Advertisement IC Markets

When is M5 a better primary than M1 for your costs?

Discuss 1-minute to 15-minute price action setups, fading intraday momentum, key support/resistance zones, and proven short-term trading methodologies.
Post Reply
LondonScalper
Posts: 965
Joined: Sat Sep 05, 2026 7:54 am

When is M5 a better primary than M1 for your costs?

Post by LondonScalper »

When M5 beats M1 as primary — after costs

M1 feels precise; M5 often survives costs better. I switched primary to M5 on several names when my M1 journal showed lovely entries eaten by spread, noise stops, and the illusion of control. Precision that cannot clear round-trip cost is decoration.

Rule of thumb I use now:
  • If average trade duration and stop distance on M1 cannot clear round-trip cost with room, promote M5 for bias and structure.
  • M1 can remain the trigger only when spread is calm and the M5 story is already clear.
  • Gold is a frequent special case either way — test with a cost log, do not assume from majors.
Timeframe pride is expensive. Let the R-cost decide hierarchy.

On which pairs did M5 become your primary because M1 could not clear costs cleanly?

I still glance at M1 for timing, but the permission to trade comes from M5 structure clearing cost math. Permission and timing are different jobs; conflating them was my old expensive habit.
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
PropScalpDesk
Posts: 521
Joined: Sat Sep 19, 2026 7:50 pm

Re: When is M5 a better primary than M1 for your costs?

Post by PropScalpDesk »

EURUSD and GBPUSD both went to M5 primary for me. The rough test I use is round-trip cost as a share of the stop. On EURUSD raw, about 0.8 pips all-in against a typical 4-pip M1 stop is 20% before the trade does anything. On an M5 structure stop of 8 to 10 pips, it drops to single digits.

Anything above about 10 to 15% and the M1 entries have to be genuinely better, not just prettier, to make up for it. Mine weren't.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: When is M5 a better primary than M1 for your costs?

Post by Shadow Trader »

Gold went the other way for me, which is LondonScalper's special case in practice. My all-in round trip on XAUUSD is about 30 cents in London, and against a 2 dollar M1 stop that is 15 percent, right at PropScalpDesk's upper line.

On M5 the structure stop is closer to 5 dollars and the cost drops to about 6 percent. The catch was that M5 entries on gold came so late in the move that the extra room was mostly spent on worse targets.

So gold stayed on M1, but only in the first ninety minutes of London, when the moves are big enough to pay the bill. After that it goes to M5 or I leave it alone.

One cost the share of stop test misses is slippage on the stop itself. My M1 stops on EURUSD slipped by about 0.2 pips on average, and since tight stops get hit more often, that slip hurts the M1 version far more than the M5 one.

Adding it moved PropScalpDesk's 20 percent closer to 25 for my fills. Does anyone else include stop slippage in this ratio, or only spread and commission?
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: When is M5 a better primary than M1 for your costs?

Post by Shadow Trader »

Another way to look at PropScalpDesk's ratio is as the win rate each version needs just to break even. Using the 0.8 pip all-in cost from that post and a 1.5R target, a 4 pip M1 stop needs to win 48 percent of the time, while a 9 pip M5 stop needs about 44 percent.
img_12570_r2.png
img_12570_r2.png (57.2 KiB) Viewed 155 times
Without costs both would need exactly 40 percent, which is what the grey bars in the chart show next to the real figures. So the M1 version gives up 8 points of win rate to costs and the M5 version a little under 4.

That difference is what the prettier M1 entries have to make up. In my own journal the M1 trades did win more often, but only by about 3 points, which was not enough to cover the extra 4.4 they needed.

Most people compare the two timeframes on win rate and stop size alone. Writing the break even win rate next to each setup in the journal keeps the comparison honest, since it moves with the spread you actually paid.

Does anyone here see M1 entries beat M5 by a wider margin than that on EURUSD? I would like to know which setups manage it.
Post Reply