on the same sheet, so I refuse any gold scalp where all-in cost is over 0.2R.
Do you recalculate the R cost when you widen a stop mid-trade, or do you keep the planned stop as the denominator? I keep the plan, otherwise a panic widen quietly shrinks the reported cost.
The attached illustration fixes the cost at 1.1 pips and varies the stop. At 2 pips you are already at 0.55R dead, and at 4 pips it is still 0.28R, above the 0.25R line I skip at the London open.
Only once the stop gets to 6 or 8 pips does cost fall into a quieter pocket. That changes which setups I allow before 08:15.
A tight Asian range break that needs a 3 pip stop is fine on paper and expensive in R, so I wait for a quieter spread or I pass. Gold is worse on the same sheet, so I refuse any gold scalp where all-in cost is over 0.2R.
Do you recalculate the R cost when you widen a stop mid-trade, or do you keep the planned stop as the denominator? I keep the plan, otherwise a panic widen quietly shrinks the reported cost.
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: How to calculate all-in cost in R-multiples not just pips
LondonScalper, the piece I would add to your worked example is the break even win rate, because that is where cost in R really bites. With 0.3R of cost and a 1.5R target, a winner nets 1.2R and a loser costs 1.3R, so you need about 52% winners just to stay flat.
At a 6 pip stop the same cost is only 0.15R. Now a winner nets 1.35R, a loser costs 1.15R, and break even falls to roughly 46%.
Without any cost the same 1.5R setup breaks even at 40%. So the 3 pip version needs twelve extra winners per hundred trades just to pay for execution, which almost no M1 edge I have seen can carry.
Partial exits are the other leak. Every extra exit adds its own slip, so a trade closed in three pieces at 0.1 pip average slip each carries more cost than the single exit the journal assumes.
I now log cost in R at entry and again at the final exit. Do you count partials as one trade with blended cost, or as separate lines in your sheet?
At a 6 pip stop the same cost is only 0.15R. Now a winner nets 1.35R, a loser costs 1.15R, and break even falls to roughly 46%.
Without any cost the same 1.5R setup breaks even at 40%. So the 3 pip version needs twelve extra winners per hundred trades just to pay for execution, which almost no M1 edge I have seen can carry.
Partial exits are the other leak. Every extra exit adds its own slip, so a trade closed in three pieces at 0.1 pip average slip each carries more cost than the single exit the journal assumes.
I now log cost in R at entry and again at the final exit. Do you count partials as one trade with blended cost, or as separate lines in your sheet?
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: How to calculate all-in cost in R-multiples not just pips
An R-multiple expresses a trade's result in units of initial risk. A trade that risks 5 pips and makes 10 pips has a result of 2R. A trade that loses the full stop is -1R. This normalization allows comparison across different pairs, sizes, and stop distances.
For scalpers, R-multiples reveal how a strategy behaves independent of lot size and instrument. A system averaging 0.15R per trade after costs gains 15 percent of its risk amount on average with each trade, regardless of pair.
Costs deserve special treatment, because with tight stops, spread can consume a large share of R. A 5-pip stop with a 1-pip spread means the spread alone costs 0.2R. Tracking the net R-multiple, after costs, gives a realistic view. Distribution analysis, including how often trades end near -1R, near 0R, and above 1R, highlights where the edge comes from. Using R makes risk management clearer, as a daily loss limit can be set in terms of total R, such as three losses worth.
For scalpers, R-multiples reveal how a strategy behaves independent of lot size and instrument. A system averaging 0.15R per trade after costs gains 15 percent of its risk amount on average with each trade, regardless of pair.
Costs deserve special treatment, because with tight stops, spread can consume a large share of R. A 5-pip stop with a 1-pip spread means the spread alone costs 0.2R. Tracking the net R-multiple, after costs, gives a realistic view. Distribution analysis, including how often trades end near -1R, near 0R, and above 1R, highlights where the edge comes from. Using R makes risk management clearer, as a daily loss limit can be set in terms of total R, such as three losses worth.