Advertisement IC Markets

Refining my news filter that is actually followed after a green week

Real-time market analysis, live trade entries, order flow commentary, and daily setups for the London, New York, and Asian session overlaps.
Post Reply
LondonScalper
Posts: 965
Joined: Sat Sep 05, 2026 7:54 am

Refining my news filter that is actually followed after a green week

Post by LondonScalper »

My news filter worked fine when I was losing. It was after green weeks that I kept breaking it, so I rebuilt it around that.

The old filter was a list of events with five-minute blackouts. After a few winning days, I started shortening the blackouts, trading closer to releases and sometimes ignoring medium-impact events altogether. The confidence from the good week made the rules feel too careful.

What I changed:
- The blackout times are now printed and taped to the monitor, so changing them means physically writing on the strip. That bit of friction helps a lot.
- After three green days in a row, the filter gets stricter, not looser: blackouts extend to ten minutes, and size on the first trade after a release is halved.
- Every filter change has to be written in the journal with a reason, on a weekend only.
- Once a month I check the journal for any trade opened inside a blackout. Each one is listed and reviewed.

It sounds backwards to be stricter after winning. But my journal showed that most of my news losses came in the week after a strong week, not after a losing one.

A filter that is only followed on bad days is not a filter. It is a mood.
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Refining my news filter that is actually followed after a green week

Post by Shadow Trader »

LondonScalper, making the filter stricter after three green days is the part that feels backwards until you look at the journal. My own news losses clustered in the week after a strong run, not after a red stretch, for the same confidence reason you describe.

I tape the blackout times to the monitor as well. Changing a number then means writing on the strip, which is enough friction to stop me shortening a window midweek because the morning felt easy.

Weekend only changes are a good rule. I broke it once on a Tuesday after a clean NFP trade and spent the next two sessions taking medium impact prints I would normally skip.

The monthly review of blackout breaches is where the filter either holds or dies. Last month I found two tickets inside the window, both after green days, and both are circled in red in the log.

I extend the blackout for every release on the card after a green streak, not only the high impact ones. Do you tighten across the board, or only for the big prints?
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Refining my news filter that is actually followed after a green week

Post by Shadow Trader »

What counts as a green week is worth pinning down, because a vague trigger is easy to argue with on a Monday. Mine is plus 2R or more for the week, or three green days in a row, and the stricter rules switch on automatically when either is met.

The other change was moving part of the filter out of my hands. A small script on the platform now refuses new orders inside the blackout windows I load on Sunday, so breaking the rule takes deliberate effort rather than one impulsive click.

Calendar times are the weak point in that setup. Releases get moved now and then, and a delayed US report once landed in what my script thought was a clear window, so I recheck the next day's times each evening.

I disagree a little on the direction of the rule, though. After a red week I tighten as well, since my revenge trades around medium impact releases cost nearly as much as the overconfidence after green ones.

Loading the whole week on Sunday saves time but misses those reschedules. Do you set your blackout list once for the week, or day by day?
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Refining my news filter that is actually followed after a green week

Post by Shadow Trader »

A trader runs a new 5-minute setup for a week. 25 trades, 16 winners, a nice little curve climbing. By Friday evening the screenshot is ready and the plan is to double the size on Monday.

Now flip a fair coin 25 times, call heads a win and tails a loss, and give every win and loss the same size. Getting 16 or more heads happens roughly 11 or 12 times in 100 tries. Not rare at all. Put a few thousand traders on that coin and a crowd of them post a screenshot like that every week.

That is the problem with a short run. A real edge and plain luck both produce green weeks, and 25 trades cannot tell them apart. The week might be skill. It might be noise. Nothing in the result says which.

The cruel part is what comes next. Size goes up right when the sample is thinnest, and the first normal losing stretch lands on the biggest position of the year.

How many trades did you need on a new setup before you trusted the numbers, and did that count ever turn out to be too small?
Post Reply