Advertisement IC Markets

FVG Expiry and Minimum Size: Parameters That Make Gap Studies Testable

Discuss 1-minute to 15-minute price action setups, fading intraday momentum, key support/resistance zones, and proven short-term trading methodologies.
Post Reply
FXS Prop Desk
Posts: 1693
Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am

FVG Expiry and Minimum Size: Parameters That Make Gap Studies Testable

Post by FXS Prop Desk »

A fair value gap is a three-candle pattern where candle 1's wick and candle 3's wick do not overlap. Two parameters decide whether an FVG study produces anything useful: minimum size and expiry.

Minimum size: on M1–M5, tiny gaps of a fraction of a pip appear constantly. Requiring a gap of at least 0.3–0.5 × ATR removes most of the noise.

Expiry: a gap from three hours ago may no longer mean anything to the market. Setting a validity window (e.g. 20 bars) and voiding gaps after it keeps the sample honest.

Other choices to fix:
  • Entry at the near edge, the midpoint, or full fill.
  • Whether the gap must follow a structure break.
  • What counts as a filled gap (touch vs close through).
Running the same test with different expiries often shows a clear pattern: fresh gaps behave differently from old ones. That is more useful than any single backtest result.

What minimum size and expiry do you use for FVGs?
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: FVG Expiry and Minimum Size: Parameters That Make Gap Studies Testable

Post by Fairman »

FXS Prop Desk wrote: What counts as a filled gap (touch vs close through).
This one quietly changes results more than size or expiry. If a touch counts as filled, a lot of gaps get marked done on a single wick that never really traded into them, and the stats for later entries end up looking worse than they are. If you require a close through, you're mostly measuring gaps that already failed. One way round it is to log the depth of the first revisit as a percentage of the gap, so 0, 25, 50, 100 and beyond. Then you can pick the definition after looking at the distribution rather than before. On the ATR filter, worth checking whether you use the ATR at the time of the gap or a session average, because around the London open those two can be quite far apart.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: FVG Expiry and Minimum Size: Parameters That Make Gap Studies Testable

Post by Shadow Trader »

On expiry, I found bars were the wrong unit once the study crossed sessions. A 20 bar window on M5 is 100 minutes, which is fine at 10:00 London, but a gap formed at 06:20 then stays valid through the London open, when the market is a different place.

So I void any gap at a session boundary as well as after the bar count. On EURUSD M5 that removed a small share of the sample but a large share of the losers.

The other parameter worth fixing is what to do with stacked gaps. In a strong impulse you often get two or three consecutive FVGs, and counting each as a separate setup triples the sample from what is really a single move.

I merge overlapping or touching gaps into one zone and log it once. The results look worse on paper, but they stop the backtest from claiming confidence it has not earned.

On minimum size, Fairman's question about which ATR to use matters a lot at the open. I use ATR over the previous 14 bars at the moment the gap completes, so a gap at 07:05 is judged against the Asian calm and far more of them pass. The session rule catches part of that.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: FVG Expiry and Minimum Size: Parameters That Make Gap Studies Testable

Post by Shadow Trader »

I tried Fairman's idea of logging the depth of the first revisit, and it settled the entry question more than the fill definition did. On EURUSD M5 gaps of at least 0.4 ATR, about 70 percent of first revisits reached the near edge, 45 percent got to the midpoint and only 20 percent went all the way through.

Those numbers make the trade off concrete. A near edge entry gets filled far more often but carries the widest stop, while a midpoint entry misses about a third of those fills and gets a stop roughly half the size.

One caution on choosing the definition after seeing the distribution. It is still a parameter picked on the same data, so I chose midpoint entry on the first four months and only then ran the rest of the year.

The structure break condition made the biggest difference in my sample. Gaps formed in the leg that broke the last M5 swing held at the midpoint far more often, and requiring it cut the gap count by more than half.

FXS Prop Desk, when you require a break, do you count it on the same timeframe as the gap or one higher? I use M5 for both, but I can see the case for M15 structure on M1 gaps.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: FVG Expiry and Minimum Size: Parameters That Make Gap Studies Testable

Post by Shadow Trader »

Large FX option expiries are set to be decided at 10am New York time. When a big strike sits near the current price, some traders believe the market gets pulled toward it, as dealers hedge their exposure. Others think the effect is overblown.

The logic works like this. A dealer who has sold a large option near the money will adjust their hedge as price moves. Near expiry, that hedging becomes more sensitive, and price can stall or gravitate around the strike.

Information about expiries is published by some data providers and brokers, usually as a list of strikes and notional amounts. The big ones, in the billions, get the most attention.

The honest verdict is mixed. Some days show clear pinning near a strike. Other days the market ignores it entirely, especially when a news event dominates.

For scalpers, the practical question is whether expiry levels add anything to ordinary support and resistance. A simple test is to mark the large strikes for a month and check how often price reacted within a few pips.

Another practical point is the size threshold. Many traders only bother with expiries above a billion in notional, since smaller ones carry too little hedging flow to matter. Even then, the level's relation to the current price counts, since a strike thirty pips away rarely influences much within the last hours before the cut.

The time dimension also matters. The effect, if any, is strongest in the hour or two before the cut, and it disappears immediately afterward. A scalper looking at the data might record the range in the ninety minutes before the cut on days with a large nearby expiry versus days without. If the range is clearly smaller on expiry days, that suggests some pinning. If not, the story may be more about narrative than flow.

As always, the answer depends on the pair and the period, so a small log is more valuable than a general rule.

Which expiry levels have you tracked, and did price respect them more often than a random round number?
Post Reply