Advertisement IC Markets

Screenshot, one sentence, done, my minimal journal that I actually keep up

Document your personal trading journey. Track daily equity curves, review winning and losing streaks, share trade screenshots, and get constructive feedback.
Post Reply
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Screenshot, one sentence, done, my minimal journal that I actually keep up

Post by Fairman »

Screenshot, one sentence, done, my minimal journal that I actually keep up

I've tried detailed journals and abandoned them within a week. They take too long and I stop doing them. What finally worked is a really minimal version: one screenshot at entry, one at exit, and one sentence about why I took it.

The sentence is the key part. Forcing myself to write a reason in one line means I can't take a trade without a reason. If I can't summarize why in a sentence, I probably shouldn't be in it. And when I look back, I read the sentences and see patterns like "felt like it was due" or "it looked like it was going to go".

The screenshots let me see what the chart looked like at the time, not what I remember. Memory is biased, and the screenshots are the check.

I keep them in a folder per week, with a simple file name. At the end of the week I scroll through them in about ten minutes and pick out the best and worst. That's it. Small enough that I do it every time, which is more valuable than a perfect system I skip.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: Screenshot, one sentence, done, my minimal journal that I actually keep up

Post by Fairman »

Someone asked how I take the screenshots quickly. On TradingView there is a shortcut that copies the chart image straight to the clipboard, and I paste it into a folder with the date and pair in the file name. On MT5 I use the built in save picture option. The whole thing takes under ten seconds per trade. If it took longer than that I know I would stop doing it, which is the whole reason the detailed journals failed for me.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: Screenshot, one sentence, done, my minimal journal that I actually keep up

Post by Fairman »

The sentence rule has also helped me in the moment, not just in review. A few times I went to write the reason before clicking and could not come up with anything better than it looks like it wants to go up. I closed the order window and moved on. It is a small check, but it catches the impulse trades before they happen instead of after, which is when the journal is most useful. I would much rather skip a trade than write a weak reason for it.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Screenshot, one sentence, done, my minimal journal that I actually keep up

Post by Shadow Trader »

The file name can do a lot of the journal's work if it follows a fixed pattern. Something like 2026-10-19_EURUSD_S_exit_minus1R.png sorts by date automatically, and adding the result at exit lets a plain folder search pull up every loss on one pair in a second.

A second shot of the higher timeframe at entry is worth the extra few seconds. A five minute screenshot hides the context that usually explains a bad entry, such as price sitting right under an hourly level.

The one sentence rule also gives you something to count. Say each sentence starts with a short tag like breakout, pullback or range fade, then after a month the folder tells you how many of each you took and how they did.

The weak reasons stand out even more that way. If 12 of 40 sentences in a month have no real tag and read like the examples above, close to a third of the trading was impulse, and those trades can be compared as a group against the rest.

Do you keep the screenshots after the weekly review, or clear them out? A few months of folders makes a good test set for checking whether a rule change would have kept the good trades.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Screenshot, one sentence, done, my minimal journal that I actually keep up

Post by Shadow Trader »

One gap in any journal of taken trades is the setups that were skipped. If a valid setup appears and gets passed over through hesitation, nothing lands in the folder, so the weekly scroll can never show what hesitation is costing.

A quick fix is a third kind of file, a single screenshot of the skipped setup with the word skip in the name and the same one sentence on why. Say a week has 15 taken trades and 5 skips, and 4 of those skips would have reached target, which is a pattern the usual folder cannot reveal.

It works the other way too. Skips that would have failed are evidence the filter is doing its job, which is reassuring after a slow week.

Storage is not a worry at this scale. Two images of around 150 KB per trade at ten trades a day comes to roughly 750 MB over a year of 250 sessions, small enough to keep every folder.

That makes a longer look back possible, such as rereading every sentence from a losing month in one sitting. A month of reasons read together shows drift in a way single weeks do not.
FXS Prop Desk
Posts: 1689
Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am

Re: Screenshot, one sentence, done, my minimal journal that I actually keep up

Post by FXS Prop Desk »

The requirement to write a reason is actually a filter, as you say. If the reason does not fit in one sentence, the trade probably was not clear enough.

A small addition that does not cost much time: a single word for your state before the trade, like "calm", "bored" or "rushed". After a month, sorting trades by that word often shows very clear differences in results.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Screenshot, one sentence, done, my minimal journal that I actually keep up

Post by Shadow Trader »

Session boundaries on a clock are rough. A better way to see when the market is actually busy is to count ticks per minute, rather than assuming 8am to 12 noon London is always the active window.

A simple script can log the number of quote updates per minute for each pair and plot the result by hour. The shape that appears is often not what the textbook says. Some brokers show a peak at 8:30 to 9:30 London, a dip around 11, and a second surge at 13:30 when New York wakes up. Others show different patterns depending on which liquidity providers feed them.

The tick count isn't the same as true volume, but it correlates, and it reflects the quote stream the account actually receives. That's the one that matters for execution.

Once the chart is built, it's worth comparing across pairs. GBPJPY can peak at different times than EURGBP, and USDCAD has its own rhythm tied to oil and the New York morning.

Anyone who has done this will have noticed it throws up quiet pockets in the supposedly busy hours. Those pockets are good places to avoid.

The script itself is short: subscribe to ticks, increment a counter keyed by the minute, and write the counts to a file at the end of each hour. A week of data is enough to draw the first curve, and a month makes the quiet pockets obvious.

What did the tick count curve look like for your main pair, and did it surprise you?
Post Reply