Advertisement IC Markets

Myth: Indicators Predict the Market

Master exponential money management, position sizing calculators, strict daily stop-loss limits, and overcoming FOMO on micro-timeframes.
Post Reply
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Myth: Indicators Predict the Market

Post by Fairman »

Myth: Indicators Predict the Market

Indicators appear to anticipate moves, so many beginners believe they contain predictive power. In fact, they describe the past in a compact form.

Every standard indicator is a mathematical transformation of past prices, and sometimes volume. Moving averages, oscillators, and bands do not contain information that is not already in the price series. They summarize it, making patterns easier to see.

Where predictive value exists, it comes from the patterns in how markets behave, not from the indicator itself. A momentum oscillator can help identify trends because trends persist to a degree, and a volatility indicator helps because volatility clusters. Those are statistical properties of markets, which the indicators merely measure.

The danger is mistaking correlation for prediction. An indicator crossing a line coincides with moves often enough that it feels predictive, because you remember the hits and forget the misses. Rigorous testing usually shows that simple indicator signals have small or no edge by themselves, after costs.

What indicators do well is structure decisions: they provide objective rules, reduce ambiguity, and make strategies testable.

Use them for what they are. Choose a few that measure things you care about, such as trend, volatility, or momentum, understand their calculation, and test them.

Avoid the temptation to keep adding or swapping indicators in search of a better signal.

Practical step: remove all indicators from a chart, and note what you can still say about trend, volatility, and momentum from price alone.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: Myth: Indicators Predict the Market

Post by Fairman »

The bare chart exercise is a great one. Most of what the indicators were telling me, I could see in swing structure and candle size once they were gone. Try it for a week with just price, maybe one moving average for reference. Mark the swing highs and lows, notice where candles get bigger and where they shrink, and where price stalls. You'll probably find that RSI was mostly telling you price had moved a lot, which you can already see. That doesn't mean indicators are useless afterwards, but you'll understand what each one is measuring and stop treating a cross as a signal from nowhere.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: Myth: Indicators Predict the Market

Post by Fairman »

Where indicators really help is consistency. Two people can disagree about whether a chart looks trending, but not about whether ADX is above 25. That makes them useful as filters in written rules and in backtests. If my rule says only take pullback buys when price is above the 50 EMA and ADX is above 20, I can check every past trade objectively. Without that, my judgement of trending would drift depending on mood and recent results. So the value isn't prediction, it's turning a vague idea into something you can test, follow and review. Keep one or two for that purpose and drop the rest from the chart.
It’s Fairman :geek:
FXS Prop Desk
Posts: 1691
Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am

Re: Myth: Indicators Predict the Market

Post by FXS Prop Desk »

A practical consequence: when testing an indicator-based strategy, it helps to compare it with a version based on simple price rules. If the indicator version does not perform clearly better, the indicator adds complexity without adding information, which is worth knowing.

Indicators can still be useful for consistency, since they apply the same rules every time and reduce subjective judgement.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Myth: Indicators Predict the Market

Post by Shadow Trader »

A useful test of redundancy is to compare indicators against each other rather than against price. RSI, stochastics and CCI with similar lookbacks often move together so closely that a correlation of 0.8 or 0.9 between them would not be surprising.

Three oscillators agreeing then feels like three confirmations, but it is closer to one opinion repeated three times. The same goes for two moving averages of nearby lengths.

My one quibble is about inputs. An indicator built only from closing prices cannot add information, yet one that brings in tick volume, the spread, the time of day or a second market like the dollar index at least has a chance to.

Even then the bar is the one set above, beating a plain price rule after costs. A volume filter that lifts the win rate from 52 to 54 percent across 50 trades is well inside the noise.

The lookback is also a hidden choice. A 14 period RSI on M5 summarises the last 70 minutes, so switching to M15 quietly changes the question from the last hour to the last three and a half hours.

Has anyone tried the price only version of their own filter and found the indicator really did add something? Those cases would be interesting to hear about.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Myth: Indicators Predict the Market

Post by Shadow Trader »

One way indicators come to look predictive is through the choice of settings. Testing many lookbacks and keeping the best one can turn noise into what seems like an edge.

Say an RSI filter is tested at every lookback from 5 to 24 on data where it has no edge, with 100 trades at each setting. In the chart (illustration), the twenty win rates average exactly 50 percent, with the best at 59 for a lookback of 14 and the worst at 42.
img_13349_r2.png
img_13349_r2.png (60.37 KiB) Viewed 177 times
With 100 trades the standard error of a 50 percent win rate is 5 points, so 59 is less than two standard errors above the middle. The best of twenty tries lands about that high fairly often by chance alone.

The neighbours give it away, since 13 scores 47 and 15 scores 51. A real effect tends to show as a plateau across nearby settings, while a lone spike surrounded by ordinary values is what chance looks like.

Writing down how many settings were tried before the winner was picked helps keep this honest. A result that is the best of twenty needs a fresh stretch of data before it means anything.

Does anyone check the settings either side of the one they use? It is a cheap test and catches most of these lone spikes.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Myth: Indicators Predict the Market

Post by Shadow Trader »

Average true range gets less attention than flashy indicators, but it answers a practical question: how far does this pair typically move in a candle?

On a 5 minute chart, EURUSD might have an ATR of 4 pips in calm conditions and 9 in active ones. That one number reframes a lot of choices. A 3 pip stop in a market with ATR of 8 sits inside the noise. A 12 pip target in a market with ATR of 3 will take a long time to reach.

Scalpers use it in three ways. First, to size stops, often at one-half to one times ATR. Second, to set realistic targets. Third, to filter conditions: if ATR is below a minimum threshold, spreads eat too much of the potential move and the setup is skipped.

Unlike many indicators, ATR does not predict direction. It describes the environment, and that is often more useful.

Comparing the ATR of the current session against the same session on previous days highlights unusually quiet or active conditions.

Is ATR part of the pre-trade routine here, and how is it used?
Post Reply