Here is my best and worst EURUSD scalp from this month, with what I learned from each.
Best: a Tuesday, 08:20 London. Price broke above the Asia high at 08:05 with a strong candle and normal spread. I waited for the first pullback, which came back to within two pips of the Asia high and held. Entry long on the M1 close at 08:21, stop below the pullback low, 4 pips. Target at the previous day's high, 9 pips away. Hit at 08:48. Result: a bit over 2R after costs.
Why it worked: the level was marked before the open, the setup matched my card exactly, and I did nothing clever.
Worst: a Thursday, 13:28 London. I was flat for the day, bored, and saw what looked like a breakout. I went long two minutes before US data that I had on my calendar but ignored. The release went against me and the stop slipped by 1.5 pips. Result: about minus 1.4R.
Why it failed: every rule I have about news was broken, and the reason was boredom, not a setup.
The lesson is the same every month. My best trades are the most boring ones, and my worst trades start with a reason that is not on the card.
Journal example: best and worst EURUSD scalp this month
-
LondonScalper
- Posts: 965
- Joined: Sat Sep 05, 2026 7:54 am
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Journal example: best and worst EURUSD scalp this month
LondonScalper, your best trade matches the card I wish I followed more often. My own best EURUSD scalp this month was also a first pullback to Asia high, but I took 7 pips with a 5 pip stop and still called it a win only because I had already marked the level at 07:55.
The worst one for me was not news. It was a second entry after a scratch, same level, wider stop, and a story about unfinished business. That one printed minus 1.8R and taught me nothing new except that revenge sizing still sneaks in.
I log a boredom tag now whenever I open the platform after two flat hours. If that tag is on, I need a written reason that is not I saw a candle.
Your point about the most boring trades being the best ones is the line I keep above my desk. Clever is usually the first warning.
Do you force a hard stop on trading after a flat morning, or only after a loss? Mine kicks in after either, and it has already saved two weak afternoons.
The worst one for me was not news. It was a second entry after a scratch, same level, wider stop, and a story about unfinished business. That one printed minus 1.8R and taught me nothing new except that revenge sizing still sneaks in.
I log a boredom tag now whenever I open the platform after two flat hours. If that tag is on, I need a written reason that is not I saw a candle.
Your point about the most boring trades being the best ones is the line I keep above my desk. Clever is usually the first warning.
Do you force a hard stop on trading after a flat morning, or only after a loss? Mine kicks in after either, and it has already saved two weak afternoons.
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Journal example: best and worst EURUSD scalp this month
Your worst trade checks out on the numbers, which is a good sign the journal is honest. If the stop was 4 pips like the best one, slipping 1.5 turns a planned 1R loss into about 1.4R, so the release added nearly half a risk unit on top of the bad decision.
One change I made to my monthly review is ranking trades by process rather than by result. My best process trade this month was a loser, a clean Asia high retest that held for six minutes and then died on a dollar headline.
Picking best and worst by money tends to reward the lucky trades. A rule break that happens to make 2R ends up crowned as the best trade, and the lesson taken from it is the wrong one.
So each trade gets a score out of three: level marked in advance, entry on the card, and exit as planned. The result sits in a separate column, and only the score decides which trades go into the review.
Have you had a trade with full process marks that still ended up as the worst result of the month? That happened to me in September, and it was the most useful entry I wrote.
One change I made to my monthly review is ranking trades by process rather than by result. My best process trade this month was a loser, a clean Asia high retest that held for six minutes and then died on a dollar headline.
Picking best and worst by money tends to reward the lucky trades. A rule break that happens to make 2R ends up crowned as the best trade, and the lesson taken from it is the wrong one.
So each trade gets a score out of three: level marked in advance, entry on the card, and exit as planned. The result sits in a separate column, and only the score decides which trades go into the review.
Have you had a trade with full process marks that still ended up as the worst result of the month? That happened to me in September, and it was the most useful entry I wrote.