Advertisement IC Markets

Expectancy Per Trade Versus Expectancy Per Hour

Master exponential money management, position sizing calculators, strict daily stop-loss limits, and overcoming FOMO on micro-timeframes.
Post Reply
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Expectancy Per Trade Versus Expectancy Per Hour

Post by Fairman »

Expectancy Per Trade Versus Expectancy Per Hour

Traders usually measure edge per trade. A second measure deserves attention: how much you make per unit of time and effort.

Imagine two strategies. One yields +0.3R per trade, but only two trades appear per week. The other yields +0.1R per trade and generates twenty trades. The second produces 2R per week against 0.6R for the first, even though its per-trade edge is smaller.

But frequency has costs. More trades mean more spreads and commissions, more screen time, more decisions, and more exposure to execution errors. Low-edge strategies are also more sensitive to costs. A 0.1R edge can vanish if the spread consumes 0.1R per trade.

So the useful comparison is net expectancy after costs, multiplied by trade frequency, and weighed against your time and the risk of burnout.

It also affects the speed of learning. A strategy with more trades produces a meaningful sample faster, which helps evaluate whether it works. A swing strategy with ten trades a year takes a long time to verify.

Choose a style that matches your life. A trader with a full-time job and two hours in the evening cannot run a strategy requiring constant attention.

Practical step: compute your net expectancy per week, in R, for your current approach, and compare it with the time you spend.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
LondonNewsTrader
Posts: 421
Joined: Mon Sep 21, 2026 9:30 am

Re: Expectancy Per Trade Versus Expectancy Per Hour

Post by LondonNewsTrader »

The per-hour framing suits news trading in an odd way. A release-based approach might only offer a handful of genuine opportunities a week, so per trade it can look attractive and per hour it looks poor, until you count the hours honestly. If the plan is to be at the screen for ten minutes around 13:30 and then close the platform, the hourly figure can be very good. If you sit there all afternoon waiting and take a few marginal trades out of boredom, both numbers suffer.

So I'd split the time measure in two: hours spent watching and hours with an open position. The gap between them tells you a lot about where the forced trades come from.
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: Expectancy Per Trade Versus Expectancy Per Hour

Post by Fairman »

Worked comparison. Strategy A: plus 0.3R per trade, two trades a week, so about plus 0.6R a week. Strategy B: plus 0.1R per trade, but 15 trades a week, so about plus 1.5R a week. B looks worse per trade and better per week, but it also costs a lot more screen time and is more sensitive to costs. A small rise in spread or slippage could push B's edge close to zero, while A would barely notice. B also needs you at the screen for many hours, with more chances for mistakes. So I'd also measure R per hour of screen time, after costs. For a part time trader, A often wins on that measure even though B produces more.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: Expectancy Per Trade Versus Expectancy Per Hour

Post by Fairman »

The per-hour view also helps with burnout. If a strategy needs eight hours a day for a small edge, the cost isn't only money, it's energy. A slower strategy with fewer hours may be the one you can actually sustain. A strategy you follow for three years beats one you abandon after three months because it wore you out. Signs of burnout are taking trades you'd normally skip, dreading the session and checking the phone constantly outside trading hours. If those show up, it might be the strategy's time demands rather than your discipline that needs fixing.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: Expectancy Per Trade Versus Expectancy Per Hour

Post by Fairman »

How I'd use this in practice: you don't always have to pick one. Run the slow strategy as the base, since it needs little time, and use the faster one only in its best window, for example from the London open at 8am Lagos until about 10am. That way you get most of the faster strategy's edge from its best hours, without the long sessions where results usually fade. Track the two separately in the journal for a couple of months. Often the fast strategy's results improve once it's limited to its best window.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Expectancy Per Trade Versus Expectancy Per Hour

Post by Shadow Trader »

The busier strategy is not always quicker to verify, which runs against the learning point in the opening post. What matters is the edge relative to the spread of results, and a small edge needs far more trades to stand out.

Take the worked example above over 50 weeks, assuming results per trade scatter with a standard deviation near 1R. Strategy A makes 100 trades for 30R with a deviation of 10R on that total, three deviations above zero, while B makes 750 trades for 75R with a deviation near 27R, only about 2.7 clear.

So B earns more, but it is not any faster to prove, and it gets worse if costs rise. An extra 0.05R of cost per trade halves B's edge while barely denting A.

The watching hours versus position hours split suggested above fits neatly here. If B needs 20 hours of watching a week for 1.5R, that is 0.075R per hour, and A at 0.6R for, say, 4 hours is 0.15R per hour.

Does anyone measure a third figure, the R lost to trades taken outside the plan during long sessions? That number might explain much of the gap between the two styles.
FXS Prop Desk
Posts: 1689
Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am

Re: Expectancy Per Trade Versus Expectancy Per Hour

Post by FXS Prop Desk »

The comparison is a helpful way to think about strategy selection. One factor that should be included in the per-hour measure is the screen time needed for each trade. A strategy with fewer trades may need less monitoring, which can make it more practical for traders with limited time, even if its expectancy per hour is lower.

Costs per trade also reduce the advantage of the high-frequency strategy.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Expectancy Per Trade Versus Expectancy Per Hour

Post by Shadow Trader »

Limiting the fast strategy to its best window, as Fairman suggested, raises a measurement question. Results can fade because the market quiets down or because the trader does, and both produce the same falling line while needing different fixes.

This chart breaks a made up version of strategy B down by hour after the London open. The first hour averages plus 0.30R per trade and the second plus 0.18, then it drops to plus 0.04, minus 0.05 and minus 0.08 by the fifth hour.
img_12962_r2.png
img_12962_r2.png (48.17 KiB) Viewed 278 times
Over the first two hours that is about plus 0.24R, while hours three to five net roughly minus 0.03R, so the long session gives back a little of what the morning made. On those figures, stopping two hours in improves both the per trade and the per hour numbers at once.

To separate fatigue from market conditions, start some sessions two hours after the open instead of at it. If the late hours suddenly look fine when you arrive fresh, the problem is stamina, and breaks may help more than a shorter window.

If they stay poor even when you are rested, the market itself is thinning out around that time. Has anyone actually tried the late start test?
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Expectancy Per Trade Versus Expectancy Per Hour

Post by Shadow Trader »

Win rate is the most quoted statistic in trading communities, but it says little on its own. A strategy winning 80 percent of the time can still lose money if the average loss dwarfs the average win. A strategy winning 35 percent of the time can be highly profitable if wins are much larger.

Expectancy combines both dimensions. It equals the win rate multiplied by the average win, minus the loss rate multiplied by the average loss. The result represents the average gain or loss per trade in a unit such as pips or currency.

For scalpers, costs must be included. A positive expectancy before spread and commission can turn negative after them. Computing expectancy net of all costs provides an honest figure. Tracking it over rolling windows, such as the last 100 trades, shows whether the edge is stable or fading. A small positive expectancy multiplied by many trades produces steady growth, which is the essence of scalping. A negative or unstable figure signals that the approach needs revision.
Post Reply