Advertisement IC Markets

Comparing planned R to actual R on every trade, where execution leaks

Document your personal trading journey. Track daily equity curves, review winning and losing streaks, share trade screenshots, and get constructive feedback.
Post Reply
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Comparing planned R to actual R on every trade, where execution leaks

Post by Fairman »

Comparing planned R to actual R on every trade, where execution leaks

I added two columns to my journal: the R I planned for a trade, based on my entry, stop and target, and the R I actually got. Differences between the two show where execution is leaking.

On winning trades, the actual R was often a bit less than planned, because I closed early or got a small slippage on the exit. On losing trades, it was sometimes a little more than one R because of slippage on the stop or because I moved it. Separately these look like small things, but together they were a noticeable part of my result.

When I split the leaks by cause, early exits turned out to be the biggest one. I was taking profit before the target on setups where I'd planned to wait. That's a behaviour problem, not a market one. The slippage was smaller and was concentrated around session opens.

Now I know where to focus. I'm working on holding to the plan for the exits, and I'm avoiding entries at times where slippage is worse. I'll post an update in a month with how the gap between planned and actual has changed.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: Comparing planned R to actual R on every trade, where execution leaks

Post by Fairman »

A detail on how I split the leaks by cause. For every trade where actual R differs from planned, I add a short tag: early exit, late exit, slippage on entry, slippage on stop, moved stop. After a month I count the tags and add up the R lost for each. It sounds like extra work, but it only takes a few seconds per trade, and it showed me very clearly that early exits were costing more than everything else combined.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: Comparing planned R to actual R on every trade, where execution leaks

Post by Fairman »

For the early exits, what I am trying now is setting the take profit order the moment I enter and then closing the platform tab or looking away. If I am not watching every tick, I am less tempted to close early. I still manage the trade if something changes, like a news headline, but I am no longer reacting to every small wiggle against me. Too soon to say how it is going, but I will update. Leaving the trade alone is harder than it sounds.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Comparing planned R to actual R on every trade, where execution leaks

Post by Shadow Trader »

How the early exit cost is measured matters. If a trade closed at plus 0.6R would later have hit its stop, the early exit actually saved 1.6R, so the tag should record what the plan would have produced, not assume the target was reached.
img_13555_r1.png
img_13555_r1.png (56.58 KiB) Viewed 198 times
Say 50 trades were planned at plus 0.3R each, 15R in total, and the actual result came in at 5R. The chart (illustration) splits that 10R gap by tag, with early exits at minus 6R costing more than moved stops, slippage on stops and slippage on entries combined at minus 4R.

With the counterfactual measured properly, the early exit figure can shrink or even flip on a strategy where many trades reverse before the target. That is a useful check before treating the leak as pure behaviour.

The session open slippage is also easy to put a number on. Compare the average R lost per trade in the first 15 minutes after the open with the rest of the day, and if the gap is large, a short delay costs very little.

Does a stop that gets moved closer to lock in profit count as a leak here, or only a stop moved further away? They show up in the same column but come from very different decisions.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Comparing planned R to actual R on every trade, where execution leaks

Post by Shadow Trader »

One adjustment makes the slippage tag much easier to read, which is recording it in pips as well as in R. The same slippage costs very different amounts of R depending on how tight the stop was.

Say entry and stop slippage add up to 0.6 pips on a losing trade. On a 4 pip stop that is 0.15R, on 6 pips 0.10R, on 10 pips 0.06R, on 15 pips 0.04R and on 20 pips only 0.03R.
img_13555_r2.png
img_13555_r2.png (54.4 KiB) Viewed 189 times
Over 100 losing trades that is the difference between 15R and 3R from identical execution, as the chart (illustration) shows across the five stop sizes. Mixing those trades in one column makes the leak look like it comes and goes, when it is really the stop size that changed.

It also changes what to fix. If the R leak sits almost entirely on the tightest setups, widening those stops slightly or skipping them at the session open may do more than any work on behaviour.

Spread at entry is worth a column for the same reason, since it is a cost that never shows as slippage. Does the planned R in the journal already include the spread, or is it measured from the mid price?
FXS Prop Desk
Posts: 1689
Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am

Re: Comparing planned R to actual R on every trade, where execution leaks

Post by FXS Prop Desk »

Planned R against actual R is one of the clearest execution checks. What was the average gap on losing trades? Often the leak is on that side too, from stops that slip or exits taken a bit late.

If most of the shortfall on winners comes from early closes, a test with a fixed limit order at the target for a few weeks shows how much is being left on the table. For many traders the difference is larger than the cost of spreads.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Comparing planned R to actual R on every trade, where execution leaks

Post by Shadow Trader »

Every trade starts with a plan: an entry, a stop, a target, and therefore an expected reward-to-risk ratio. The realized result usually differs. Tracking the gap between planned R and realized R, trade by trade, isolates problems that overall profit hides.

The gap has several sources. Entries filled later than planned shrink the reward and enlarge the risk. Stops that slipped extend losses beyond one R. Targets exited early cut winners short, and stops widened mid-trade turn a planned one R loss into something larger. Each source can be given its own tag.

Summing the average shortfall by cause shows where the most value leaks. A strategy with a respectable planned expectancy can deliver a poor realized one if most of the drift comes from a single habit, such as moving stops. In that case the strategy is sound and the execution is the target for improvement.

The metric also protects against a different error: changing a working setup because results disappointed, when planned versus realized data would have shown that the plan was rarely followed. A setup can only be judged once it has actually been executed as written.
Post Reply