Advertisement IC Markets

Roundup: Overtrading and boredom trades, the friction that works for scalpers

Master exponential money management, position sizing calculators, strict daily stop-loss limits, and overcoming FOMO on micro-timeframes.
Post Reply
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Roundup: Overtrading and boredom trades, the friction that works for scalpers

Post by Fairman »

Roundup: Overtrading and boredom trades, the friction that works for scalpers

Overtrading is harder to notice for scalpers because a lot of trades is the job. The board has several threads that each attack it from a different angle: boredom, lunch, late NY, quiet Fridays, the day after big news. Here's the combined picture.

Know the signs

The overtrading signs thread gives a usable list. Trades outside your planned session, entries on pairs you don't normally trade, setups with only part of your criteria, and costs becoming a large share of gross profit. That last one is a good objective check: if spread and commission are eating a growing slice of what you make, you're probably taking trades that don't earn their cost.

The troubleshooting thread lists the causes: boredom, FOMO, chasing losses, excitement after wins, believing more trades mean more profit, no daily limit, and the platform just being open. A reply adds one that's easy to miss: waiting for a scheduled release. The hour before a big number is often slow, and if the plan is to trade the number, boredom in that hour turns into filler trades.

Boredom, not FOMO

The boredom trades thread makes an interesting claim: most bad London clicks weren't FOMO, they were boredom. Quiet tape, spread fine, brain wanting action. The fix there was a written minimum tape condition before any order is allowed, so inactivity counts as following the plan rather than being lazy.

Time-of-day traps
  • Lunch. The lunch thread closes the platform, or at least disables one-click and hides M1, then reopens with a mini checklist for the afternoon. A reply has a neat version: switch the terminal to a demo login at lunch, so charts and levels stay put but nothing clicked can cost money.
  • Late NY. That thread uses a hard clock: after a set London time, new risk is blocked unless an event trade was planned on paper. Choppy tape and odd spreads plus fatigue is where process scores go to die.
  • Quiet Fridays. The low volatility Friday thread found the worst Friday trades almost all came in the slowest hour, when a tiny range looks like a breakout and a small wick looks like a rejection. The mouse needs a job that isn't clicking.
  • Last hour of any session, according to a reply in the troubleshooting thread, after sitting there a while with nothing.
The day after a big day

The news day thread describes a different trigger. After a big volatile day, the next one feels dull, and your sense of normal is still set to yesterday. Ranges are usually smaller after a big event, so chasing yesterday's kind of move means forcing trades. Replies suggest writing the expected range for the next day the night before and comparing it with what just happened.

Limits that help

The threads mostly agree on a mix: a maximum trades per session based on your own stats, trading only the two or three hours with your best results, stopping after a set number of trades without a clean setup, and a physical tally. One reply suggests a sticky note with your allowed trades, crossing one off each entry.

The only disagreement is whether to close the platform or keep it open with friction. Both worked for someone. The common ground is that discipline while staring at noise doesn't.

What time of day do your filler trades happen, and what did you change to stop them?

Threads this pulls from
It’s Fairman :geek:
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
FXS Prop Desk
Posts: 1689
Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am

Re: Roundup: Overtrading and boredom trades, the friction that works for scalpers

Post by FXS Prop Desk »

One friction method that works well for scalpers: a short written note required before every trade, just pair, direction and the reason in a few words. It adds maybe ten seconds, but boredom trades rarely survive having to explain themselves in writing.

The cost share check is a great objective signal. A related one is average holding time. When overtrading starts, trades often get shorter and more frequent, so a sudden drop in average hold time on a given day can be a useful warning before the P&L shows anything.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Roundup: Overtrading and boredom trades, the friction that works for scalpers

Post by Shadow Trader »

Between 8pm and 2am in New York, the majors often sit in a narrow band. Nothing moves, and the mind starts to fill the silence.

A boredom entry looks like a real one. The chart shows a small pullback, an indicator turns, and the click happens. But the signal wasn't a signal. It was the brain looking for stimulation.

The result is a series of small trades with no edge, each paying the spread. Four or five of those can cost more than a whole good session earns.

A few signs help catch it: entering without being able to state the specific reason in one sentence, checking the clock more than the chart, or opening a second platform to look for something to do.

When the market is quiet, doing nothing is a position, and it has positive expectancy compared with paying spread for noise.

How are boredom entries spotted and stopped when the chart goes flat?
Post Reply