Advertisement IC Markets

Using demo only for platform practice, never for cost estimates

Discuss 1-minute to 15-minute price action setups, fading intraday momentum, key support/resistance zones, and proven short-term trading methodologies.
Post Reply
LondonScalper
Posts: 965
Joined: Sat Sep 05, 2026 7:54 am

Using demo only for platform practice, never for cost estimates

Post by LondonScalper »

Demo for platform practice — never for cost estimates

Demo fills are polite. Live costs are not. I use demo to rehearse hotkeys, workspace layouts, and flatten paths under fake stress. I do not use demo expectancy to decide whether a scalp edge survives raw commission and slippage on a real book.

Desk split I insist on:
  • Demo: execution hygiene, layout, news-flatten drill, muscle memory.
  • Live tiny size: cost logging and emotional reality — including the urge to overtrade.
  • Only after a live cost sample do I discuss whether the setup is viable at normal size.
If your backtest or demo says the edge is obvious and live R-cost says otherwise, believe live. Polite fills are not a broker review; they are a different product.

How long do you run tiny live cost sampling before you trust a setup out of demo?

Demo can still be useful for rehearsing news flatten under a timer. Just never confuse rehearsal fills with a broker scorecard. Different physics, same buttons.
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Using demo only for platform practice, never for cost estimates

Post by Shadow Trader »

To answer the question directly, I count trades rather than weeks. My minimum is 60 live tickets on the setup at tiny size, and I want at least 20 of them in the exact session window I plan to trade at normal size.

The session split matters more than the total. Fifty tickets taken in calm midweek London will tell you nothing about what the same setup costs at 13:30 on a data day.

One caveat is that tiny size can mislead in both directions. At 0.01 lots some accounts charge a minimum commission per ticket, so the cost per lot looks worse than it will be at normal size.

At the other end, if normal size for you is several lots, tiny fills can flatter you a little. My slip on 0.05 lots was close to zero, while at 3 lots it averaged a few tenths of a pip on stop orders.

What's your threshold for scrapping a setup after the live sample? Mine is net expectancy under 0.1R after costs, even if the demo said 0.3R.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Using demo only for platform practice, never for cost estimates

Post by Shadow Trader »

LondonScalper, my scrap threshold is still net expectancy under 0.1R after costs, but the path to that number matters. I now compare three parallel samples before I trust or kill a setup: demo, tiny live, and a short burst at normal size.

On one EURUSD open drive the demo said plus 0.28R, tiny live said plus 0.14R, and twenty tickets at my normal 2 lot size said plus 0.09R after slip. The chart below is an illustration of those three readings on the same setup.
img_12565_r2.png
img_12565_r2.png (57.64 KiB) Viewed 305 times
Tiny size had flattered the fill quality, and demo had ignored costs entirely. Without the normal size burst I would have kept a setup that was already on the scrap line.

Sixty tiny tickets remain the minimum before that burst. I want twenty of them in the exact session window, then ten to twenty at real size before I decide.

How long is your tiny live sample before you try normal size? I used to wait for a calendar month and learned less than I do from a hard ticket count.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Using demo only for platform practice, never for cost estimates

Post by Shadow Trader »

Demo accounts run on the same platform but frequently on a different server setup. Orders there are commonly filled by the broker itself against the displayed quote, without passing through to a liquidity provider, so there is no market depth to consume and no rejection from outside parties.

That produces several flattering artifacts: little or no slippage, consistent fill times, and stops that execute at the trigger price even during fast moves. Live trading introduces queue position, last-look practices, variable spreads, and genuine counterparties who may reprice or decline requests.

Latency differs as well. Demo servers are often lightly loaded, so processing is quicker than on a production server handling thousands of simultaneous clients during a news release.

None of this makes demo useless. It remains good for testing platform mechanics, order logic, and code. The trouble comes from drawing conclusions about profitability from it, especially for scalping methods whose edge per trade is small and sensitive to execution costs.

A sensible bridge is a small live account used to measure real slippage, spread, and rejection rates, then feeding those measured costs back into demo or backtest assumptions. Even then, live conditions drift over time, so periodic remeasurement is useful.
Post Reply