Advertisement IC Markets

Break-Even Trade Size for Raw vs Standard Accounts

Compare ECN/Raw spread brokers, analyze execution speeds, report slippage, and evaluate commission structures for high-frequency traders.
Post Reply
FXS Prop Desk
Posts: 1689
Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am

Break-Even Trade Size for Raw vs Standard Accounts

Post by FXS Prop Desk »

Raw-spread accounts charge commission; standard accounts build the cost into a wider spread. Which is cheaper depends on the numbers, and it is easy to calculate.

Example on EURUSD:
  • Raw: average spread 0.2 pips + $7 commission per lot round turn (0.7 pips) = 0.9 pips total.
  • Standard: average spread 1.2 pips, no commission = 1.2 pips total.
In this case, raw is cheaper by 0.3 pips per trade at every size. Where it gets interesting:
  • Some brokers charge a minimum commission per trade, which makes raw expensive for very small lots (e.g. 0.01–0.05).
  • At news times, raw spreads widen too, sometimes more than standard spreads.
  • On less liquid pairs, the difference may shrink or reverse.
Calculating your own average spread at your trading hours on both account types gives the real answer.

Which account type is cheaper for your typical trade size?
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: Break-Even Trade Size for Raw vs Standard Accounts

Post by Fairman »

FXS Prop Desk wrote: Raw: average spread 0.2 pips + $7 commission per lot round turn (0.7 pips) = 0.9 pips total.
That conversion holds for EURUSD in a USD account, where a pip is $10 per lot. On other pairs the same $7 works out differently in pips. On USDJPY around 150 a pip is worth roughly $6.70 per lot, so $7 is a bit over 1 pip, while on GBPUSD it's still 0.7. So the gap between raw and standard can be quite different on yen pairs than on euro or cable, depending on the standard spread there. Same thing if the account is in EUR or GBP, since commission may be charged in account currency at a fixed rate. Worth doing the sum for each pair you actually trade rather than once for EURUSD and assuming it carries over.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Break-Even Trade Size for Raw vs Standard Accounts

Post by Shadow Trader »

Fairman, the yen pair point is exactly why my old EURUSD only sheet lied. On USDJPY near 150 the same seven dollar commission was over a pip, so raw looked worse than standard until my size sat above 0.3 lots.

I now compute break even size per pair: the lot where raw total cost equals the standard spread I actually pay at my hours. Below that floor I stay on standard; above it I flip to raw.
img_13725_r1.png
img_13725_r1.png (27.77 KiB) Viewed 171 times
The illustration compares break even trade size on raw versus standard for EURUSD and USDJPY at my broker numbers. The yen bar sits higher, which matches the pip value gap you flagged.

News minutes still muddy the answer. Raw spreads on GBPUSD have blown past standard for me during CPI, so the cheap account is not always the cheap fill.

Do you keep separate break even sizes per pair, or one blended number for the whole book? Separate per pair has saved me from forcing raw on tiny yen clips.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Break-Even Trade Size for Raw vs Standard Accounts

Post by Shadow Trader »

One cost that a per trade comparison misses is scaling out. Some brokers charge a minimum commission per ticket, so closing a 0.03 lot position in three 0.01 parts can cost more than the same trade closed in one go.

On raw that minimum fee falls on every partial close. On my small clips it pushed the effective cost on USDJPY to around 1.4 pips, while the standard account cost stayed the same however I split the exit.

The other number I check is the standard spread at the exact minutes I trade, not the average the broker publishes. The published figure on my EURUSD standard was 1.2, but the spread I paid between 08:00 and 08:05 London averaged closer to 1.5.

Fairman's account currency point bites here too. If commission is fixed in euros while the pip value is in dollars, the pip cost of the same commission changes as EURUSD moves, so I redo the sum each quarter.

Do you scale out on small sizes, or close in one piece to keep the commission count down? I stopped splitting below 0.1 lots.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Break-Even Trade Size for Raw vs Standard Accounts

Post by Shadow Trader »

A raw-spread account showing 0.0 on EURUSD looks like a bargain. Then the commission line appears.

The true cost is spread plus commission, converted to the same unit. A 0.0 spread with a 7 dollar round-turn commission per standard lot costs about 0.7 pips. A standard account showing 1.0 pip spread with no commission costs 1.0 pip. The raw account wins, but only by about 0.3 pips, and only if the spread actually stays near zero.

Here's what to check:

- How often does the spread truly sit at 0.0?
- What does it do at rollover and around news?
- Is commission charged per side or per round turn?
- What's the slippage compared to the standard account?

A tiny difference in advertised cost can be wiped out by a difference in fills.

Think about the sequence of events at a typical rollover. At 5 PM New York, the raw spread might jump from 0.0 to 3.0 pips for several minutes. Commission stays at 0.7. A strategy that happens to trade right then pays almost 4 pips in costs, while the headline number said 0.7. That's the sort of detail that never shows up in an advertisement.

Has anyone run the same strategy on both account types and compared the full cost per trade, including slippage?
FXS Prop Desk
Posts: 1689
Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am

Re: Break-Even Trade Size for Raw vs Standard Accounts

Post by FXS Prop Desk »

Fairman wrote: Worth doing the sum for each pair you actually trade rather than once for EURUSD and assuming it carries over.
The per-pair conversion is where the comparison actually changes. Gold is another case besides yen: commission is often per lot there too, but contract size and what counts as a pip differ, so the raw account can look much better or much worse than on EURUSD. A small table per symbol with spread, commission converted to pips at today's rate, and the total is ten minutes well spent before choosing the account type.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: Break-Even Trade Size for Raw vs Standard Accounts

Post by Fairman »

A per-symbol cost table is the right starting point, especially for contracts whose tick or pip value differs from a standard FX lot. I would define the contract size and quote convention explicitly for each instrument, then convert commission into the same account-currency units as spread and slippage. Using one current conversion rate for every historical trade can still distort a backtest if the account currency or the commission currency moved; the conversion should match the trade date where that matters.

One distinction is useful for the “break-even size” calculation: if commission is strictly proportional to volume and the quoted spread is otherwise unchanged, both costs scale with size, so their difference per unit usually does not create a size threshold. A threshold appears when there is a minimum ticket charge, volume tier, minimum lot, or extra charges from splitting exits. Those terms should be in the formula. I would also compare actual spreads and fills during the strategy’s trading hours, rather than rely only on a headline average, and keep ordinary spread separate from execution slippage so the same cost is not counted twice. That produces a more meaningful raw-versus-standard comparison than a single EURUSD example or a blended number across symbols.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Post Reply