Reviewing my five worst trades each month, and what they had in common
at the end of every month, I pull out my five worst trades by result, and I look at them side by side. It's uncomfortable but useful. The point isn't to feel bad, it's to see if they share something.
When I started, I expected them to be a random assortment of bad luck. In practice, they had a lot in common. Most were taken outside my main sessions, most had a wider spread than normal at entry, and several were taken within an hour of a previous loss. They weren't unlucky, they were predictable.
Having that list has changed how I think about risk. I no longer worry as much about the setups themselves. I worry about the conditions around them: the time of day, the spread and my state after a loss. Those are things I can control.
I write down one rule from each month's review, and I add it to my checklist. It's a short list now, and every item on it came from a real trade. That makes it easier to follow than a list of generic rules.
Reviewing my five worst trades each month, and what they had in common
Re: Reviewing my five worst trades each month, and what they had in common
This is a great habit. I tried it and found the same kind of thing. My worst trades were mostly outside my main session and after a loss, not because of the setups themselves. The point about the conditions around the trade being more important than the trade is the key. Now I have rules about time, spread and state, and the setups are the same as before. It is one of the most useful half hours I spend each month, even if it is not a fun one.
It’s Fairman 
Re: Reviewing my five worst trades each month, and what they had in common
Worth doing the same with the five best trades too, side by side with the worst. The contrast shows what the good conditions look like, not just the bad ones. For me the best trades were almost all in the first two hours of London with normal spread and after a break. That gave me a positive picture to aim for, and aiming at something is easier for me than just avoiding things. Doing both side by side takes about an hour once a month and gives me more to work with than weeks of looking at totals.
It’s Fairman 
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Reviewing my five worst trades each month, and what they had in common
Rank the five by R rather than money, otherwise a month where size went up will fill the list with ordinary losses that were simply bigger tickets. Ranking by R puts a 2R loss at half size above a 1R loss at double size, which is the right order.
The common features also need a base rate before they become rules. If three of the five worst trades came after a previous loss, that only means something if far fewer than 60 percent of all the month's trades followed a loss. When most trades sit in that state anyway, the pattern is just the normal mix.
A useful extra pick is the worst rule break that made money. Winners taken outside the plan teach the same lesson as the worst losers, but they never show up in a list sorted by result.
The checklist will also keep growing at one rule a month. Retiring an item once it has gone three months without being needed keeps the list short enough to read before each session.
Do you check whether a new rule actually reduced that kind of trade the following month? Or does it stay on the list for good once it is written?
The common features also need a base rate before they become rules. If three of the five worst trades came after a previous loss, that only means something if far fewer than 60 percent of all the month's trades followed a loss. When most trades sit in that state anyway, the pattern is just the normal mix.
A useful extra pick is the worst rule break that made money. Winners taken outside the plan teach the same lesson as the worst losers, but they never show up in a list sorted by result.
The checklist will also keep growing at one rule a month. Retiring an item once it has gone three months without being needed keeps the list short enough to read before each session.
Do you check whether a new rule actually reduced that kind of trade the following month? Or does it stay on the list for good once it is written?
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Reviewing my five worst trades each month, and what they had in common
Five is a fixed number, which means it samples very differently month to month. In a 25 trade month the worst five are a fifth of everything, and in a 150 trade month they are about 3 percent, the true tail.
A percentage keeps the review comparable. Taking the worst 10 percent gives 3 trades in a 25 trade month, rounding up from 2.5, and 15 in a 150 trade month, which is a big enough group for a pattern to mean something.
It also helps to pull the trade before each one. The point in the opening post about trades within an hour of a loss shows up much more clearly when the prior trade sits next to the bad one, along with the minutes between them.
Worth splitting execution from decisions as well. A loss that was 1R by plan but 1.6R after slippage belongs in a different pile from a trade that should never have been taken, because one fix is the order type and the other is the plan.
Does the worst list ever contain a trade that was fine by every rule? Those are the ones that show the plan itself has a hole.
A percentage keeps the review comparable. Taking the worst 10 percent gives 3 trades in a 25 trade month, rounding up from 2.5, and 15 in a 150 trade month, which is a big enough group for a pattern to mean something.
It also helps to pull the trade before each one. The point in the opening post about trades within an hour of a loss shows up much more clearly when the prior trade sits next to the bad one, along with the minutes between them.
Worth splitting execution from decisions as well. A loss that was 1R by plan but 1.6R after slippage belongs in a different pile from a trade that should never have been taken, because one fix is the order type and the other is the plan.
Does the worst list ever contain a trade that was fine by every rule? Those are the ones that show the plan itself has a hole.
-
FXS Prop Desk
- Posts: 1689
- Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am
Re: Reviewing my five worst trades each month, and what they had in common
The five worst trades rarely turn out to be random. Common patterns include trades taken after a loss, trades outside the normal session, and trades with larger size than planned.
Once a pattern is clear, a specific rule can target it. For example, if three of the five worst trades came after a loss, a cooling-off period after losses might prevent most of that damage next month.
Once a pattern is clear, a specific rule can target it. For example, if three of the five worst trades came after a loss, a cooling-off period after losses might prevent most of that damage next month.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Reviewing my five worst trades each month, and what they had in common
Most traders review losses. It feels productive: find the mistake, fix it, move on. Fewer review the winners, and that's a gap.
A winning trade might have been a perfect execution. It might also have been a lucky escape from a bad entry. Without a review, there's no way to tell the difference, and luck gets mistaken for skill.
Reviewing winners also shows what's working, so more of it can be done deliberately. The best setups often have shared traits that only emerge from side-by-side comparison.
A balanced weekly review looks at the three worst losses, the three best wins, and three randomly chosen trades. The random sample guards against bias, since the extremes stick in memory and the ordinary trades pay the bills.
A simple split makes the weekly routine easier: ten minutes on losses, ten on wins, ten on a random draw. The random draw is the real hero. It shows what ordinary trading looks like, away from the highlights and lowlights that dominate memory.
What does the review routine cover, and has studying winners ever uncovered a surprise?
A winning trade might have been a perfect execution. It might also have been a lucky escape from a bad entry. Without a review, there's no way to tell the difference, and luck gets mistaken for skill.
Reviewing winners also shows what's working, so more of it can be done deliberately. The best setups often have shared traits that only emerge from side-by-side comparison.
A balanced weekly review looks at the three worst losses, the three best wins, and three randomly chosen trades. The random sample guards against bias, since the extremes stick in memory and the ordinary trades pay the bills.
A simple split makes the weekly routine easier: ten minutes on losses, ten on wins, ten on a random draw. The random draw is the real hero. It shows what ordinary trading looks like, away from the highlights and lowlights that dominate memory.
What does the review routine cover, and has studying winners ever uncovered a surprise?