The Trader Who Took Only A+ Setups (Story)
A composite story based on patterns many traders experience. Names are illustrative.
Let's call him Bolu. For a long time, he took every setup that looked decent. His journal showed about 120 trades in three months, with mixed results and a lot of stress.
One evening he graded each trade from A+ to C, based on his checklist. Then he calculated the average result of each grade. The picture was revealing.
- A+ trades (fewer than 20): strong positive results
- B trades: roughly break-even
- C trades: consistently negative
Most of his activity was in B and C trades, and they were canceling out the gains from his best ones.
Bolu made a decision: only A+ setups from now on, even if it meant trading far less. He expected to feel bored. Instead, he felt relieved. The pressure to find trades disappeared.
Over the next three months, he took about 25 trades. His win rate and average reward were noticeably better, and his stress dropped.
He summarized it to a friend: "I didn't improve my strategy. I just stopped trading the parts of it that don't work."
You may already have an edge hidden inside your results. The question is whether you've measured it.
Grade your trades for a month, then cut what loses. The best improvement is often subtraction.
The Trader Who Took Only A+ Setups (Story)
The Trader Who Took Only A+ Setups (Story)
It’s Fairman 
Re: The Trader Who Took Only A+ Setups (Story)
For anyone wondering how Bolu decided what counted as A+, the trick was being boring about it. He took his best 20 trades from the journal and listed what they had in common. Only setups that ticked every box from that list got taken. It wasn't fancy, just honest.
It’s Fairman 
-
LondonNewsTrader
- Posts: 421
- Joined: Mon Sep 21, 2026 9:30 am
Re: The Trader Who Took Only A+ Setups (Story)
Fewer than 20 is a small sample to build a whole approach on, so I'd add one safeguard to Bolu's method: grade the trade before entry, in writing, not afterwards in the review. When the grade is assigned after the result is known, winners tend to get promoted to A+ and losers drift down to C, and the subtraction ends up removing trades by outcome rather than by quality. A grade written into the journal at entry time keeps the comparison honest.
Re: The Trader Who Took Only A+ Setups (Story)
Something people don't expect with fewer trades: the waiting is harder than the trading. Bolu said the first month felt like doing nothing. Having a list of other things to do during the session, like journaling or marking levels, helped him not take the B setups out of boredom. Setting alerts at the A+ levels and walking away from the screen helped even more. If price gets there, the phone tells you, and you come back to check the full checklist calmly. Sitting and watching every candle is what makes a B setup start looking like an A+ after a couple of hours.
It’s Fairman 
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: The Trader Who Took Only A+ Setups (Story)
The subtraction only works if Bolu is ready for what a low trade count does to the monthly results. About 25 trades in three months is roughly 8 a month, so a single bad week carries a lot of weight.
Say his A+ setups win 55 percent of the time at 2R. Each trade is then worth 0.55 times 2 minus 0.45, which is 0.65R on average, or a little over 16R across 25 trades.
Yet with 8 trades a month, 2 winners or fewer means a red month, since 3 wins give 6R against 5R of losses. The odds of 2 or fewer wins at 55 percent come to roughly 9 percent, so about one month a year goes red on a method that is working.
That red month is exactly when B setups start looking good again. Knowing the number in advance makes it easier to treat it as expected noise rather than a sign the filter is broken.
Did he also note the A+ setups he missed or skipped? Those show whether the filter is strict or just whether he happened to be at the screen.
Say his A+ setups win 55 percent of the time at 2R. Each trade is then worth 0.55 times 2 minus 0.45, which is 0.65R on average, or a little over 16R across 25 trades.
Yet with 8 trades a month, 2 winners or fewer means a red month, since 3 wins give 6R against 5R of losses. The odds of 2 or fewer wins at 55 percent come to roughly 9 percent, so about one month a year goes red on a method that is working.
That red month is exactly when B setups start looking good again. Knowing the number in advance makes it easier to treat it as expected noise rather than a sign the filter is broken.
Did he also note the A+ setups he missed or skipped? Those show whether the filter is strict or just whether he happened to be at the screen.
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: The Trader Who Took Only A+ Setups (Story)
One thing the story leaves open is whether the better results came from the filter or from the market. The second three months were a different period, so trends, ranges and volatility were not the same as when he took everything.
A cheap way to separate the two is to keep paper logging the B and C setups while trading only the A+ ones. No money goes on them, just the entry, stop, target and result written down at the time.
Say over those three months he paper logs 60 B and C setups next to his 25 live A+ trades. If the B and C trades also improved compared with the first period, part of the gain came from friendlier conditions rather than subtraction.
If the B and C setups stayed flat or negative while the A+ trades kept their edge, the filter really is doing the work. That is much stronger evidence than two different periods placed side by side.
It also keeps the grading honest, because he still has to judge every setup he sees, not only the ones he takes. Did he keep watching the lower grade setups at all, or did he stop looking once he decided to skip them?
A cheap way to separate the two is to keep paper logging the B and C setups while trading only the A+ ones. No money goes on them, just the entry, stop, target and result written down at the time.
Say over those three months he paper logs 60 B and C setups next to his 25 live A+ trades. If the B and C trades also improved compared with the first period, part of the gain came from friendlier conditions rather than subtraction.
If the B and C setups stayed flat or negative while the A+ trades kept their edge, the filter really is doing the work. That is much stronger evidence than two different periods placed side by side.
It also keeps the grading honest, because he still has to judge every setup he sees, not only the ones he takes. Did he keep watching the lower grade setups at all, or did he stop looking once he decided to skip them?
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: The Trader Who Took Only A+ Setups (Story)
Slippage is usually discussed as a cost, but it can work in the trader's favour. When an order fills at a better price than requested, that is price improvement, or positive slippage.
A healthy execution environment shows both. Over a large sample, positive and negative slippage should be roughly balanced, with the net depending on market conditions.
Some brokers advertise statistics on price improvement, showing the percentage of orders filled at a better price. It is worth checking whether the figures cover all orders or only a selected subset, and over what period.
If a trader's own data shows almost no positive slippage, but frequent negative slippage, something in the execution model may be asymmetric. That may be a policy of passing on only negative slippage, or it may be a quirk of the order type being used.
Comparing across brokers on the same strategy shows how common positive slippage is elsewhere.
A related measure is the improvement size, since tiny improvements of a few hundredths of a pip are worth far less than frequent large ones. Averages alone can be misleading, so a histogram of the differences between requested and filled prices is more informative.
What share of your fills show price improvement, and how does it compare with negative slippage?
A healthy execution environment shows both. Over a large sample, positive and negative slippage should be roughly balanced, with the net depending on market conditions.
Some brokers advertise statistics on price improvement, showing the percentage of orders filled at a better price. It is worth checking whether the figures cover all orders or only a selected subset, and over what period.
If a trader's own data shows almost no positive slippage, but frequent negative slippage, something in the execution model may be asymmetric. That may be a policy of passing on only negative slippage, or it may be a quirk of the order type being used.
Comparing across brokers on the same strategy shows how common positive slippage is elsewhere.
A related measure is the improvement size, since tiny improvements of a few hundredths of a pip are worth far less than frequent large ones. Averages alone can be misleading, so a histogram of the differences between requested and filled prices is more informative.
What share of your fills show price improvement, and how does it compare with negative slippage?
Re: The Trader Who Took Only A+ Setups (Story)
Grading at entry is the part that makes this honest. I tried the A+ only approach after reading the story and fooled myself for about six weeks. Looking back, I'd downgraded losing trades to B or C after the result, with reasons like "the entry was a bit early". Of course the A+ pile looked great, since I'd built it from the winners.
So I changed to a checklist before the order goes in. Four items: trend agrees on the higher timeframe, level has a clear reaction, spread under 12 percent of stop, no release within 30 minutes. Four ticks is an A. Three is a B. Anything less I skip. The grade goes in the journal before I click.
After 60 trades, hypothetically, 14 A trades averaged +0.6R, 30 B trades +0.1R and 16 C trades -0.3R. If I only took the A trades at 0.5 lots and 8 pip stops, that's about +24 dollars per trade on average, but only 14 trades, so the income is small. The sample is also under 20, as you say, so I treat it as a lead, not a result.
How strict is your checklist, and does the grade ever change after the entry, say when price moves fast? Also, do you put a different risk size on each grade, or keep it constant until the data is bigger?
So I changed to a checklist before the order goes in. Four items: trend agrees on the higher timeframe, level has a clear reaction, spread under 12 percent of stop, no release within 30 minutes. Four ticks is an A. Three is a B. Anything less I skip. The grade goes in the journal before I click.
After 60 trades, hypothetically, 14 A trades averaged +0.6R, 30 B trades +0.1R and 16 C trades -0.3R. If I only took the A trades at 0.5 lots and 8 pip stops, that's about +24 dollars per trade on average, but only 14 trades, so the income is small. The sample is also under 20, as you say, so I treat it as a lead, not a result.
How strict is your checklist, and does the grade ever change after the entry, say when price moves fast? Also, do you put a different risk size on each grade, or keep it constant until the data is bigger?
It’s Fairman 