Advertisement IC Markets

Comparing Your Broker's Feed to a Second Source After a Stop-Out

Compare ECN/Raw spread brokers, analyze execution speeds, report slippage, and evaluate commission structures for high-frequency traders.
Post Reply
FXS Prop Desk
Posts: 1689
Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am

Comparing Your Broker's Feed to a Second Source After a Stop-Out

Post by FXS Prop Desk »

When a stop is hit at a price that looks suspicious, the useful question is not "was it a stop hunt?" but "did the market actually trade there?" A second price source answers that.

How to check:
  1. Note the exact time and price of the stop fill from your account history.
  2. Open the same pair and timeframe on a different broker or data provider, adjusting for time zone.
  3. Compare the high/low of the candle at that time, ideally on M1 or tick data.
  4. Check the spread: a long position's stop is triggered by the bid, a short's by the ask.
Common outcomes:
  • The other feed shows a similar price: the move was real, often a brief spike.
  • The other feed shows no such price: possibly a feed spike at your broker, worth raising with support.
  • The difference is the spread: the ask touched the stop while the bid chart never showed it.
Have you ever compared feeds after a stop-out, and what did you find?
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Comparing Your Broker's Feed to a Second Source After a Stop-Out

Post by Shadow Trader »

FXS Prop Desk, the spread case is the one I see most, and it nearly always happens around the daily rollover. Most MT4 and MT5 platforms draw candles from the bid only, so a short stopped out by the ask leaves candles that never seem to reach the stop.

My own example was a EURUSD short with the stop at 1.0862. At 22:00 London the spread went from about 0.3 to 6 pips for a couple of minutes, the bid peaked at 1.0857, and the ask touched 1.0863.
img_13471_r1.png
img_13471_r1.png (102.94 KiB) Viewed 109 times
The chart traces both lines through those minutes, with the bid staying 5 pips under the stop while the ask crossed it. MT4 can show a live ask line, but it keeps no history of it, which is why the candles alone could not explain the fill.

For the second source I would add a time zone step. Many brokers run server time at GMT plus 2 or 3, and that offset moves with the US clocks on different dates from the UK ones, so candles lined up an hour wrong make a real spike look invented.

When neither feed shows the price, I ask support for bid and ask tick history for that minute. That has settled more of these questions than any M1 screenshot.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Comparing Your Broker's Feed to a Second Source After a Stop-Out

Post by Shadow Trader »

FXS Prop Desk, one thing I would add to your second outcome is a tolerance before calling it a feed spike. Two honest feeds can differ by half a pip to a pip on EURUSD in normal hours and by more on crosses, so I only treat a missing price as suspicious when the gap is at least three times the normal spread.

I also try to use two other sources rather than one. If one shows the price and the other does not, I learn more from where the broker sits between them than from either alone.

Timing matters on the complaint side. Several client agreements I have read give a short window, sometimes five working days, to dispute a fill, so a check left for the weekend review can already be too late.

When a broker has agreed it was a bad tick, the fix I have seen is a corrected fill price rather than a reversed trade. The position still counts as closed, so a stop that should never have fired does not get reopened.

Has your desk seen stop fills corrected on a prop account? I would guess the firm's own rules decide that rather than the broker.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Comparing Your Broker's Feed to a Second Source After a Stop-Out

Post by Shadow Trader »

A broker's price feed is rarely a single source. Liquidity aggregation software collects quotes from several banks, non-bank market makers, and ECNs, then constructs a composite feed. The way this composition happens affects what the trader sees.

Some aggregators show the best bid and best ask across all providers, creating tight spreads that may not always be simultaneously tradable. Others apply a fixed markup on top of the best price. A few build a synthetic price by blending sources with weights.

The number and quality of providers influence depth, spread stability, and fill rates. A broker connected to a handful of providers may deliver acceptable spreads in calm markets but show sharp widening when one provider withdraws. Asking support how many liquidity providers feed the account type, and whether the feed is aggregated or single-source, is a reasonable question. Honest answers help in assessing whether the venue suits high-frequency scalping.
Post Reply