Ten Review Questions That Turn Data Into Decisions
Having data is not the same as learning from it. A fixed set of questions guides weekly review so that it produces decisions.
Here are ten that work for many traders. Which setup earned the most R this week, and which lost the most? Did I follow my plan on every trade, and where did I deviate? What was my largest loss, and was it within my risk limit? Which trade would I most like to repeat, and why? Which would I avoid, and what warning sign did I ignore?
What was my emotional state at entries, and did it correlate with results? Did I respect my daily and weekly loss limits? How did costs, including spreads and slippage, affect my results compared with last week? What market conditions did I face, and did my strategy suit them? What one change will I make next week, and how will I measure it?
Write short answers each time. After a few weeks, read them together. Repeated answers show your real recurring issues.
The last question is the most important. Limit yourself to one change at a time, so that you can see its effect.
Keep the review time-boxed, about thirty minutes. If it takes longer, simplify the questions.
Practical step: copy these questions into a document, and answer them this weekend.
Ten Review Questions That Turn Data Into Decisions
Ten Review Questions That Turn Data Into Decisions
It’s Fairman 
Re: Ten Review Questions That Turn Data Into Decisions
The which trade would I repeat question is my favourite on the list. It forces you to describe what good looks like, not just complain about what went wrong. I'd go a step further and save a screenshot of that trade into a separate folder each week. After a couple of months you'll have a small gallery of your best decisions. Flicking through it before the session is a nice way to remind yourself what you're actually looking for. It works better than looking at examples from courses, because these are your own trades on your own pairs in your own session, with the same kind of conditions you'll see tomorrow.
It’s Fairman 
Re: Ten Review Questions That Turn Data Into Decisions
Time boxing it matters. If the review drags past thirty minutes, I've usually started re analysing charts instead of answering the questions. That's a trap because re analysing in hindsight always finds a better entry or a cleverer exit, and you end up changing rules based on perfect information you'll never have live. I set a timer, answer the ten questions with a sentence each, and pick the one change for next week. If I genuinely want to study a chart pattern more deeply, that goes into a separate study session later in the week, with a clear question to answer. Keeping the two apart keeps the review short and honest.
It’s Fairman 
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Ten Review Questions That Turn Data Into Decisions
Question eight is the one I would make people answer with a number rather than a sentence. Costs hide well inside a weekly total, and an answer like spreads were a bit worse tells you nothing.
As an example, take 40 scalps in a week with a 5 pip average target. If slippage and wider spreads add 0.3 pips per round trip compared with last week, that is 12 pips gone, more than two full winners.
Question six has a sample size problem. Fifteen trades are not enough to say whether being tired at entry hurt results, so I would tag the emotional state every week but judge it once a month, with sixty or so trades to compare.
On the gallery idea from the second post, I would add one rule. Include trades that lost but were executed exactly to plan, otherwise the folder slowly teaches you that good means profitable.
That distinction matters most after a rough week. A clean loss next to a sloppy win is a quick reminder of which one you want to repeat.
Fairman, when the answer to question ten repeats three weeks running, do you treat that as the change not working or as the change not being applied? Those need very different fixes.
As an example, take 40 scalps in a week with a 5 pip average target. If slippage and wider spreads add 0.3 pips per round trip compared with last week, that is 12 pips gone, more than two full winners.
Question six has a sample size problem. Fifteen trades are not enough to say whether being tired at entry hurt results, so I would tag the emotional state every week but judge it once a month, with sixty or so trades to compare.
On the gallery idea from the second post, I would add one rule. Include trades that lost but were executed exactly to plan, otherwise the folder slowly teaches you that good means profitable.
That distinction matters most after a rough week. A clean loss next to a sloppy win is a quick reminder of which one you want to repeat.
Fairman, when the answer to question ten repeats three weeks running, do you treat that as the change not working or as the change not being applied? Those need very different fixes.
-
FXS Prop Desk
- Posts: 1689
- Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am
Re: Ten Review Questions That Turn Data Into Decisions
The question about the largest loss is especially useful. One more that often helps: "What did I avoid this week that I would have taken a few months ago?" It highlights progress that doesn't show in the P&L, which is important during flat periods when the numbers alone can be discouraging.
Answering in writing, even briefly, makes the review much more effective than answering mentally, because written answers can be compared from week to week.
Answering in writing, even briefly, makes the review much more effective than answering mentally, because written answers can be compared from week to week.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Ten Review Questions That Turn Data Into Decisions
Question one can mislead in a small week. If one setup had three trades for plus 4R and another had twelve for plus 3R, the first tops the list, yet the second is the one with a result you can lean on.
Showing the count next to every R figure fixes most of that. A setup with fewer than about ten trades in the week gets noted but not ranked.
Question nine works better when the conditions are written before the session rather than during the review. Once the week is over, a choppy Tuesday that lost money gets remembered as choppy, while a choppy Thursday that made money somehow becomes a range day that suited the plan.
A one word label at the start of each session, trend, range or news, takes seconds. By Friday it can be compared with results without the outcome rewriting the description.
On question ten, the measurement deserves a pass mark set on the day the change is chosen. Something like no entries in the first five minutes after a loss, checked on every trade and kept if it holds on at least 90 percent of them, leaves nothing to argue about next week.
Showing the count next to every R figure fixes most of that. A setup with fewer than about ten trades in the week gets noted but not ranked.
Question nine works better when the conditions are written before the session rather than during the review. Once the week is over, a choppy Tuesday that lost money gets remembered as choppy, while a choppy Thursday that made money somehow becomes a range day that suited the plan.
A one word label at the start of each session, trend, range or news, takes seconds. By Friday it can be compared with results without the outcome rewriting the description.
On question ten, the measurement deserves a pass mark set on the day the change is chosen. Something like no entries in the first five minutes after a loss, checked on every trade and kept if it holds on at least 90 percent of them, leaves nothing to argue about next week.
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Ten Review Questions That Turn Data Into Decisions
Many traders skim their trades at the end of the day, which produces little learning. Effective reviews are structured, brief, and focused on process more than outcome.
A useful format asks a few fixed questions. Which trades followed the plan, and which did not? What did the spread and slippage look like? Were there any rule violations, and what triggered them? What single adjustment would improve tomorrow?
Separating execution quality from result matters. A trade that followed the rules but lost was a good trade, and one that broke the rules but won was a bad trade that happened to work. Recording this distinction prevents reinforcing poor habits. Weekly and monthly reviews add a broader view, with aggregate statistics and patterns across sessions. Limiting each review to ten or fifteen minutes keeps it sustainable. The key is consistency, since small insights accumulated across many reviews compound into meaningful improvement.
Even a short review done consistently each day beats a long one done rarely, because the habit itself is what turns experience into skill.
A useful format asks a few fixed questions. Which trades followed the plan, and which did not? What did the spread and slippage look like? Were there any rule violations, and what triggered them? What single adjustment would improve tomorrow?
Separating execution quality from result matters. A trade that followed the rules but lost was a good trade, and one that broke the rules but won was a bad trade that happened to work. Recording this distinction prevents reinforcing poor habits. Weekly and monthly reviews add a broader view, with aggregate statistics and patterns across sessions. Limiting each review to ten or fifteen minutes keeps it sustainable. The key is consistency, since small insights accumulated across many reviews compound into meaningful improvement.
Even a short review done consistently each day beats a long one done rarely, because the habit itself is what turns experience into skill.