Using Indicators Without Depending on Them
Indicators can be helpful tools, but they can also become crutches. The key is to use them intentionally, not blindly.
What indicators are good for:
- Context. A moving average can quickly show trend direction.
- Momentum. RSI or MACD can suggest the strength behind a move.
- Volatility. ATR helps set stops based on recent range.
- Confirmation. They can support what price is already telling you.
What they aren't good for:
- Predicting the future on their own
- Replacing structure and levels
- Fixing a weak process
Example approaches:
1. RSI divergence at a liquidity sweep. If price makes a new high but RSI makes a lower high, and the high sweeps liquidity, it may add to a bearish case.
2. ATR for stops. Use a multiple of ATR to gauge whether your stop is reasonable for current volatility.
3. Moving average as a filter. Only take buys when price is above a chosen moving average.
Guidelines:
- Use no more than two or three indicators
- Understand what each one measures
- Test how they affect results
- Never let an indicator override your risk rules
Many indicators show the same information in different forms. More indicators rarely mean more clarity.
Price is the source. Indicators are commentary.
Using Indicators Without Depending on Them
Using Indicators Without Depending on Them
It’s Fairman 
-
LondonNewsTrader
- Posts: 421
- Joined: Mon Sep 21, 2026 9:30 am
Re: Using Indicators Without Depending on Them
The ATR point is where news days bite. A 14-period ATR on the M5 chart includes the release candle for 70 minutes afterwards. If NFP prints a 60 pip bar, the ATR roughly doubles and an "ATR times 1.5" stop suddenly looks sensible at three times its normal width. Then, as the spike rolls out of the window, the same rule shrinks the stop back again while price is still unsettled.
I handle it in one of two ways. Either use a longer ATR on a higher timeframe for stop sizing, so a single bar can't dominate it, or just skip the indicator-based stop for the first hour after a major release and use structure.
Your moving average filter has a similar quirk. Price can cross a 20 EMA on the release spike and cross back within ten minutes, so "only buy above the MA" needs a closing rule or it flips on noise.
I handle it in one of two ways. Either use a longer ATR on a higher timeframe for stop sizing, so a single bar can't dominate it, or just skip the indicator-based stop for the first hour after a major release and use structure.
Your moving average filter has a similar quirk. Price can cross a 20 EMA on the release spike and cross back within ten minutes, so "only buy above the MA" needs a closing rule or it flips on noise.
-
FXS Prop Desk
- Posts: 1689
- Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am
Re: Using Indicators Without Depending on Them
A balanced framework. The RSI-divergence-at-sweep example is a good one, because the indicator only adds information at a location that already matters. One practical addition: limit the chart to two or three indicators that measure different things, for example one trend tool, one momentum tool and ATR. Several momentum oscillators at once mostly repeat each other and create conflicting signals.
A simple test of whether an indicator earns its place: remove it for two weeks and see whether the results or decisions change. If not, it was decoration.
A simple test of whether an indicator earns its place: remove it for two weeks and see whether the results or decisions change. If not, it was decoration.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Using Indicators Without Depending on Them
The removal test FXS Prop Desk describes is a good one, but two weeks is short for a scalper taking three or four trades a day. That is maybe 35 trades, and a single news week inside it can decide the result on its own.
I run it on decisions rather than results. For each trade I note whether the indicator changed anything, either stopping an entry or moving a stop, and if it changed fewer than one decision in ten it goes.
The RSI divergence example passed that test for me only partly. When I went back through 50 sweeps of the Asian high on EURUSD, divergence was present on 41 of them. It showed up almost every time and barely separated the good sweeps from the bad ones.
On the ATR point, I took a middle route between the two options LondonNewsTrader gives. My stop uses the median true range of the last 14 bars instead of the average, so one 60 pip release candle barely moves it.
The moving average filter I dropped years ago. Swing structure was already telling me the same thing, and the average just arrived later.
Which indicator have others removed and then quietly put back? Mine was ATR, and it lasted about four days off the screen.
I run it on decisions rather than results. For each trade I note whether the indicator changed anything, either stopping an entry or moving a stop, and if it changed fewer than one decision in ten it goes.
The RSI divergence example passed that test for me only partly. When I went back through 50 sweeps of the Asian high on EURUSD, divergence was present on 41 of them. It showed up almost every time and barely separated the good sweeps from the bad ones.
On the ATR point, I took a middle route between the two options LondonNewsTrader gives. My stop uses the median true range of the last 14 bars instead of the average, so one 60 pip release candle barely moves it.
The moving average filter I dropped years ago. Swing structure was already telling me the same thing, and the average just arrived later.
Which indicator have others removed and then quietly put back? Mine was ATR, and it lasted about four days off the screen.
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Using Indicators Without Depending on Them
One trap the guidelines do not mention is repainting. A higher timeframe indicator placed on an M1 screen, for example an H1 moving average, keeps changing its current value until the hour closes, so a cross that appeared at 10:20 can be gone by 10:59.
Scrolling back through history only shows the final values. That makes the indicator look far cleaner in review than it was in real time, and a few months of screenshots taken live showed me how big the gap was.
I now only use the value from the last closed higher timeframe bar. It lags more, but it reads the same in review as it did when I traded.
Volume indicators deserve a footnote too. Spot forex has no central volume figure, so the platform shows a tick count from one broker, which tracks activity reasonably well but can differ noticeably between two feeds on the same minute.
The median range stop from my last post has one downside. After a genuine shift in volatility, such as the day after a central bank surprise, it takes longer to catch up, so on those days I widen it by hand and note that in the journal.
Scrolling back through history only shows the final values. That makes the indicator look far cleaner in review than it was in real time, and a few months of screenshots taken live showed me how big the gap was.
I now only use the value from the last closed higher timeframe bar. It lags more, but it reads the same in review as it did when I traded.
Volume indicators deserve a footnote too. Spot forex has no central volume figure, so the platform shows a tick count from one broker, which tracks activity reasonably well but can differ noticeably between two feeds on the same minute.
The median range stop from my last post has one downside. After a genuine shift in volatility, such as the day after a central bank surprise, it takes longer to catch up, so on those days I widen it by hand and note that in the journal.
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Using Indicators Without Depending on Them
Forums overflow with indicator hunts. RSI settings, stochastic periods, moving average crossovers, custom oscillators with mysterious names.
Most indicators are transformations of price and sometimes volume. They contain no information beyond what the price series already holds. They simply display it differently.
The value lies in discipline and clarity, not magic. An indicator provides a consistent rule that reduces improvisation. A trader who follows a simple moving average rule with discipline will often beat one who changes indicators weekly.
What does matter is matching the tool to the job. Trend indicators lag in ranges. Oscillators fail in strong trends. The key is knowing which environment is present.
Fewer indicators usually works better. Two or three that complement each other, such as one for trend direction and one for entry timing, avoid clutter.
Price itself, including levels, structure and volume, provides most of the content.
What indicators remain on the charts here, and which ones could be removed without loss?
Most indicators are transformations of price and sometimes volume. They contain no information beyond what the price series already holds. They simply display it differently.
The value lies in discipline and clarity, not magic. An indicator provides a consistent rule that reduces improvisation. A trader who follows a simple moving average rule with discipline will often beat one who changes indicators weekly.
What does matter is matching the tool to the job. Trend indicators lag in ranges. Oscillators fail in strong trends. The key is knowing which environment is present.
Fewer indicators usually works better. Two or three that complement each other, such as one for trend direction and one for entry timing, avoid clutter.
Price itself, including levels, structure and volume, provides most of the content.
What indicators remain on the charts here, and which ones could be removed without loss?