Twenty Questions to Ask Before Every Trade
A short list of questions can catch mistakes that analysis alone misses. Use these as an extended checklist, especially for important trades.
Market context:
1. What is the higher-timeframe bias?
2. Where is price in the range: premium or discount?
3. What liquidity has been taken, and what remains?
4. Is there upcoming news that could disrupt this?
5. Is this a liquid session?
Setup quality:
6. What exactly is my trigger?
7. Is the zone fresh and meaningful?
8. Did a structure shift confirm the move?
9. Is there displacement behind it?
10. Does the reward-to-risk meet my minimum?
Risk:
11. Where is my stop, and why there?
12. What is my risk percentage?
13. Have I calculated the lot size correctly?
14. Does this overlap with other open trades?
15. Is my daily limit still intact?
Mindset:
16. Am I calm and focused?
17. Am I trying to recover a loss or prove something?
18. Would I take this trade if I'd just won three in a row? Lost three?
Exit:
19. What's my target, and what invalidates the idea?
20. What will I do if price hits my stop?
Not every question needs a long answer. If you cannot answer one, pause.
Some traders choose five or six of these as their main checklist and keep the full list for review.
Better questions lead to better trades.
Twenty Questions to Ask Before Every Trade
Twenty Questions to Ask Before Every Trade
It’s Fairman 
Re: Twenty Questions to Ask Before Every Trade
I don't actually go through all twenty for every trade. I picked the six that catch my most common mistakes and those are on a sticky note. The full list is for bigger trades or when something feels off. To choose your six, look at your last month of losing trades and note which question would have stopped each one. For me it was mostly news timing, trading against the higher timeframe, and entering before the candle closed. Your list will be different. Review it every couple of months, because once a mistake stops showing up in the journal, that question can come off the note and something else can take its place.
It’s Fairman 
-
LondonNewsTrader
- Posts: 421
- Joined: Mon Sep 21, 2026 9:30 am
Re: Twenty Questions to Ask Before Every Trade
I'd make this one more specific, because "is there news" is easy to answer yes to every day and then ignore. Three sub-questions work better: what is the next high-impact release for either currency in the pair, how many minutes away is it, and will my target realistically be hit before then? If the answer to the last one is no, the trade becomes a bet on the release whether I intended that or not.
It also links to question 13. Holding a full-size position into CPI with a stop that assumes normal spreads is a different trade from the one drawn on the chart, even if the lot size calculation was correct.
Re: Twenty Questions to Ask Before Every Trade
For the first couple of weeks I'd answer them in writing. After that they become automatic and you'll run through the important ones in your head in a few seconds. A shortened version of five key questions is useful after that: what's the higher timeframe bias, is there news in the next hour, where is the stop and why, what's the size for my risk, and am I calm or chasing something. Write those five on a card next to the screen. Go back to the full list for any trade that feels unusual or when you notice your results slipping.
It’s Fairman 
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Twenty Questions to Ask Before Every Trade
Timing is the practical problem with a list this long for scalping. At around 5 seconds a question, all twenty take 100 seconds, which is more than a full M1 candle and often the whole entry window.
One way round it is to split the list by when the answer can change. Questions 1 to 5 and number 15 hardly change within a session, so they can be answered once before it starts and revisited only after a release or a big loss.
That leaves the setup and risk questions, 6 to 14, for the moment of entry, and most of them become a glance once the levels are already marked. Question 13 in particular can be done in advance by writing the lot size for two or three likely stop distances next to the screen.
The mindset ones work better as a fixed rule than as a question. Asking am I calm in the middle of a fast move tends to get a yes every time, while a rule such as no new trade for 15 minutes after two straight losses answers number 17 without asking it.
Order matters too. Putting the questions that can cancel a trade outright first, like the daily limit and the news check, saves running through the rest only to stop at the end.
One way round it is to split the list by when the answer can change. Questions 1 to 5 and number 15 hardly change within a session, so they can be answered once before it starts and revisited only after a release or a big loss.
That leaves the setup and risk questions, 6 to 14, for the moment of entry, and most of them become a glance once the levels are already marked. Question 13 in particular can be done in advance by writing the lot size for two or three likely stop distances next to the screen.
The mindset ones work better as a fixed rule than as a question. Asking am I calm in the middle of a fast move tends to get a yes every time, while a rule such as no new trade for 15 minutes after two straight losses answers number 17 without asking it.
Order matters too. Putting the questions that can cancel a trade outright first, like the daily limit and the news check, saves running through the rest only to stop at the end.
-
FXS Prop Desk
- Posts: 1689
- Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am
Re: Twenty Questions to Ask Before Every Trade
Twenty questions is a lot to go through before every trade, especially for scalpers. Some traders split them: a longer list for the session plan, and a shorter list of three or four questions before each entry.
The most useful short questions are often: is this my setup, where is the stop, what is the risk, and is there news soon. If any answer is unclear, the trade is skipped.
The most useful short questions are often: is this my setup, where is the stop, what is the risk, and is there news soon. If any answer is unclear, the trade is skipped.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Twenty Questions to Ask Before Every Trade
FXS Prop Desk's four question version raises the obvious next step, which is checking whether each question earns its place. The simplest way is to note which question cancelled a trade every time one does.
After a couple of months the skipped trades become a small test of their own. Say 40 setups were cancelled, 25 by the news check, 10 by the daily limit and 5 by question 9 on displacement.
Then follow each skipped setup to see what it would have done. If 4 of the 5 displacement skips would have reached the target, that question is cancelling good trades and probably needs a clearer definition or removal.
The news skips need a different reading. A skipped trade that would have won is not proof the news check is wrong, because the point of that question is avoiding the occasional slip through a release, which a handful of winners does not measure.
Fairman's sticky note of six questions works best with this kind of review behind it. Questions that never cancel anything over a month or two can come off, and the space goes to whichever mistake the journal shows next.
After a couple of months the skipped trades become a small test of their own. Say 40 setups were cancelled, 25 by the news check, 10 by the daily limit and 5 by question 9 on displacement.
Then follow each skipped setup to see what it would have done. If 4 of the 5 displacement skips would have reached the target, that question is cancelling good trades and probably needs a clearer definition or removal.
The news skips need a different reading. A skipped trade that would have won is not proof the news check is wrong, because the point of that question is avoiding the occasional slip through a release, which a handful of winners does not measure.
Fairman's sticky note of six questions works best with this kind of review behind it. Questions that never cancel anything over a month or two can come off, and the space goes to whichever mistake the journal shows next.
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Twenty Questions to Ask Before Every Trade
Tax rules for trading profits differ enormously across countries, and some places treat forex gains as capital gains, others as income, others under special regimes. Nothing in a forum post replaces advice from a qualified local professional, and the aim here is knowing what to ask.
Useful questions: How are gains classified for an individual trader? Is there a threshold at which trading is regarded as a business? How are losses treated, and can they offset other income or be carried forward? Which currency and exchange rate apply when converting profits? Does the country tax gains on unrealized positions at year end? What records must be kept, and for how long?
Practical prep makes the meeting more productive: annual statements from every broker, a spreadsheet of deposits and withdrawals, and a clear list of costs like data and software subscriptions.
Early planning avoids nasty surprises, including the situation where a profit has been withdrawn and spent, and a bill arrives later.
What was the most useful thing learned about trading taxes, and which assumption turned out wrong?
Useful questions: How are gains classified for an individual trader? Is there a threshold at which trading is regarded as a business? How are losses treated, and can they offset other income or be carried forward? Which currency and exchange rate apply when converting profits? Does the country tax gains on unrealized positions at year end? What records must be kept, and for how long?
Practical prep makes the meeting more productive: annual statements from every broker, a spreadsheet of deposits and withdrawals, and a clear list of costs like data and software subscriptions.
Early planning avoids nasty surprises, including the situation where a profit has been withdrawn and spent, and a bill arrives later.
What was the most useful thing learned about trading taxes, and which assumption turned out wrong?
Re: Twenty Questions to Ask Before Every Trade
Splitting the news question into three parts is better, because I answer yes to "is there news" nearly every day and then do nothing with it. The question about whether the target gets hit before the release is the one that changes the decision. A 12 pip target in a market that normally moves 3 pips an hour is not going to be reached in 25 minutes, so the trade is really a bet on the number.
I put it into a quick calculation. Say CPI is in 40 minutes. If my average M5 range is 4 pips and I need 12, a rough estimate is 3 bars of travel, but with a pullback in the middle, call it 8 bars, so 40 minutes. That's cutting it close with no margin, so I skip. If the target is 6 pips and the release is 45 minutes away, I take it with 0.5 lots and a 6 pip stop, 30 dollars risked.
The link to question 13 is a good catch. I once held 1 lot into a number with a stop that assumed a 1 pip spread, and the fill came at 9 pips worse. The lot calculation was right, but the trade drawn on the chart wasn't the one I had.
Which question do you find people skip most often? Mine is the one about whether I'd take the trade again if I'd just lost the last one.
I put it into a quick calculation. Say CPI is in 40 minutes. If my average M5 range is 4 pips and I need 12, a rough estimate is 3 bars of travel, but with a pullback in the middle, call it 8 bars, so 40 minutes. That's cutting it close with no margin, so I skip. If the target is 6 pips and the release is 45 minutes away, I take it with 0.5 lots and a 6 pip stop, 30 dollars risked.
The link to question 13 is a good catch. I once held 1 lot into a number with a stop that assumed a 1 pip spread, and the fill came at 9 pips worse. The lot calculation was right, but the trade drawn on the chart wasn't the one I had.
Which question do you find people skip most often? Mine is the one about whether I'd take the trade again if I'd just lost the last one.
It’s Fairman 