Advertisement IC Markets

Planning Reward Targets Honestly: Probability Before Ambition

Master exponential money management, position sizing calculators, strict daily stop-loss limits, and overcoming FOMO on micro-timeframes.
Post Reply
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Planning Reward Targets Honestly: Probability Before Ambition

Post by Fairman »

Planning Reward Targets Honestly: Probability Before Ambition

A target of three times the risk looks attractive. Whether it is realistic depends on how often price actually gets there.
diagram.png
diagram.png (37.17 KiB) Viewed 221 times
Estimate the probability. If your setup reaches 1R about 60 percent of the time, 2R about 35 percent, and 3R about 20 percent, the expectancy of fixed targets differs. With a 1R target and a 1R stop, a 60 percent hit rate gives an expectancy of 0.2R. With a 2R target and a 35 percent rate, the expectancy is 0.35 times 2 minus 0.65 times 1, or 0.05R. With a 3R target and a 20 percent rate, it is 0.2 times 3 minus 0.8, or negative 0.2R.

So the most ambitious target is not the best. The target that maximizes expectancy depends on the distribution of how far trades go in your favor, which is why MFE data is useful.

Structure also matters. Targets placed just before significant levels have higher hit rates than those beyond them.

Combine with the costs: after spread, each of these expectancies is slightly lower.

Use your own data. After thirty or forty trades per setup, compute the share reaching 1R, 1.5R, 2R, and 3R, and pick the target with the best expectancy, avoiding overfitting by choosing a round number.

Revisit periodically, since conditions change.

Practical step: calculate the share of your last forty trades that reached 1R, 2R, and 3R at any point.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: Planning Reward Targets Honestly: Probability Before Ambition

Post by Fairman »

The example shows it nicely: the 3R target looks the best on paper and has the worst expectancy. The chart doesn't tell you that, only the hit rates do. Running the numbers: 1R at 60 percent gives plus 0.2R, 2R at 35 percent gives plus 0.05R, and 3R at 20 percent gives minus 0.2R per trade. So the trader holding for the big target is losing money on a setup that's profitable with a closer target. A mixed approach can also work, for example taking half at 1R and leaving half for 2R. Run that through the same hit rates before assuming it's better than a single target.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: Planning Reward Targets Honestly: Probability Before Ambition

Post by Fairman »

Placing targets just before obvious levels rather than at them is a small change that bumps hit rates. Everyone else's orders are sitting right on the level. If resistance is at 1.1000, a take profit at 1.0995 or 1.0990 gets filled more often than one at 1.1000, because price frequently stalls a few pips short when sellers there start working. Also remember your long target triggers on the bid, so the spread works against you there too. On a 40 pip target, giving up 5 pips costs about 12 percent of the reward. Check your own MFE data to see how many trades got within 5 pips and reversed.
It’s Fairman :geek:
FXS Prop Desk
Posts: 1689
Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am

Re: Planning Reward Targets Honestly: Probability Before Ambition

Post by FXS Prop Desk »

Measure these probabilities from your own trade history using maximum favourable excursion. That gives your real hit rates for each target distance, which are often different from what traders assume.

Partial exits at different targets can also combine the advantages of different target levels.

MFE data can be exported from many platforms or calculated from trade logs with high and low prices during each trade.

Once collected, the numbers often show that targets around 1.5R to 2R give the best expectancy, but this varies by setup.

These numbers also suggest why a mixed approach often works: taking part of the position at 1R, where the hit rate is high, and leaving the rest for 2R or more combines a higher hit rate with some of the larger targets. Running that variant through the same probabilities gives an expectancy that can be compared directly with the fixed-target versions in the post.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Planning Reward Targets Honestly: Probability Before Ambition

Post by Shadow Trader »

Running the half at 1R, half at 2R version through the same hit rates gives an interesting answer. Trades that reach 2R have also passed 1R, so 35 percent make 1.5R, 25 percent reach 1R but not 2R, and 40 percent lose the full 1R.

If the stop stays where it was, that middle group makes nothing, half at plus 1R and half at minus 1R, so the expectancy is 0.525 minus 0.4, about 0.13R. That is worse than the plain 1R target at 0.2R.

Moving the stop to entry after the first exit lifts the middle group to plus 0.5R each and the total to 0.25R. The catch is that the 35 percent figure was measured with the original stop, and some of those trades dip back to entry before reaching 2R, so the real number is lower.

The MFE needs one rule to be honest as well. It should only count the excursion before the stop would have been hit, because a trade that tags the stop and then runs to 3R is a loss, not a 3R hit.

How often do people rerun these numbers? Hit rates for 2R and beyond seem to move a lot between quiet and busy months.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Planning Reward Targets Honestly: Probability Before Ambition

Post by Shadow Trader »

Forty trades is a small sample for hit rates. With 60 percent of 40 trades reaching 1R, the standard error is about 7.7 points, so a rough 95 percent range runs from about 45 to 75 percent.

On a 1R target with a 1R stop the expectancy is twice the hit rate minus one, so that range covers anything from minus 0.1R to plus 0.5R. The 2R figure has a similar spread, and its 35 percent could be anywhere from about 20 to 50.

So the gap between 0.2R and 0.05R in the opening example can easily be noise here. Ranking targets needs a few hundred trades, or pooled similar setups.

Costs push in the same direction for every target, since the spread is paid once per trade. Say costs come to 0.1R per trade, then the 1R target drops to plus 0.1R and the 2R target to minus 0.05R, which makes the further target a loser before noise even enters.

Is the MFE in these figures read from the side the target actually fills on? A short's target fills on the ask, which the candles do not show, so an MFE taken from bid candles overstates every short by the spread.
Post Reply