Including the spread in my risk calculation, the small number that changed my size
my position size used to come from the distance between my entry and my stop. It sounds right, but it ignores the spread, which matters a lot on a tight scalp.
If I'm long, my stop triggers on the bid, but I enter at the ask. So the real distance I can lose is the stop distance plus the spread. On a stop of a few pips, a spread of one pip is a big share. If I size using the stop distance only, my actual risk is higher than I think, and the gap changes with the spread at the time.
Now I add the spread to the stop distance when I calculate the lot size. If the spread is wider than usual, the lot size gets smaller automatically, or I skip the trade. It makes my risk consistent in money terms and takes the guess out of it.
The effect is small on most trades but it showed up in my records. My average loss was slightly above the planned amount before I did this, and now it's close. It also reminded me that wide spread moments are costly in more than one way.
Including the spread in my risk calculation, the small number that changed my size
Re: Including the spread in my risk calculation, the small number that changed my size
This is a small change with a real effect. I do the same, and I also use the average spread at my trading time rather than the current one when I plan the trade in advance, then recheck at entry. If the spread at entry is clearly wider than average, I skip rather than size down, because a wide spread usually means something is going on. With a really tight stop, leaving the spread out can make the real risk noticeably higher than planned.
It’s Fairman 
Re: Including the spread in my risk calculation, the small number that changed my size
Worth noting that this matters more for longs than shorts on some setups. When you go long, the fill is at the ask while the exit happens on the bid price. Going short flips it, selling at the bid and getting stopped at the ask, so it costs you there too. Either way it adds to the distance. Including it in the calculation makes every trade's risk honest. I put the spread into the calculator as its own field so I cannot forget it when I am rushing before an entry.
It’s Fairman 
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Including the spread in my risk calculation, the small number that changed my size
Adding spread to stop distance is the honest risk formula for a long scalp. Entry at the ask and stop on the bid means the quoted stop understates what you can lose by exactly the spread at fill time.
On a 6 pip stop with a 0.8 pip spread, sizing off 6 pips overstates the lot by about 13 percent. That gap is small once and real across a month of short stops.
Using average session spread for planning, then rechecking at entry, is the right two step. If the live spread is clearly wide, skipping beats shrinking the lot into a messy tape.
Shorts pay the same tax in reverse, so the calculator field should not be labelled long only. Either direction, spread is part of the distance.
Do you hard code a minimum stop plus spread floor? Or do you refuse any trade where spread is more than a set share of the stop?
On a 6 pip stop with a 0.8 pip spread, sizing off 6 pips overstates the lot by about 13 percent. That gap is small once and real across a month of short stops.
Using average session spread for planning, then rechecking at entry, is the right two step. If the live spread is clearly wide, skipping beats shrinking the lot into a messy tape.
Shorts pay the same tax in reverse, so the calculator field should not be labelled long only. Either direction, spread is part of the distance.
Do you hard code a minimum stop plus spread floor? Or do you refuse any trade where spread is more than a set share of the stop?
-
FXS Prop Desk
- Posts: 1691
- Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am
Re: Including the spread in my risk calculation, the small number that changed my size
Your note that the average loss is now close to the planned amount is a useful measurement in itself. Whatever gap is left once the spread is included comes mostly from slippage on the stop, so it is worth logging planned risk next to the realised loss on each trade and grouping the difference by hour. If the overshoot only appears around the London open or data releases, a small slippage allowance added to the stop distance for those hours does the job without shrinking every other trade.
Rounding is the other quiet leak. If the calculator says 0.37 lots and the account steps in 0.01 that is harmless, but on an account with 0.1 lot steps rounding to the nearest step can add back more risk than the spread did. Rounding down every time keeps the money at risk at or below plan.
Rounding is the other quiet leak. If the calculator says 0.37 lots and the account steps in 0.01 that is harmless, but on an account with 0.1 lot steps rounding to the nearest step can add back more risk than the spread did. Rounding down every time keeps the money at risk at or below plan.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Including the spread in my risk calculation, the small number that changed my size
Commission belongs in the same distance as the spread. At 7 dollars per lot round turn on EURUSD it works out to 0.7 pip, so the 6 pip stop above, plus the 0.8 pip spread and that 0.7, really loses 7.5 pips when it gets hit.
At 1 percent of 10,000 the honest size is 100 divided by 75 dollars per lot, which rounds down to 1.33 lots. Sized off the 6 pips alone it would be 1.66 lots, and a full stop out then costs about 124.50, nearly 1.25 percent.
The rounding point above matters most on small stops like this. With 0.1 lot steps, 1.33 becomes 1.3, while rounding 1.66 to the nearest step would give 1.7 and push the overshoot higher still.
Spread can also widen at the stop rather than at the entry. A long's stop fires on the bid, so a rollover spread jumping from 0.8 to 3 pips drops the bid by 1.1 pips with no change in the mid price, enough to tag a stop sitting close.
Is the calculator here set up with commission as its own field next to spread? Separate fields show which one moved when a loss comes out wrong.
At 1 percent of 10,000 the honest size is 100 divided by 75 dollars per lot, which rounds down to 1.33 lots. Sized off the 6 pips alone it would be 1.66 lots, and a full stop out then costs about 124.50, nearly 1.25 percent.
The rounding point above matters most on small stops like this. With 0.1 lot steps, 1.33 becomes 1.3, while rounding 1.66 to the nearest step would give 1.7 and push the overshoot higher still.
Spread can also widen at the stop rather than at the entry. A long's stop fires on the bid, so a rollover spread jumping from 0.8 to 3 pips drops the bid by 1.1 pips with no change in the mid price, enough to tag a stop sitting close.
Is the calculator here set up with commission as its own field next to spread? Separate fields show which one moved when a loss comes out wrong.
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Including the spread in my risk calculation, the small number that changed my size
Say a trader opens a $150 account and wants to risk 1%, which is $1.50. On EUR/USD, 0.01 lots is about $0.10 a pip. So $1.50 buys a 15 pip stop at the minimum size. Fine for a 15 pip stop.
Then the setup turns out to need a 30 pip stop. The smallest allowed size now risks $3, which is 2% of the account, double the plan. There is no 0.005 lot to drop down to. The choices are to skip the trade, take a different setup, or quietly accept the bigger risk.
On a tight 5 pip stop it goes the other direction. 0.01 lots risks $0.50, about 0.33% of the account, less than the plan, and the spread or commission becomes a larger share of what is at stake.
Small accounts get coarse risk control. The percentage cannot be dialled in smoothly, it moves in chunks.
Some brokers offer finer steps than 0.01 on some instruments, but plenty do not.
How do small-account traders here deal with the 0.01 floor when a setup needs a wider stop?
Then the setup turns out to need a 30 pip stop. The smallest allowed size now risks $3, which is 2% of the account, double the plan. There is no 0.005 lot to drop down to. The choices are to skip the trade, take a different setup, or quietly accept the bigger risk.
On a tight 5 pip stop it goes the other direction. 0.01 lots risks $0.50, about 0.33% of the account, less than the plan, and the spread or commission becomes a larger share of what is at stake.
Small accounts get coarse risk control. The percentage cannot be dialled in smoothly, it moves in chunks.
Some brokers offer finer steps than 0.01 on some instruments, but plenty do not.
How do small-account traders here deal with the 0.01 floor when a setup needs a wider stop?