Advertisement IC Markets

Prop Firm Trading Journal: What to Record Beyond Entry and Exit

Navigate the rules, daily drawdown limits, and consistency guidelines of prop trading firms. Discuss how to pass funded account challenges using scalping strategies.
Post Reply
FXS Prop Desk
Posts: 1689
Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am

Prop Firm Trading Journal: What to Record Beyond Entry and Exit

Post by FXS Prop Desk »

A journal for a prop account serves two purposes: improving trading and supporting payout reviews. Useful fields:
  • Date/time in server time, plus session (Asia, London, NY).
  • Instrument, direction, lot size, risk in money and %.
  • Setup name, with a screenshot at entry.
  • Spread at entry and slippage on the fill.
  • Distance to daily floor and max floor at entry.
  • Whether the trade was near a news event.
  • Exit reason (target, stop, manual, time).
The "distance to floor" field is the one most traders skip, and it explains many bad decisions: trades taken with very little room left tend to be worse.

It also helps to check the exact equity source the firm uses for termination decisions, and whether there is a written appeal route. Firms that describe their review process clearly tend to apply discretionary clauses less often and more consistently.

What field in your journal has taught you the most?
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Prop Firm Trading Journal: What to Record Beyond Entry and Exit

Post by Shadow Trader »

FXS Prop Desk, logging how much floor room remains at the click is the column that changed my behaviour most. Once I started writing it down, I saw that tickets taken under 0.4 percent of room left were losers far more often than the rest of the book.

I also record spread at the click and the actual fill slip as separate columns. Looking at them side by side for a month showed that my worst days clustered when both were stretched, not when the setup itself was weak.
img_13699_r1.png
img_13699_r1.png (60.41 KiB) Viewed 121 times
The chart groups 80 journal rows by floor room at entry and shows the win rate dropping once that room falls under half a percent. That is why I now refuse new risk below that line even if the setup looks clean.

Exit reason matters for payout reviews too. A string of manual closes near the soft stop reads differently from stops hit in a trending session, and I want that distinction on paper before anyone asks.

The floor column taught me to skip more often rather than just size down. Has it changed your entries the same way, or do you mainly cut size when room is tight?
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Prop Firm Trading Journal: What to Record Beyond Entry and Exit

Post by Shadow Trader »

A field I have added since my earlier reply is minutes since the previous exit. It sounds minor, but over the last 140 journal rows, trades opened within three minutes of a losing exit averaged about minus 0.3 R while the rest averaged around plus 0.1 R.

Those quick re-entries rarely look like revenge at the time. In the journal they look like a valid setup that happened to appear right away, which is exactly why the timestamp is more useful than my own label.

I also log the planned target next to the actual exit. On manual closes the gap between the two shows how often I take profit early out of nerves, and on my rows that was nearly half of them.

For payout reviews, the boring fields earn their place. I record which device or VPS each trade came from, since one firm asked about an IP change during a review and the journal answered it in a minute.

Mine had no timing fields at all until this year, which still surprises me. Do you keep any, or does your journal stop at the trade itself?
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Prop Firm Trading Journal: What to Record Beyond Entry and Exit

Post by Shadow Trader »

Many journals contain entry price, exit price, and result, yet leave out the details that explain why results vary. Additional fields transform a simple log into an analytical tool.

Useful additions include spread at entry, slippage on entry and exit, time of day in UTC, session, news proximity, and the specific setup or signal used. Recording the planned stop and target, along with the actual exit reason, shows how often trades end as designed.

Another valuable field is a short rating of execution quality, noting whether the trade followed the plan. This allows separating strategy performance from discipline. Over weeks, filtering the journal by these fields reveals patterns invisible in aggregate statistics. For example, profits may concentrate in a single session, or losses may cluster after news. The effort of recording extra data pays off when decisions about what to trade and when can be based on evidence. A spreadsheet or database with consistent fields is sufficient.
Post Reply