The ratio rule only looks at the target side, but the stop pays the same cost on every loser. On a symmetric trade the test I trust more is the win rate needed just to break even once costs are in.

- img_13485_r2.png (69.06 KiB) Viewed 102 times
The chart uses a 1.0 pip round trip cost with the stop set equal to the target. At 3 pips the trade has to win about 67 percent of the time to break even, at 5 pips it needs 60 percent, and at 10 pips that falls to 55 percent.
The arithmetic is simple. A winner nets the target minus cost and a loser costs the stop plus cost, so with a 5 pip target you bank 4 and give up 6.
This is where I part slightly with the four to five times rule. A 4 pip target with a 2 pip stop needs only 50 percent, while a 5 pip target with a 5 pip stop needs 60, even though the second one passes the ratio test more comfortably.
Tight stops bring their own problems, so I do not treat that as a free lunch. What win rate does your log actually show at your usual target, and how far above the break even line does it sit?