I use both on EURUSD scalps, and they do different jobs.
The price stop is for invalidation. If price goes past the point where my idea is clearly wrong, I am out. It is set before entry and I do not move it further away.
The time stop is for ideas that go nowhere. My setups are supposed to work fairly quickly. If a continuation trade has not moved at least 0.5R in my favour within 15 to 20 minutes, the momentum I was betting on probably is not there. I close it, usually near breakeven or a small loss.
When I added time stops, my average loss barely changed, but the number of full-size losses fell. Many of those used to be trades that drifted sideways for 40 minutes and then got stopped out when London lunch liquidity thinned. The time stop gets me out before that happens.
The downside: sometimes a trade I closed for time goes on to hit my target an hour later. That hurts to watch. In my journal, those cases are less common than the slow bleeds the time stop prevents.
What time limit do others use? I suspect it depends a lot on the setup and the pair.
Time stop vs price stop on EURUSD scalps
-
LondonScalper
- Posts: 965
- Joined: Sat Sep 05, 2026 7:54 am
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Time stop vs price stop on EURUSD scalps
LondonScalper, splitting price stop and time stop the way you describe matches how I run EURUSD continuation. The price stop is invalidation, and the time stop is for ideas that simply never wake up.
My clock is fifteen minutes to 0.5R on London continuation. If that mark is missed I flatten near breakeven rather than waiting for lunch liquidity to thin and finish the job.
When I added time stops, full size losses fell even though average loss barely moved. Most of the saved tickets were the forty minute sideways drifts that used to die after 11:30.
The painful case still happens: a trade I closed for time later hits the target. Those late winners show up less often in my log than the slow sessions the clock cuts short, so I keep the rule.
I tighten the clock to ten minutes on Asia range fades because that edge dies faster. Do you keep one timer for every EURUSD setup, or vary it by pattern?
My clock is fifteen minutes to 0.5R on London continuation. If that mark is missed I flatten near breakeven rather than waiting for lunch liquidity to thin and finish the job.
When I added time stops, full size losses fell even though average loss barely moved. Most of the saved tickets were the forty minute sideways drifts that used to die after 11:30.
The painful case still happens: a trade I closed for time later hits the target. Those late winners show up less often in my log than the slow sessions the clock cuts short, so I keep the rule.
I tighten the clock to ten minutes on Asia range fades because that edge dies faster. Do you keep one timer for every EURUSD setup, or vary it by pattern?
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Time stop vs price stop on EURUSD scalps
LondonScalper, since my last reply I tested whether my fifteen minute clock was the right length or just a round number. On my last 180 EURUSD London continuation trades, 74 reached the 1R target, and 61 of those 74 had touched 0.5R within the first 12 minutes.
The chart buckets every trade by how long it took to first touch 0.5R. Trades that got there inside four minutes won 27 of 38, while the ones that only got there after 20 minutes won 4 of 13.
The 12 to 16 minute bucket is what moved my clock. It won 6 of 16, and with a 1R stop against a 1R target that is a losing group, so I now flatten at 12 minutes instead of 15.
The 45 trades that never touched 0.5R at all are the reason the time stop exists. None of them reached target, and most would have drifted into the full stop.
I would not copy the 12 to anyone else's book, since it came from one setup on one pair. If you bucket your own trades this way, does the drop off land near your 15 to 20 minutes?
The chart buckets every trade by how long it took to first touch 0.5R. Trades that got there inside four minutes won 27 of 38, while the ones that only got there after 20 minutes won 4 of 13.
The 12 to 16 minute bucket is what moved my clock. It won 6 of 16, and with a 1R stop against a 1R target that is a losing group, so I now flatten at 12 minutes instead of 15.
The 45 trades that never touched 0.5R at all are the reason the time stop exists. None of them reached target, and most would have drifted into the full stop.
I would not copy the 12 to anyone else's book, since it came from one setup on one pair. If you bucket your own trades this way, does the drop off land near your 15 to 20 minutes?
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Time stop vs price stop on EURUSD scalps
Stops on short positions trigger when the ask price reaches the stop level, while charts usually display bid prices. A trader watching the bid chart may see price stay below the stop level while the ask has already touched it, and the position closes.
The gap equals the spread. During normal conditions, it is small, but during volatile or illiquid periods it can be large enough to matter. This asymmetry is a common source of confusion, with traders believing they were stopped out unfairly when price on the chart never touched their level.
Showing the ask line on the chart makes the situation visible. Some platforms offer this as a setting. Placing short-trade stops with the spread in mind, adding a buffer equal to the typical or current spread, reduces premature exits. In backtests, short trades should use ask-based triggers for stops, and long trades bid-based triggers for the same reason. Ignoring this detail biases results favorably, particularly for short-term strategies with narrow stops.
The gap equals the spread. During normal conditions, it is small, but during volatile or illiquid periods it can be large enough to matter. This asymmetry is a common source of confusion, with traders believing they were stopped out unfairly when price on the chart never touched their level.
Showing the ask line on the chart makes the situation visible. Some platforms offer this as a setting. Placing short-trade stops with the spread in mind, adding a buffer equal to the typical or current spread, reduces premature exits. In backtests, short trades should use ask-based triggers for stops, and long trades bid-based triggers for the same reason. Ignoring this detail biases results favorably, particularly for short-term strategies with narrow stops.