Advertisement IC Markets

A pair by pair review that made me drop two of my favourites

Document your personal trading journey. Track daily equity curves, review winning and losing streaks, share trade screenshots, and get constructive feedback.
Post Reply
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

A pair by pair review that made me drop two of my favourites

Post by Fairman »

A pair by pair review that made me drop two of my favourites

I like trading certain pairs. I find them fun to watch, I know their personalities, and I feel comfortable with them. But last month I finally broke down my results by pair, and the picture was not what I'd assumed.

Two of my favourite pairs were my weakest performers. After costs, they were about break even at best, and they contributed to many of my rule breaks. The pair I considered boring was quietly doing most of the work. Looking at the numbers, I could see I was trading the ones I liked, not the ones that worked.

I made a simple change. I cut the list from five pairs to three, and for the two I removed, I'm only allowing myself to trade them on a demo. If the demo results hold up over a good sample, I'll think about it again.

It felt like a loss at first, because I enjoy those charts. But fewer pairs means less screen time, less noise and more focus on the ones with an edge. I'll update after a month.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: A pair by pair review that made me drop two of my favourites

Post by Fairman »

For anyone wanting to do the same review, I added a pair column to my journal and grouped the results by it. For each pair I looked at the number of trades, average result in R after costs, and how many rule breaks I had on it. The rule breaks were the surprise. My favourite pairs had far more of them, probably because I was more excited watching them and took trades I should not have. Excitement and discipline do not mix well for me.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: A pair by pair review that made me drop two of my favourites

Post by Fairman »

On the demo plan for the two pairs I dropped, I am keeping the same rules and the same journal fields as for live. If they still look weak on demo after a decent number of trades, they stay off the list. If they improve, I will look at what changed, whether it was the market or my behaviour. Either way, it means I am deciding based on results rather than on which charts I enjoy watching. It is a slower path back but a more honest one.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: A pair by pair review that made me drop two of my favourites

Post by Shadow Trader »

One extra split might change which pairs get dropped. Separating each pair's trades into those that followed the rules and those that broke them shows whether a favourite looks weak only because that is where the rule breaks pile up.
img_13553_r1.png
img_13553_r1.png (66.03 KiB) Viewed 192 times
Say a favourite cross had 30 trades averaging minus 0.04R after costs, with 9 of them rule breaks averaging minus 0.6R. The other 21 then average plus 0.2R, better than many boring pairs manage, as the chart (illustration) sets out.

In that case the pair is fine and the problem is how it gets traded. The demo plan above tests part of that, though a demo also lacks the pressure that produced the breaks, so clean results there may flatter the pair.

Sample size is the other caution. With results spread about 1.2R per trade, 30 trades give a standard error near 0.22R, so a gap of a few tenths between two pairs can be pure chance.

Would a rule allowing the favourites back only at reduced risk per trade suit this? It keeps them on the screen but caps the damage while the rule break count is watched.
FXS Prop Desk
Posts: 1689
Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am

Re: A pair by pair review that made me drop two of my favourites

Post by FXS Prop Desk »

Dropping favourite pairs is hard, and most traders never check the numbers because they do not want the answer. Did the two weak pairs lose on costs mainly, or was the win rate itself lower? If it was mostly costs, they might still work at a different time of day when spreads are tighter.

Either way, a breakdown by pair once a quarter is a cheap review that can add a lot to results without changing the strategy at all.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: A pair by pair review that made me drop two of my favourites

Post by Shadow Trader »

One thing to watch after cutting the list is where the missing trades go. Fewer pairs means fewer signals, and the urge to fill the gap often lands on the pairs that were working.

Say five pairs produced 100 trades a month, with the two dropped ones giving 40 trades at minus 0.02R and the other three giving 60 at plus 0.12R. The month was 6.4R in total, and simply removing the weak pairs lifts it to 7.2R with 40 fewer trades.

That only holds if the remaining three keep their own standard. If 20 marginal entries creep in on them at minus 0.1R each, the total drops to 5.2R, below where it started.

So the trade count per pair is worth watching next to the results. A boring pair that suddenly produces twice its usual number of setups is probably being traded with looser eyes rather than offering more opportunities.

When the month is up, it would be interesting to see whether the count on the three remaining pairs stayed flat. That number would say a lot about whether the change stuck.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: A pair by pair review that made me drop two of my favourites

Post by Shadow Trader »

Take one pair and about 60 days of five-minute or fifteen-minute data. For each candle, record high minus low, then average the figure by hour of the day. List it or plot it. What comes out is a volatility clock.

The usual picture for EUR/USD is a rise around London open, another bump when American data lands, a slow fade into the late afternoon, and a floor in the Asian hours. Pair differences are large though, so check the pair in question rather than trusting a general picture. USD/JPY, for example, tends to be busier in Tokyo hours than EUR/USD.

Two details trip people up. Convert everything to one time zone first, since a broker's server clock is often GMT+2 or GMT+3 and can shift with American daylight saving. And think about the spread, because 3 pips of range at 03:00 isn't the same thing as 3 pips at 14:00 when the cost at night is higher.

The table won't hand over entries. It shows when a 5-pip target is ordinary and when it's a stretch.

Which hour came out busiest for your pair, and was there an hour you'd have bet money on that turned out flat?
Post Reply