Advertisement IC Markets

Logging the trades I didn't take, my missed setups column and what it taught me

Document your personal trading journey. Track daily equity curves, review winning and losing streaks, share trade screenshots, and get constructive feedback.
Post Reply
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Logging the trades I didn't take, my missed setups column and what it taught me

Post by Fairman »

Logging the trades I didn't take, my missed setups column and what it taught me

most journals only record trades I took. I started adding a section for setups that met my criteria but I skipped, and a short reason why. It's been more useful than I expected.

Looking at it after a month, I saw I was skipping a lot of valid setups right after a losing trade. I'd lost one, felt cautious, and then missed the next two, which happened to be winners. That's the reverse of the usual overtrading problem. It was fear, and it was costing me.

Other reasons were more reasonable, like skipping because of news or because the spread was wide. Those I was happy with. The data lets me split the skips into good ones and bad ones.

The bad ones, like fear after a loss or being distracted, are the ones I can work on. I added a rule that if I skip a valid setup, I have to write why in a few words. It makes me think about whether it's a real reason or an excuse.

It's not about regretting what didn't happen. It's about finding patterns in my own behaviour.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: Logging the trades I didn't take, my missed setups column and what it taught me

Post by Fairman »

For anyone setting this up, I keep the skipped setups in the same spreadsheet as my real trades, just with a column marking them as not taken. I record where the entry, stop and target would have been and then fill in what would have happened later, without counting it in my real stats. Keeping it in the same sheet means I can filter and compare the two groups easily, and I can see whether my skipped trades would have done better or worse than the ones I took.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: Logging the trades I didn't take, my missed setups column and what it taught me

Post by Fairman »

One pattern that came out for me was time of day. I skipped far more valid setups in the last hour of my session than earlier on. Partly tiredness, partly feeling like I had already done enough. Seeing that made me decide to either trade the full session properly or end it earlier on purpose. Drifting through the last hour half paying attention was the worst of both, since I was neither resting nor trading well. Picking one and sticking to it has made my sessions calmer.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Logging the trades I didn't take, my missed setups column and what it taught me

Post by Shadow Trader »

The pattern after a loss is easy to put into numbers once the column exists. Say six weeks give 60 valid setups, 20 of them right after a losing trade, and 9 of those 20 get skipped compared with 4 of the other 40.
img_13531_r1.png
img_13531_r1.png (85.77 KiB) Viewed 193 times
That is a 45 percent skip rate after a loss against 10 percent the rest of the time, and the chart (illustration) puts the two side by side. If the 9 skipped trades would have produced 5 winners at plus 1.5R and 4 losers at minus 1R, fear cost 3.5R in that stretch.

The hard part is keeping the column honest. A setup recorded after you have seen where price went tends to look more valid than it did at the time, so the entry, stop and target need to be written down before the outcome is known.

A screenshot with the time showing, taken at the moment of the skip, solves most of that. Without it, the skipped group slowly fills up with the winners you remember and loses the ones you forget.

How do you handle setups that only half met the criteria? Leaving them out keeps the comparison clean, but they might be where most of the hesitation actually sits.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Logging the trades I didn't take, my missed setups column and what it taught me

Post by Shadow Trader »

The not taken column tends to flatter itself in a quieter way too. Skipped setups get scored at the exact planned entry and exit, with no spread, no slippage and none of the second guessing that real trades go through.

Say the taken trades average 0.4R after costs and the skipped ones score 0.6R on paper. Before calling that a fear problem, take off a realistic cost, perhaps 0.1R on a tight scalping stop, and score each skipped trade with the exit habits actually used live.

If the gap shrinks to 0.1R or less, the skips were roughly as good as the takes and the problem is smaller than it looked. If it stays at 0.2R or more, the hesitation really is costing money.

It also helps to split skipped from missed. A setup seen and passed over is a decision, while one that formed during lunch or a phone call is a schedule question, and mixing the two blurs both answers.

A third tag worth having is skipped for a written rule, such as news due within ten minutes. Those should score worse than average over time, and if they do not, the rule itself deserves a second look.
FXS Prop Desk
Posts: 1689
Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am

Re: Logging the trades I didn't take, my missed setups column and what it taught me

Post by FXS Prop Desk »

Skipping valid setups right after a loss shows up in a lot of journals once people start logging them. A useful follow-up is to calculate what those skipped trades would have produced. If the missed setups were profitable, the caution after a loss is costing you money, and that gives a strong reason to trust the rules more.

Some traders handle it with a simple rule: after a loss, the next valid setup must be taken at normal size. It sounds strict, but it removes the hesitation completely.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Logging the trades I didn't take, my missed setups column and what it taught me

Post by Shadow Trader »

Missing a trade costs exactly zero. Taking a bad one costs real money.

That asymmetry is easy to forget in the heat of a session. The market doesn't hand out medals for participation. Every setup missed because attention was elsewhere, or because the rules said wait, is simply a trade that never existed.

The only situation where a missed trade hurts is when it triggers the urge to compensate by taking the next marginal setup at a worse price.

It helps to think in terms of opportunity flow, not individual trades. A scalper with a solid edge will see dozens of valid setups over a week. Missing a few changes nothing meaningful about the monthly result.

A mantra some use: "There's always another one." It's cheesy, and it works.

Another reframe: the market produces roughly the same number of opportunities per week regardless of whether any single one gets taken. Missing a trade doesn't reduce the supply, it just frees up the next decision for a clearer head.

It may help to quantify the point. Suppose the strategy produces about 40 valid setups per week. A trader who is present and focused might take 34 of them, missing six due to breaks, distractions or hesitation. If the average setup has an expectancy of 0.15R, the six missed trades cost about 0.9R over the week, a modest sum, roughly equivalent to one decent winner.

Now compare that with the cost of the usual reaction to a miss: a revenge or catch-up trade. A single impulsive entry with no edge and a bad price can easily cost 1R or more. Chasing the missed trade is often several times more expensive than the miss itself.

That's why many experienced traders measure "missed opportunities" in a spreadsheet, not to feel bad about them, but to see how small the number really is compared with the damage done by trying to claw them back.

A related practice is a written rule that says: if a setup has already moved more than a set distance from the entry trigger, skip it. A rule like that converts a stressful in-the-moment decision into a mechanical one, and the miss becomes a non-event.

What reminders help during the moments when a missed move stings?
Post Reply