Comparing the price feeds of two brokers on the same pair, what the differences were
I had accounts with two brokers and ran charts for the same pair side by side for a few weeks. I wanted to see how different the prices were, because I'd heard that feeds vary.
Most of the time, the prices were close, within a fraction of a pip. The differences showed up at specific moments: the opens of sessions, around news releases and near rollover. At those times one feed would spike a little more than the other, or the spread would be wider on one. Highs and lows of candles differed by a pip or two on some bars, which matters if you're trading from the high and low of a range.
That had some practical effects. A level I marked on one chart might be a pip off on the other. A stop that was safe on one feed could have been touched on the other. So I realised I should test my strategy on the feed I trade, not on a different one.
It also taught me not to compare my trades with a friend's on another broker and expect the same result. Small differences exist, and they accumulate.
Comparing the price feeds of two brokers on the same pair, what the differences were
Re: Comparing the price feeds of two brokers on the same pair, what the differences were
This matches what I saw too. The candle highs and lows were the biggest difference, which matters a lot if you trade the Asian range or anything based on exact extremes. One feed had a spike to a high that the other never printed. If I had been using the second feed to mark levels, the range would have looked different and the breakout would have triggered at another price. Now I mark my levels only on the broker I trade with, and I treat anything from another chart as a rough guide.
It’s Fairman 
Re: Comparing the price feeds of two brokers on the same pair, what the differences were
Worth adding that a lot of people mark levels on TradingView and then trade on a different platform. The data source on TradingView may not be your broker at all, so the levels can be a pip or two off from what you are actually trading. For a swing trader that is nothing, but for a scalper with a small stop it can be the difference between being stopped and not. I either use my broker's feed on TradingView if it is available, or I mark the final levels on the trading platform itself.
It’s Fairman 
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Comparing the price feeds of two brokers on the same pair, what the differences were
Marking levels only on the feed you trade is the practical takeaway. A one pip high that exists on broker A and never prints on broker B will invent breakouts and stops that your live account never saw.
Session opens and news are where the feeds diverge most, which is exactly when scalpers care about exact extremes. Quiet mid session bars often match within a tenth of a pip and hide the problem.
TradingView as a marking pad is fine for structure, but the final level should be confirmed on the broker platform before size is calculated. Otherwise the stop distance you typed is not the stop distance you will get.
I would also compare spreads at the same timestamp, not only mid prices. Two brokers can show similar mids and still charge very different costs on the same M5 scalp.
Has anyone logged side by side highs and lows for a full week on one pair? How many bars disagreed by a pip or more in that sample?
Session opens and news are where the feeds diverge most, which is exactly when scalpers care about exact extremes. Quiet mid session bars often match within a tenth of a pip and hide the problem.
TradingView as a marking pad is fine for structure, but the final level should be confirmed on the broker platform before size is calculated. Otherwise the stop distance you typed is not the stop distance you will get.
I would also compare spreads at the same timestamp, not only mid prices. Two brokers can show similar mids and still charge very different costs on the same M5 scalp.
Has anyone logged side by side highs and lows for a full week on one pair? How many bars disagreed by a pip or more in that sample?
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Comparing the price feeds of two brokers on the same pair, what the differences were
Server time is a quieter source of feed differences than the prices themselves. Two brokers with near identical ticks still build different daily and H4 candles if their servers sit in different time zones.
A server on GMT produces a short Sunday bar, so a week has six daily candles instead of five. Say a 14 day ATR covers 12 normal days averaging 80 pips and two Sunday bars of 20 each, then it reads 1,000 divided by 14, about 71 pips instead of 80.
That is roughly 11 percent smaller, so a stop or target set as a fraction of daily ATR comes out tighter on one feed than the other. H4 candles shift too, since a one hour difference in server offset moves every 4 hour boundary.
So a side by side test should line up the server clocks before comparing highs and lows. Otherwise two feeds that agree to a tenth of a pip on M1 can still disagree on every daily level.
Does either broker here run its server on GMT? The Sunday bar is easy to spot on D1, a small candle sitting just before each Monday.
A server on GMT produces a short Sunday bar, so a week has six daily candles instead of five. Say a 14 day ATR covers 12 normal days averaging 80 pips and two Sunday bars of 20 each, then it reads 1,000 divided by 14, about 71 pips instead of 80.
That is roughly 11 percent smaller, so a stop or target set as a fraction of daily ATR comes out tighter on one feed than the other. H4 candles shift too, since a one hour difference in server offset moves every 4 hour boundary.
So a side by side test should line up the server clocks before comparing highs and lows. Otherwise two feeds that agree to a tenth of a pip on M1 can still disagree on every daily level.
Does either broker here run its server on GMT? The Sunday bar is easy to spot on D1, a small candle sitting just before each Monday.
-
FXS Prop Desk
- Posts: 1689
- Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am
Re: Comparing the price feeds of two brokers on the same pair, what the differences were
The differences at specific moments are the important part. Most of the time, feeds agree within a fraction of a pip, but at the open, around news and at rollover they can differ by several pips. Those are exactly the moments where stops and entries are most sensitive.
Did one broker regularly show wider wicks at those moments? That can explain why a stop is hit on one account and not on another, even with the same level.
Did one broker regularly show wider wicks at those moments? That can explain why a stop is hit on one account and not on another, even with the same level.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Comparing the price feeds of two brokers on the same pair, what the differences were
Spot forex has no central exchange, so there is no single official tape. Each broker builds its own price stream from its liquidity providers, applies its own markup, and sometimes smooths or filters the result. Two brokers quoting EURUSD at the same moment can show different bids and asks by a fraction of a pip.
That fraction matters. A scalping strategy targeting four or five pips can see its win rate shift materially when entry prices are consistently half a pip apart. Backtests built on one broker's tick history may not transfer cleanly to another.
Some traders run the same strategy on two demo accounts simultaneously to measure the difference. Others compare tick counts per minute, since the number of ticks delivered also varies and can change how tick-based indicators behave. The practical takeaway: historical data should come from the same broker intended for live trading, or at minimum from a feed that has been checked against it.
That fraction matters. A scalping strategy targeting four or five pips can see its win rate shift materially when entry prices are consistently half a pip apart. Backtests built on one broker's tick history may not transfer cleanly to another.
Some traders run the same strategy on two demo accounts simultaneously to measure the difference. Others compare tick counts per minute, since the number of ticks delivered also varies and can change how tick-based indicators behave. The practical takeaway: historical data should come from the same broker intended for live trading, or at minimum from a feed that has been checked against it.