Advertisement IC Markets

Roundup: Order types for scalpers, plus the typos that cost more than bad entries

Compare ECN/Raw spread brokers, analyze execution speeds, report slippage, and evaluate commission structures for high-frequency traders.
Post Reply
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Roundup: Order types for scalpers, plus the typos that cost more than bad entries

Post by Fairman »

Roundup: Order types for scalpers, plus the typos that cost more than bad entries

This one pulls together the order-type threads and the order-entry error threads, because they turned out to be the same conversation. How you send an order and what you accidentally send are both execution costs, and both are mostly fixable with setup rather than willpower.

Market or limit for entries

The limit vs market thread frames it as a cost question. Market orders guarantee the fill and charge you spread plus slippage. Limits get a better price and no negative slip, but no guarantee of a fill, and the missed trades are often the best ones because price never came back. The point it makes, and which almost nobody does, is that a fair comparison needs both sides: average cost per market fill, and the result of the limit orders that didn't fill.

The EA limit-entry thread is the practical version. Switching to limits at the signal level with an expiry of a few candles cut the average cost and removed entry slippage, at the price of skipped trades. Two replies are worth reading. One tried a middle option, a limit placed slightly beyond the signal so it fills on a small pullback. Another argued for accepting the missed winners as the price of the method rather than bolting on a market fallback, because the fallback brings the costs back. There isn't a consensus there, which is honest.

Stop-limit in fast markets

The stop-limit thread covers the in-between order: a trigger plus a worst acceptable price. Useful for breakout entries where a bad fill wrecks the R:R. Dangerous as a stop loss, because if price gaps through your limit you're simply not out. That caveat is the most important line in the thread.

Basics that still catch people
  • Which side of the quote triggers what. A reply in the order types thread points out buy orders trigger on the ask and sells on the bid, which matters a lot at rollover and around news when the spread blows out.
  • Old pending orders filling days later in different conditions.
  • Buy stops left above price into CPI, triggered by the spike and reversed straight through.
  • Fix from the pending mistakes thread: every pending order gets an expiry, end of session by default.
Fat fingers and typos

The two error threads are short and very practical. The common expensive mistakes are buy instead of sell, an extra zero on the lot size, a limit and stop confused so it fills instantly, and a stop on the wrong side. The fixes that came up:
  • Set a maximum lot per order in the platform or client area, near your normal maximum. The worst typo becomes survivable.
  • Watch the default lot trap. MetaTrader remembers your last size, so a quick click after a bigger trade becomes a bigger trade.
  • Say the pair and direction out loud before sending. Sounds silly, catches the wrong-direction click.
  • Keep an error log with the circumstances. If most mistakes happen late at night, the fix is not trading late at night, not "being more careful".
Overall the threads agree market orders aren't bad, just most expensive when things are fast or thin. The disagreement is only about how much missed business you'll accept to avoid paying that.

Anyone measured their limit fill rate against the trades they missed? I'd like to see real numbers on how often the missed ones were the big winners.

Threads this pulls from
It’s Fairman :geek:
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
FXS Prop Desk
Posts: 1692
Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am

Re: Roundup: Order types for scalpers, plus the typos that cost more than bad entries

Post by FXS Prop Desk »

Most order typos can be designed out. A few setup changes that prevent most of them: fixed default lot sizes per chart, a confirmation dialog only for orders above a set size, and the one-click panel disabled on any chart kept purely for analysis.

On market versus limit for entries, a middle option is a marketable limit, a limit order placed a pip or two through the current price. It fills almost like a market order but caps slippage at that distance, which is useful around the open when spreads move quickly.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Roundup: Order types for scalpers, plus the typos that cost more than bad entries

Post by Shadow Trader »

Some brokers offer FIX protocol connections, the same standard institutions use. It promises lower latency and direct, structured order flow, and it appeals to anyone with a fast strategy.

Access isn't automatic. Many brokers offer it only above a minimum balance, sometimes tens of thousands of dollars, or only on specific account types. Some charge a monthly fee. Some require the client to sign a separate agreement.

Beyond access, there's the work. FIX is a message-based protocol with its own session handling, sequence numbers and recovery rules. A client has to handle logons, heartbeats and resends correctly. Libraries exist in several languages but need configuration.

The benefits are genuine for the right user: lower overhead than platform-based trading, access to market data streams, and cleaner control of order types.

For many retail scalpers, the gap between a good VPS with a standard platform and a FIX connection is smaller than assumed. The bottleneck is more often the broker's liquidity and execution policy than the protocol.

Before investing time, it's worth measuring the existing latency and fill quality, and asking whether the potential gain justifies the effort.

Is a FIX connection in use, and did it change the quality of execution noticeably?
Post Reply