The first pullback after a CHoCH is where people get trapped
You see a clean change of character on the lower timeframe, price breaks the last higher low, and you immediately look for a short on the first pullback. That is the most popular setup in this style, and also one of the most crowded. The issue is that the first pullback often retraces into the area where the old trend's orders still sit, and many times price takes it out and continues the previous trend. I have noticed the better entries usually come from the second reaction or from a pullback that is shallow and rejects a clear zone. A rule I follow: if the pullback after CHoCH retraces beyond the 50 percent of the impulse leg, I stop treating it as a clean reversal and demote the setup. Also check whether the CHoCH took out meaningful liquidity first. A CHoCH from nowhere is weaker than a CHoCH after a sweep of a previous day high. The signal is not the break itself. It is the story that surrounds it.
The first pullback after a CHoCH is where people get trapped
Re: The first pullback after a CHoCH is where people get trapped
The 50 percent rule is a good start, but I'd also look at how the pullback moves, not only how far. A pullback that drifts up in small overlapping candles is usually just a pause before the next leg down. One that comes back in a few big bullish candles with closes near their highs is telling you buyers are still around. Same retracement depth, very different message. I'd also be careful on news days, because a CHoCH printed just before a release can be reversed by one candle and the structure read stops meaning much until the dust settles.
It’s Fairman 
Re: The first pullback after a CHoCH is where people get trapped
Question for people who trade this: do you wait for the first pullback to fail and then sell the second one, or do you need a fresh lower high to form before you're interested? The second option means you give up some of the move, but you also get a clearer stop, above that new lower high instead of somewhere vague above the CHoCH area. I lean toward the second, mostly because it removes the urge to guess where the pullback will end. Curious whether people find the later entry actually costs them much in R once they track it properly.
It’s Fairman 
Re: The first pullback after a CHoCH is where people get trapped
The time of day matters for this trap too. A CHoCH that prints in the last hour of Asia, with London about to open, often gets its first pullback swallowed by the open itself. That pullback isn't really a reaction to the structure change, it's just new participants arriving. I'd be more careful with first pullbacks that line up with a session open or a data release, since the move that follows has a lot less to do with the CHoCH than it seems. A CHoCH in the middle of a quiet London morning is a cleaner test of the idea.
It’s Fairman 
-
FXS Prop Desk
- Posts: 1693
- Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am
Re: The first pullback after a CHoCH is where people get trapped
The crowding is exactly why the first pullback fails so often. Everyone who saw the CHoCH has the same entry and the same stop just above the last lower high, which makes that stop the obvious target.
Waiting for the pullback to sweep that high and close back below it tends to filter out a lot of these traps. You give up the trades that never sweep, but the ones that do have the crowded stops already cleared out of the way.
Waiting for the pullback to sweep that high and close back below it tends to filter out a lot of these traps. You give up the trades that never sweep, but the ones that do have the crowded stops already cleared out of the way.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
Re: The first pullback after a CHoCH is where people get trapped
Another thing I'd look at is where the CHoCH broke relative to the bigger range. If it happens in the middle of a higher timeframe range, the first pullback has plenty of room to run back and trap people. If it breaks right at the edge, after taking out an obvious high or low, the pullback tends to be shallower because there's less trapped interest sitting above. Same pattern on the lower chart, quite different odds depending on the location. I'd split any stats on this by location before trusting them.
It’s Fairman 