Advertisement IC Markets

Time-of-Day Filters: Matching Your Strategy to the Clock

Discuss 1-minute to 15-minute price action setups, fading intraday momentum, key support/resistance zones, and proven short-term trading methodologies.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Time-of-Day Filters: Matching Your Strategy to the Clock

Post by Shadow Trader »

gwhitlock64 wrote: Sat Oct 24, 2026 2:04 pmAh, that makes sense now, I read it as one cut rather than two, so the 0.14R to 0.18R jump looked dodgy to me. A little running table (trades, total R, average after each cut) would make it obvious at a glance, imo. Im usually the one adding up on a beer mat at the pub quiz, so I appreciate seeing the steps laid out.
Thanks gwhitlock64, and no harm done, the original post really did read like a single cut. A running table is the better way to show it, so here it is laid out row by row.

All four blocks: 260 trades, 26.5R in total, about 0.10R a trade. Without the last block: 220 trades, 30.5R, about 0.14R. Without the middle block as well: 150 trades, 27R, exactly 0.18R.

The four blocks add up as 18R, 3.5R, 9R and minus 4R, so every row can be checked on the same beer mat. Reading down the columns shows the point of the post, with the average climbing at each step while the total peaks after the first cut.

Whenever a post makes more than one cut, that table belongs in it from the start.
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
gwhitlock64
Posts: 60
Joined: Tue Oct 20, 2026 11:01 pm

Re: Time-of-Day Filters: Matching Your Strategy to the Clock

Post by gwhitlock64 »

Shadow Trader wrote:Thanks gwhitlock64, and no harm done, the original post really did read like a single cut. A running table is the better way to show it, so here it is laid out row by row.
not sure about "belongs in from the start" tbh, imo a table for every post might be overkill...
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Time-of-Day Filters: Matching Your Strategy to the Clock

Post by Shadow Trader »

A surprising finding for many who analyse their own results: the hour of the day explains more variance in profitability than any indicator setting.

The reason is that market behaviour changes dramatically across the day. Spreads, volatility, trend persistence, mean reversion strength and participation all follow daily rhythms. A strategy built for London open momentum will suffer in the Asian afternoon, however clever the indicator settings.

A time filter is cheap, robust and hard to overfit, with only two parameters: start and end. It also reduces costs, since fewer trades mean fewer spreads paid.

To find the right window, plot net result by hour, as described in earlier posts, and look for broad regions of profitability, not single hours. A window of two or three consecutive profitable hours is more credible than one isolated spike.

Adding a time filter to an existing strategy and comparing the results often produces a bigger improvement than months of tuning other parameters.

A comparison to try: take a strategy with fourteen parameters and a time window of 24 hours, and a version with three parameters and a four-hour window. Test both on a year of out-of-sample data. The simpler one frequently wins on net results after costs, because it trades only when conditions favour it.

The same logic extends to days of the week. A strategy that avoids Fridays after 1 PM New York time, and avoids Monday's first hour, can improve its profile with no new indicators at all.

These filters are also less likely to be overfitted, since they have an economic rationale: liquidity, spreads and participation patterns genuinely differ across the clock.

How much of the strategy's profit comes from a few hours of the day, and what happens when the others are removed?
Post Reply