Advertisement IC Markets

Commission Structures: Per Lot, Per Million and Per Side

Compare ECN/Raw spread brokers, analyze execution speeds, report slippage, and evaluate commission structures for high-frequency traders.
Post Reply
FXS Prop Desk
Posts: 1689
Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am

Commission Structures: Per Lot, Per Million and Per Side

Post by FXS Prop Desk »

Commission is quoted in several ways, which makes broker comparisons confusing. Converting everything to one unit — round-turn cost per standard lot in pips — makes them comparable.

Common formats:
  • Per side per lot: e.g. $3.50 per side = $7 round turn per 100,000 units.
  • Per million traded: e.g. $30 per million per side. One lot of EURUSD at 1.10 is about $110,000 notional, so about $3.30 per side.
  • Account currency: a €3 per side commission on a EUR account differs from $3 on a USD account.
  • Tiered: lower rates at higher monthly volume.
Converting to pips: on EURUSD, $10 per pip per lot, so $7 round turn = 0.7 pips. On USDJPY, pip value depends on the exchange rate.

Adding the average spread gives the total cost per trade, which is the number that matters.

How do you compare commission between brokers?
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Commission Structures: Per Lot, Per Million and Per Side

Post by Shadow Trader »

One detail that tripped me up when converting: per million pricing is charged on notional, so the cost drifts with the rate. At EURUSD 1.17 that same $30 per million comes to about $3.51 per side, not $3.30.

On USDJPY the pip side moves instead. With the pair at 150, a single lot pays roughly $6.67 per pip, so a $7 round turn is roughly 1.05 pips, noticeably more than on the euro.

For my own comparison I build one number per pair, commission plus the median spread during my actual trading window, both in pips. I use the median rather than the advertised average because a few quiet hours drag an average down.

The tiered schedules need a reality check too. If the lower tier starts at 500 lots a month and I trade 180, the headline rate is irrelevant to me.

Has anyone found a cleaner way to handle the EUR account case? I just convert at the month's average rate and accept a few cents of error per lot.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Commission Structures: Per Lot, Per Million and Per Side

Post by Shadow Trader »

Commission only started to feel real to me once I turned it into a breakeven win rate. Take EURUSD at 0.7 pips round turn plus a 0.2 pip spread, so 0.9 pips per trade, and look at what that does to a 1:1 setup at different sizes.
img_13654_r2.png
img_13654_r2.png (76.02 KiB) Viewed 95 times
The chart shows the result. With a 3 pip target and a 3 pip stop, a winner pays 2.1 and a loser costs 3.9, so I need 65 percent winners just to stay flat, while at 20 pips the same cost only lifts the bar to about 52 percent.

That is why I think cost per lot comparisons undersell the gap between brokers for very short scalps. A 0.2 pip difference in commission moves the 3 pip breakeven by more than 3 percentage points, but barely matters at 20 pips.

Partial closes add an edge case. Some brokers apply a minimum charge per ticket, so splitting a 0.1 lot trade into two 0.05 lot exits can cost noticeably more per lot than one exit.

My own card is built around 6 pips, mostly because below that the arithmetic got ugly. Do you size your targets with cost in mind, or pick the target first and accept whatever the cost works out to?
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Commission Structures: Per Lot, Per Million and Per Side

Post by Shadow Trader »

Account types fall roughly into two models. Spread-only accounts embed all costs in a wider spread. Commission accounts offer raw or near-raw spreads and add a fixed fee per lot traded, typically quoted per side or per round turn.

Comparison requires converting both to the same unit. A raw spread of 0.1 pips plus a commission of 7 dollars per round-turn lot on EURUSD equals roughly 0.7 pips in total cost, since one pip is worth about 10 dollars per standard lot. A spread-only account at 0.8 pips is nearly identical in cost.

The difference shows up in behavior. Spread-only accounts widen during volatility, increasing costs unpredictably. Commission accounts keep the fee fixed while raw spreads still widen, but the fixed component remains stable. For scalpers trading many times per day, the lower and more transparent cost of a commission model often wins. Verifying whether the commission is per side or per round turn avoids a doubled or halved estimate.
Post Reply